Expanding the Scope of Molecular Glues: TRIM21 as a Multimeric Protein Degrader

IF 10.7 Q1 MEDICINE, RESEARCH & EXPERIMENTAL
MedComm Pub Date : 2025-04-14 DOI:10.1002/mco2.70178
Kai Huang, Anqi Zhou, Xiangxiang Zhou
{"title":"Expanding the Scope of Molecular Glues: TRIM21 as a Multimeric Protein Degrader","authors":"Kai Huang,&nbsp;Anqi Zhou,&nbsp;Xiangxiang Zhou","doi":"10.1002/mco2.70178","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>In a recent study published on <i>Cell</i>, Lu et al. [<span>1</span>] introduce a novel targeted protein degradation (TPD) strategy that employs Tripartite motif-containing protein 21 (TRIM21), an E3 ligase activated through clustering, to achieve multimeric protein degradation with remarkable selectivity.</p><p>The field of TPD has expanded rapidly with the development of molecular glues (MGs) and proteolysis-targeting chimeras (PROTACs), which use E3 ubiquitin ligases to tag proteins for degradation [<span>2</span>]. However, current TPD methods rely heavily on E3 ligases such as Cereblon and Von Hippel–Lindau tumor suppressor, which are broadly expressed and lack conditional activity, posing challenges for selective targeting, especially in complex protein assemblies [<span>3</span>].</p><p>An additional challenge lies in selectively targeting multimeric proteins, which are often implicated in disease due to their aggregated forms, as seen in neurodegenerative disorders and certain cancers. Current TPD strategies typically lack the ability to distinguish between monomeric and multimeric forms of a protein, resulting in potential off-target effects and limited efficacy for diseases marked by aberrant multimerization. These limitations have highlighted the need for degraders that can selectively target multimeric assemblies with minimal impact on their monomeric counterparts, which may retain essential cellular functions.</p><p>The study focuses on (S)-ACE-OH, a metabolite derived from the antipsychotic acepromazine, which acts as a MG facilitating interaction between TRIM21 and the nuclear pore protein NUP98, leading to selective degradation of multimeric protein structures within the nuclear pore complex (NPC) (Figure 1). Specifically, the authors demonstrate that treatment with (S)-ACE-OH leads to the depletion of NPC subunits, as evidenced by proteomics analyses and transmission electron microscopy, which reveal structural disintegration of the inner NPC ring.</p><p>The researchers first identify (S)-ACE-OH as a MG that mediates an interaction between TRIM21 and NUP98, a protein critical to the integrity of the NPC. Using CRISPR-based screening, the authors confirmed TRIM21 as essential for the cytotoxic effects of (S)-ACE-OH, particularly under interferon-gamma conditions, which induce TRIM21 expression. Through a competitive cell growth assay in interferon-gamma-stimulated cancer cell lines, they observed that (S)-ACE-OH selectively targets multimeric NUP98-containing complexes, reducing cell viability by degrading the NPC's inner ring. Proteomic quantification demonstrated a significant reduction in NUP98 levels, underscoring the compound's potency. The work highlights how multimeric proteins, but not monomeric counterparts, induce the clustering of TRIM21, a mechanism necessary for activating TRIM21's E3 ligase function. This clustering-dependent activation serves as a unique mechanism for selectively degrading multimeric protein assemblies within the cell. Importantly, this approach offers a distinct advantage over previous TPD methods that primarily rely on monovalent binding mechanisms, which struggle to distinguish between monomeric and multimeric protein states.</p><p>A pivotal aspect of the study involved structural analyses of the TRIM21–(S)-ACE-OH complex. The researchers resolved cocrystal structures that reveal a key binding pocket within TRIM21's PRYSPRY domain, where (S)-ACE-OH binds to facilitate TRIM21–NUP98 interaction. Structural comparisons further revealed that the configuration of (S)-ACE-OH within this binding pocket is critical for complex formation with NUP98, as (R)-ACE-OH and acepromazine, though structurally similar, fail to engage TRIM21 similarly. This structural insight not only confirms the specificity of (S)-ACE-OH but also provides a foundation for engineering next-generation TRIM21-based degraders with enhanced selectivity for disease-relevant multimeric proteins.