Spiritual struggles drive psychological distress in psychotherapy: Replication of findings using a practice-research network.

Abstract

Longitudinal evidence indicates struggles with spirituality/religion (S/R; e.g., feeling distant or abandoned by God, guilty for not attaining standards of moral perfection, judged by one's family or community) may cause distress and hinder recovery from mental health challenges. However, research has not examined temporal associations between spiritual struggles and psychological distress in spiritually integrated psychotherapies (SIPs). In total, 175 practitioners of SIPs from 38 clinics and other settings in a practice-research network assessed these outcomes with 1,404 clients over the first 6 weeks of treatment (Time 1 [Weeks 1-2], Time 2 [Weeks 3-4], and Time 3 [Weeks 5-6]). In keeping with findings from other samples (e.g., Cowden et al., 2022, 2024; Currier et al., 2015, 2018), cross-lagged panel analyses across the three time points revealed spiritual struggles predicted clients' psychological distress at the next interval rather than vice versa. Specifically, whereas psychological distress was not predictive of later spiritual struggles, clients who were struggling with their S/R at Time 2 were generally more psychologically distressed at Time 3. Further, the positive prospective association between spiritual struggles at Time 1 and psychological distress at Time 3 was mediated by the severity of spiritual struggles at Time 2. In combination, these findings affirm spiritual struggles drive many clients' depression, anxiety, and other symptoms over the course of SIPs. As such, clinicians will ideally cultivate foundational knowledge and skills about the darker side of S/R that might prepare them to address their clients' spiritual struggles throughout the treatment process when clinically indicated. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2025 APA, all rights reserved).