Knowledge-guided machine learning with multivariate sparse data for crop growth modelling

Abstract

Context

Process-based crop models are widely used to simulate the crop growth process. However, these models face limitations due to the simplified process representation and challenges in parameter estimation. Machine learning methods, as an emerging paradigm, have shown potential in circumventing these limitations, but they are criticized for their black-box nature that does not necessarily encompass known crop growth mechanisms, and their demand for big data that may be not available in most agricultural applications.

Objective

This research aims to propose a deep learning architecture that can leverage agronomic knowledge and sparse observational data for crop multivariable simulation, thereby establishing a novel paradigm for crop growth modeling.

Methods

We propose a Deep learning Crop Growth Model (DeepCGM) with a mass-conserving architecture that adheres to the principles of crop growth. Two additional knowledge-guided constraints regarding crop physiology and model convergence are designed to train the model with sparse datasets. An observational dataset from a two-year rice experiment of 105 plots is used to evaluate the DeepCGM against a process-based crop model (ORYZA2000) and two classical deep learning models, also employing augmentation methods. To demonstrate the validity and generalizability of the proposed model, we also conducted a replication case study of a three-year rice experiment totaling 122 plots.

Results

The DeepCGM architecture produces physically plausible crop growth curves for all simulated variables, while the classical machine learning models may make unreasonable predictions that violate the law of mass conservation. Furthermore, DeepCGM simulates more accurately the observed growth process when compared with the traditional process-based model, with overall accuracy (weighted normalized mean square error) across all variables improves by 8.3 % (2019) and 16.9 % (2018).

Conclusions

Knowledge-guided deep learning can integrate the principal mechanisms of crop growth process with deep learning. It addresses the issue of data scarcity, and thereby facilitating data-driven crop growth modelling with multivariable sparse datasets.

Implications

OR SIGNIFICANCE: This study highlights the potential of knowledge-guided deep learning to overcome structural error due to the simplification in conventional crop models and reduce the data requirements of data-driven models. The capacity to autonomously identify multivariable dynamic patterns in crop growth from sparse data suggests a new generation of crop growth models.