</p><p>The study then investigates the downstream effects of NPC degradation. By targeting NUP98 within the NPC, (S)-ACE-OH induces the degradation of specific NPC subunits, disrupting nucleocytoplasmic trafficking and leading to characteristic cellular changes. High-resolution microscopy and proteomics revealed that degradation initially impacts the NPC's inner ring, including proteins such as NUP35 and NUP155, while the outer ring and nuclear basket remain relatively intact. This selective degradation was confirmed through Western blot analysis and transmission electron microscopy, both showing a gradual collapse of the NPC architecture as TRIM21 initiates the degradation process. The authors suggest that TRIM21's modular structure, which positions its ubiquitin-binding RING domain at a distance from the PRYSPRY domain, enables it to ubiquitinate nearby proteins within the NPC, thus selectively dismantling the multimeric assembly.</p><p>Finally, the authors examined how mutations in NUP98 confer resistance to (S)-ACE-OH. Using CRISPR-suppressor scanning, they identified key residues within NUP98's autoproteolytic domain essential for (S)-ACE-OH-induced degradation. Mutations disrupting this domain impair TRIM21 recruitment to the NPC, effectively blocking (S)-ACE-OH's degradative action. To further probe the interaction between (S)-ACE-OH, TRIM21, and NUP98, the authors engineered an in vitro condensate assay that simulates multimerized interactions within the NPC. They found that (S)-ACE-OH specifically enriches TRIM21 in these condensates, confirming that clustering of multimeric structures is necessary for TRIM21 activation. This clustering effect, coupled with structural insights into (S)-ACE-OH's binding mode, underlines the potential of this MG to achieve precise and selective degradation of disease-relevant protein assemblies.</p><p>By showcasing a TRIM21-based degrader selective for multimeric proteins, the authors provide a new path for targeting complex protein assemblies in diseases like cancer and neurodegeneration. This clustering-dependent TRIM21 activation offers a precision that could be expanded to explore other E3 ligases that activate under specific structural conditions, broadening the therapeutic landscape for TPD. The unique ligandable pocket within the PRYSPRY domain opens possibilities for rational design of TRIM21-based degraders that might selectively regulate protein complexes in diverse cellular environments. Beyond the NPC, this system could potentially address pathological protein aggregations in diseases such as Alzheimer's, suggesting that targeted TPD could offer a novel approach to manage such conditions. Future work could involve systematic screening of MGs that enhance TRIM21 clustering or the development of engineered TRIM21 variants with optimized E3 ligase activity for specific multimeric substrates.</p><p>Recent preprints further expand our understanding of TRIM21-based MGs [<span>4, 5</span>]. Cheng et al. [<span>5</span>] demonstrate that the TRIM21–NUP98 interface can accommodate structurally diverse MGs, such as PRLX-93936 and BMS-214662, reinforcing the therapeutic potential of TRIM21 as an E3 ligase for targeting multimeric proteins. Meanwhile, Scemama de Gialluly et al. [<span>4</span>] identify PRLX-93936 and BMS-214662 as potent MGs that leverage TRIM21 to degrade nucleoporins, revealing their high cellular potency and potential clinical applications. These findings further highlight the versatility of TRIM21 in mediating targeted degradation beyond the originally identified (S)-ACE-OH compound.</p><p>This study also raises compelling questions about the limits of selective degradation—such as achieving context-specific activity without off-target effects—and invites further engineering of TRIM21 or similar ligases for broader applications. By advancing our ability to target multimeric proteins, Lu et al. [<span>1</span>] provide a conceptual shift in TPD, paving the way for new therapies that tackle the molecular foundations of complex diseases.</p><p>K. H. wrote the draft of the manuscript. A. Z. made the figure. X. Z. initiated the idea and edited the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.</p><p>The authors declare no conflicts of interest.</p><p>The authors have nothing to report.</p>","PeriodicalId":94133,"journal":{"name":"MedComm","volume":"6 5","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":10.7000,"publicationDate":"2025-04-14","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/mco2.70178","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"MedComm","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/mco2.70178","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"MEDICINE, RESEARCH & EXPERIMENTAL","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

