Intercropping of oat or mustard with legumes under organic management in the semiarid Canadian Prairie

Abstract

Intercropping, the growing of more than one crop at the same time within the same land area, could be a sustainable method of crop production in semiarid regions, which could increase biodiversity, and productivity and quality of crops compared to monocultures. This may be of significance under limited N, such as in organic agriculture, and could be an alternative to green manure. An organic study was conducted in the semiarid Canadian Prairie in drier than average years (2017–2018) to determine if intercropping legumes with non-legumes could reduce weeds and increase grain yield and quality of crops at different seeding rate ratios. Intercrops examined were lentil (Lens culinaris Medik.)–yellow mustard (Sinapis alba L.), and field pea (Pisum sativum L.)–oat (Avena sativa L.), at three seeding rate ratios, and their respective monocultures. Weed density was lower in the pea–oat intercrop than the pea monoculture, while weed biomass was lower in the lentil–mustard intercrop than the lentil monoculture. Legumes, when intercropped even at monoculture ratios, had lower aboveground biomass and grain yield than their monocultures, with pea showing higher tolerance than lentil to competition with its companion. Total biomass and grain yield were accounted for mostly by the non-legumes, which performed better than expected based on their seeding ratios. Mustard grown with lentil appeared to be more competitive than oat grown with pea. Grain weight of oat was higher in all intercrops with pea than in its monoculture, while grain protein of pea was higher when intercropped with oat than in its monoculture.