Evaluating Hysteresis Patterns in Sap Flow of a Red Pine Forest Subjected to Different Variable Retention Harvesting Treatments

Abstract

Forests significantly influence regional and global water cycles through transpiration, which is affected by meteorological variables, soil water availability, and stand and site characteristics. Variable retention harvesting (VRH) is a forest management practice in which varying densities of trees, such as 55% and 33%, are retained after thinning or harvesting. These trees can be grouped together or evenly distributed. VRH aims to enhance forest growth, improve biodiversity, preserve ecosystem functions, and generate economic revenue from harvested timber. Application of VRH treatment in forest ecosystems can potentially impact the response of forest transpiration to environmental controls. This study analyzed the impacts of four different VRH treatments on sap flow velocity (SV) in an 83-year-old red pine (Pinus resinosa Ait.) plantation forest in the Great Lakes region in Canada. These VRH treatments included 55% aggregated (55A), 55% dispersed (55D), 33% aggregated (33A), and 33% dispersed (33D) basal area retention, and an unharvested control (CN) plot, 1 ha each. Analysis of counterclockwise hysteresis loops between SV and meteorological variables showed larger hysteresis areas between SV and photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) than vapor pressure deficit (VPD) and air temperature (T_air), particularly in clear sky and warm temperatures in the summer. It demonstrated that PAR was the primary control on SV across VRH treatments, followed by VPD and T_air. Larger hysteresis loop areas and higher SV values were observed in the CN and 55D treatments, with lower values found in the 55A, 33D, and 33A plots. This suggests that maintaining dispersed retention of 55% basal area (55D) is the optimal forest management practice that can be utilized to enhance transpiration and forest growth. These findings will assist forest managers and other stakeholders to adopt sustainable forest management practices, thereby enhancing forest growth, water use efficiency, and resilience to climate change. Additionally, these practices will contribute to nature-based climate solutions.