Abstract

In a recent study published on Cell, Lu et al. [1] introduce a novel targeted protein degradation (TPD) strategy that employs Tripartite motif-containing protein 21 (TRIM21), an E3 ligase activated through clustering, to achieve multimeric protein degradation with remarkable selectivity.

The field of TPD has expanded rapidly with the development of molecular glues (MGs) and proteolysis-targeting chimeras (PROTACs), which use E3 ubiquitin ligases to tag proteins for degradation [2]. However, current TPD methods rely heavily on E3 ligases such as Cereblon and Von Hippel–Lindau tumor suppressor, which are broadly expressed and lack conditional activity, posing challenges for selective targeting, especially in complex protein assemblies [3].

An additional challenge lies in selectively targeting multimeric proteins, which are often implicated in disease due to their aggregated forms, as seen in neurodegenerative disorders and certain cancers. Current TPD strategies typically lack the ability to distinguish between monomeric and multimeric forms of a protein, resulting in potential off-target effects and limited efficacy for diseases marked by aberrant multimerization. These limitations have highlighted the need for degraders that can selectively target multimeric assemblies with minimal impact on their monomeric counterparts, which may retain essential cellular functions.

The study focuses on (S)-ACE-OH, a metabolite derived from the antipsychotic acepromazine, which acts as a MG facilitating interaction between TRIM21 and the nuclear pore protein NUP98, leading to selective degradation of multimeric protein structures within the nuclear pore complex (NPC) (Figure 1). Specifically, the authors demonstrate that treatment with (S)-ACE-OH leads to the depletion of NPC subunits, as evidenced by proteomics analyses and transmission electron microscopy, which reveal structural disintegration of the inner NPC ring.

The researchers first identify (S)-ACE-OH as a MG that mediates an interaction between TRIM21 and NUP98, a protein critical to the integrity of the NPC. Using CRISPR-based screening, the authors confirmed TRIM21 as essential for the cytotoxic effects of (S)-ACE-OH, particularly under interferon-gamma conditions, which induce TRIM21 expression. Through a competitive cell growth assay in interferon-gamma-stimulated cancer cell lines, they observed that (S)-ACE-OH selectively targets multimeric NUP98-containing complexes, reducing cell viability by degrading the NPC's inner ring. Proteomic quantification demonstrated a significant reduction in NUP98 levels, underscoring the compound's potency. The work highlights how multimeric proteins, but not monomeric counterparts, induce the clustering of TRIM21, a mechanism necessary for activating TRIM21's E3 ligase function. This clustering-dependent activation serves as a unique mechanism for selectively degrading multimeric protein assemblies within the cell. Importantly, this approach offers a distinct advantage over previous TPD methods that primarily rely on monovalent binding mechanisms, which struggle to distinguish between monomeric and multimeric protein states.

A pivotal aspect of the study involved structural analyses of the TRIM21–(S)-ACE-OH complex. The researchers resolved cocrystal structures that reveal a key binding pocket within TRIM21's PRYSPRY domain, where (S)-ACE-OH binds to facilitate TRIM21–NUP98 interaction. Structural comparisons further revealed that the configuration of (S)-ACE-OH within this binding pocket is critical for complex formation with NUP98, as (R)-ACE-OH and acepromazine, though structurally similar, fail to engage TRIM21 similarly. This structural insight not only confirms the specificity of (S)-ACE-OH but also provides a foundation for engineering next-generation TRIM21-based degraders with enhanced selectivity for disease-relevant multimeric proteins.

The study then investigates the downstream effects of NPC degradation. By targeting NUP98 within the NPC, (S)-ACE-OH induces the degradation of specific NPC subunits, disrupting nucleocytoplasmic trafficking and leading to characteristic cellular changes. High-resolution microscopy and proteomics revealed that degradation initially impacts the NPC's inner ring, including proteins such as NUP35 and NUP155, while the outer ring and nuclear basket remain relatively intact. This selective degradation was confirmed through Western blot analysis and transmission electron microscopy, both showing a gradual collapse of the NPC architecture as TRIM21 initiates the degradation process. The authors suggest that TRIM21's modular structure, which positions its ubiquitin-binding RING domain at a distance from the PRYSPRY domain, enables it to ubiquitinate nearby proteins within the NPC, thus selectively dismantling the multimeric assembly.

