Sarah J. Boulton , Joshua N. Jones , Fatma S. Malcioglu , Aisling O'Kane , Matthew D. Cleave , Orestis Adamidis , Teoman Efeoglu , Yasemin Didem Aktaş
{"title":"Earthquake environmental effects and ESI 2007 of the 6th February 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquakes along the East Anatolian Fault Zone (Türkiye)","authors":"Sarah J. Boulton , Joshua N. Jones , Fatma S. Malcioglu , Aisling O'Kane , Matthew D. Cleave , Orestis Adamidis , Teoman Efeoglu , Yasemin Didem Aktaş","doi":"10.1016/j.quaint.2025.109804","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<div><div>The February 6, 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquake doublet resulted in a range of devasting impacts on the built and natural environments. Here the macroseimic intensity of the event is assessed using the Environmental Seismic Intensity Scale (ESI 2007), which considers a range of primary and secondary earthquake environmental effects (EEEs) resulting from the causative earthquakes. These features were documented as part of the hybrid Earthquake Engineering Field Investigation Team (EEFIT) mission and by numerous other studies in the aftermath of the earthquakes. The primary fault ruptures along segments of the East Anatolian Fault Zone exceeded 350 km along the Pazarcık segment (the first fault to rupture) with a maximum displacement (D<sub>max</sub>) of ∼8 m, and 150 km with a D<sub>max</sub> ∼7–8 m along the Çardak-Sürgü Fault, which subsequently ruptured later the same day in an event termed the Elbistan or Ekinözü earthquake. In addition, a range of other secondary effects such as landslides and rockfalls, liquefaction and lateral spreading, changes to springs, tsunami and widespread damage were reported over an area >35,000 km<sup>2</sup>. These data indicate epicentral intensities of XI and X for the Pazarcık and Elbistan earthquakes, respectively, consistent with the intensity inferred from measured offsets along these faults. Whereas site intensities based upon various secondary effects range from VIII – XI. Given the close association in time and space of the two main shock events it is difficult to attribute the wider off-fault secondary features to either event, especially where the faults converge in the north, but there is good correlation with: a) the mapped fault traces and many documented EEEs occur with 10–15 km of the rupture; and b) measured peak ground acceleration (PGA), where ESI 2007 intensities of > X correspond to regions experiencing >0.2 g PGA, and there are a few EEEs where PGA did not exceed 0.05 g. However, both maximum reported moment magnitude intensity (MMI) and Did You Feel It (DYFI) reports are 1–3° lower than the ESI 2007 values derived here, possibly resulting from bias towards urban areas. These data not only highlight the utility of using environmental effects in earthquake intensity studies but also suggest that the Kahramanmaraş earthquakes are unprecedented within the historical record of the region.</div></div>","PeriodicalId":49644,"journal":{"name":"Quaternary International","volume":"732 ","pages":"Article 109804"},"PeriodicalIF":1.9000,"publicationDate":"2025-04-27","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Quaternary International","FirstCategoryId":"89","ListUrlMain":"https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1040618225001478","RegionNum":3,"RegionCategory":"地球科学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q3","JCRName":"GEOGRAPHY, PHYSICAL","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
The February 6, 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquake doublet resulted in a range of devasting impacts on the built and natural environments. Here the macroseimic intensity of the event is assessed using the Environmental Seismic Intensity Scale (ESI 2007), which considers a range of primary and secondary earthquake environmental effects (EEEs) resulting from the causative earthquakes. These features were documented as part of the hybrid Earthquake Engineering Field Investigation Team (EEFIT) mission and by numerous other studies in the aftermath of the earthquakes. The primary fault ruptures along segments of the East Anatolian Fault Zone exceeded 350 km along the Pazarcık segment (the first fault to rupture) with a maximum displacement (Dmax) of ∼8 m, and 150 km with a Dmax ∼7–8 m along the Çardak-Sürgü Fault, which subsequently ruptured later the same day in an event termed the Elbistan or Ekinözü earthquake. In addition, a range of other secondary effects such as landslides and rockfalls, liquefaction and lateral spreading, changes to springs, tsunami and widespread damage were reported over an area >35,000 km2. These data indicate epicentral intensities of XI and X for the Pazarcık and Elbistan earthquakes, respectively, consistent with the intensity inferred from measured offsets along these faults. Whereas site intensities based upon various secondary effects range from VIII – XI. Given the close association in time and space of the two main shock events it is difficult to attribute the wider off-fault secondary features to either event, especially where the faults converge in the north, but there is good correlation with: a) the mapped fault traces and many documented EEEs occur with 10–15 km of the rupture; and b) measured peak ground acceleration (PGA), where ESI 2007 intensities of > X correspond to regions experiencing >0.2 g PGA, and there are a few EEEs where PGA did not exceed 0.05 g. However, both maximum reported moment magnitude intensity (MMI) and Did You Feel It (DYFI) reports are 1–3° lower than the ESI 2007 values derived here, possibly resulting from bias towards urban areas. These data not only highlight the utility of using environmental effects in earthquake intensity studies but also suggest that the Kahramanmaraş earthquakes are unprecedented within the historical record of the region.
2023年2月6日的kahramanmaraki地震对建筑和自然环境造成了一系列毁灭性的影响。在这里,使用环境地震强度量表(ESI 2007)评估事件的大地震强度,该量表考虑了由诱发地震引起的一系列初级和次级地震环境影响(eee)。这些特征被记录为地震工程现场调查小组(EEFIT)任务的一部分,并在地震后进行了许多其他研究。沿东安纳托利亚断裂带部分的主断层破裂沿Pazarcık段(第一个断裂的断层)超过350公里,最大位移(Dmax)为~ 8米,沿Çardak-Sürgü断层超过150公里,Dmax为~ 7-8米,随后在同一天晚些时候在称为Elbistan或Ekinözü地震的事件中破裂。此外,据报道,在35000平方公里的范围内发生了一系列其他次生影响,如滑坡和落石、液化和横向扩散、泉水变化、海啸和广泛的破坏。这些数据表明Pazarcık和Elbistan地震的震中强度分别为XI和X,与沿这些断层测量偏移推断的强度一致。而基于各种次生效应的场址强度范围为VIII - XI。考虑到两个主要冲击事件在时间和空间上的密切联系,很难将更广泛的离断层次级特征归因于任何一个事件,特别是在断层向北汇聚的地方,但与以下因素有很好的相关性:a)绘制的断层迹线和许多记录的eee发生在破裂的10-15公里处;b)实测峰值地加速度(PGA),其中ESI 2007年强度为>;X对应于经历0.2 g PGA的区域,并且有少数eee的PGA不超过0.05 g。然而,最大报告矩量级强度(MMI)和Did You Feel It (DYFI)报告都比这里得出的ESI 2007值低1-3°,可能是由于对城市地区的偏倚。这些数据不仅突出了在地震强度研究中使用环境影响的效用,而且表明kahramanmaraku地震在该地区的历史记录中是前所未有的。
期刊介绍:
Quaternary International is the official journal of the International Union for Quaternary Research. The objectives are to publish a high quality scientific journal under the auspices of the premier Quaternary association that reflects the interdisciplinary nature of INQUA and records recent advances in Quaternary science that appeal to a wide audience.
This series will encompass all the full spectrum of the physical and natural sciences that are commonly employed in solving Quaternary problems. The policy is to publish peer refereed collected research papers from symposia, workshops and meetings sponsored by INQUA. In addition, other organizations may request publication of their collected works pertaining to the Quaternary.