Finally, the authors examined how mutations in NUP98 confer resistance to (S)-ACE-OH. Using CRISPR-suppressor scanning, they identified key residues within NUP98's autoproteolytic domain essential for (S)-ACE-OH-induced degradation. Mutations disrupting this domain impair TRIM21 recruitment to the NPC, effectively blocking (S)-ACE-OH's degradative action. To further probe the interaction between (S)-ACE-OH, TRIM21, and NUP98, the authors engineered an in vitro condensate assay that simulates multimerized interactions within the NPC. They found that (S)-ACE-OH specifically enriches TRIM21 in these condensates, confirming that clustering of multimeric structures is necessary for TRIM21 activation. This clustering effect, coupled with structural insights into (S)-ACE-OH's binding mode, underlines the potential of this MG to achieve precise and selective degradation of disease-relevant protein assemblies.

By showcasing a TRIM21-based degrader selective for multimeric proteins, the authors provide a new path for targeting complex protein assemblies in diseases like cancer and neurodegeneration. This clustering-dependent TRIM21 activation offers a precision that could be expanded to explore other E3 ligases that activate under specific structural conditions, broadening the therapeutic landscape for TPD. The unique ligandable pocket within the PRYSPRY domain opens possibilities for rational design of TRIM21-based degraders that might selectively regulate protein complexes in diverse cellular environments. Beyond the NPC, this system could potentially address pathological protein aggregations in diseases such as Alzheimer's, suggesting that targeted TPD could offer a novel approach to manage such conditions. Future work could involve systematic screening of MGs that enhance TRIM21 clustering or the development of engineered TRIM21 variants with optimized E3 ligase activity for specific multimeric substrates.

Recent preprints further expand our understanding of TRIM21-based MGs [4, 5]. Cheng et al. [5] demonstrate that the TRIM21–NUP98 interface can accommodate structurally diverse MGs, such as PRLX-93936 and BMS-214662, reinforcing the therapeutic potential of TRIM21 as an E3 ligase for targeting multimeric proteins. Meanwhile, Scemama de Gialluly et al. [4] identify PRLX-93936 and BMS-214662 as potent MGs that leverage TRIM21 to degrade nucleoporins, revealing their high cellular potency and potential clinical applications. These findings further highlight the versatility of TRIM21 in mediating targeted degradation beyond the originally identified (S)-ACE-OH compound.

This study also raises compelling questions about the limits of selective degradation—such as achieving context-specific activity without off-target effects—and invites further engineering of TRIM21 or similar ligases for broader applications. By advancing our ability to target multimeric proteins, Lu et al. [1] provide a conceptual shift in TPD, paving the way for new therapies that tackle the molecular foundations of complex diseases.

K. H. wrote the draft of the manuscript. A. Z. made the figure. X. Z. initiated the idea and edited the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

The authors have nothing to report.

Abstract Image

Lu等人[1]最近在《细胞》(Cell)杂志上发表的一项研究介绍了一种新型靶向蛋白质降解(TPD)策略,该策略利用通过聚类激活的E3连接酶三方基序含蛋白21(TRIM21)来实现多聚蛋白降解,并具有显著的选择性。随着分子粘合剂(MGs)和蛋白酶解靶向嵌合体(PROTACs)的发展,TPD 领域得到了迅速扩展,它们使用 E3 泛素连接酶来标记蛋白质以便降解[2]。然而,目前的 TPD 方法在很大程度上依赖于 E3 连接酶,如 Cereblon 和 Von Hippel-Lindau 肿瘤抑制因子,它们表达广泛且缺乏条件活性,给选择性靶向带来了挑战,尤其是在复杂的蛋白质组合中[3]。目前的 TPD 策略通常无法区分蛋白质的单体和多聚体形式,导致潜在的脱靶效应,对以异常多聚化为特征的疾病疗效有限。这项研究的重点是(S)-ACE-OH,这是一种从抗精神病药物乙酰丙嗪(acepromazine)中提取的代谢物,它可以作为一种MG促进TRIM21与核孔蛋白NUP98之间的相互作用,从而导致核孔复合体(NPC)内多聚蛋白结构的选择性降解(图1)。具体来说,作者证明了用(S)-ACE-OH 处理会导致 NPC 亚基的耗竭,蛋白质组学分析和透射电子显微镜证明了这一点,它们揭示了 NPC 内环的结构解体。研究人员首先确定(S)-ACE-OH 是一种介导 TRIM21 和 NUP98 之间相互作用的 MG,NUP98 是一种对 NPC 的完整性至关重要的蛋白质。利用基于 CRISPR 的筛选,作者证实 TRIM21 对于 (S)-ACE-OH 的细胞毒性作用至关重要,尤其是在诱导 TRIM21 表达的干扰素-γ 条件下。通过在γ干扰素刺激的癌细胞系中进行竞争性细胞生长试验,他们观察到(S)-ACE-OH选择性地靶向含有多聚物NUP98的复合物,通过降解NPC内环来降低细胞活力。蛋白质组学定量分析显示,NUP98 的水平显著降低,凸显了该化合物的效力。这项研究强调了多聚蛋白(而非单体蛋白)如何诱导 TRIM21 聚合,这是激活 TRIM21 E3 连接酶功能的必要机制。这种依赖聚类的激活机制是在细胞内选择性降解多聚蛋白组合的独特机制。重要的是,与以往主要依赖单价结合机制的 TPD 方法相比,这种方法具有明显的优势,因为后者很难区分单体和多聚体蛋白质状态。研究人员解析的共晶体结构揭示了 TRIM21 PRYSPRY 结构域内的一个关键结合口袋,(S)-ACE-OH 与该口袋结合,促进了 TRIM21-NUP98 的相互作用。结构比较进一步发现,(S)-ACE-OH 在这个结合袋中的构型对于与 NUP98 形成复合物至关重要,因为(R)-ACE-OH 和乙酰丙嗪虽然结构相似,但却不能与 TRIM21 发生类似的结合。这一结构洞察不仅证实了(S)-ACE-OH的特异性,还为设计下一代基于TRIM21的降解剂奠定了基础,这种降解剂对疾病相关的多聚蛋白具有更强的选择性。通过靶向 NPC 内的 NUP98,(S)-ACE-OH 可诱导特定 NPC 亚基的降解,从而破坏核细胞质的运输并导致特征性的细胞变化。高分辨率显微镜和蛋白质组学显示,降解最初会影响 NPC 的内环,包括 NUP35 和 NUP155 等蛋白质,而外环和核筐则保持相对完整。这种选择性降解通过 Western 印迹分析和透射电子显微镜得到了证实,两者都显示了 TRIM21 启动降解过程时 NPC 结构的逐渐崩溃。作者认为,TRIM21的模块化结构使其泛素结合RING结构域与PRYSPRY结构域保持一定距离,这使其能够泛素化NPC内附近的蛋白质,从而选择性地拆解多聚体组装。最后,作者研究了NUP98的突变如何赋予(S)-ACE-OH抗性。 通过CRISPR抑制扫描,他们确定了NUP98的自蛋白水解结构域中对(S)-ACE-OH诱导降解至关重要的关键残基。破坏该结构域的突变会影响 TRIM21 招募到 NPC,从而有效阻止 (S)-ACE-OH 的降解作用。为了进一步探究 (S)-ACE-OH、TRIM21 和 NUP98 之间的相互作用,作者设计了一种体外凝结试验,模拟 NPC 内部的多聚体相互作用。他们发现,(S)-ACE-OH 在这些凝聚物中特异性地富集了 TRIM21,这证实了多聚体结构的聚集是 TRIM21 激活所必需的。通过展示基于 TRIM21 的降解器对多聚蛋白的选择性,作者为针对癌症和神经变性等疾病中的复杂蛋白组合提供了一条新途径。这种依赖聚类的 TRIM21 激活提供了一种精确性,可以扩展到探索在特定结构条件下激活的其他 E3 连接酶,从而拓宽 TPD 的治疗领域。PRYSPRY 结构域内独特的可配体口袋为合理设计基于 TRIM21 的降解器提供了可能性,这种降解器可以选择性地调节不同细胞环境中的蛋白质复合物。除鼻咽癌外,该系统还有可能解决阿尔茨海默氏症等疾病中的病理性蛋白质聚集问题,这表明靶向 TPD 可为控制此类疾病提供一种新方法。未来的工作可能包括系统筛选能增强 TRIM21 聚类的 MGs,或开发对特定多聚体底物具有优化 E3 连接酶活性的 TRIM21 工程变体[4, 5]。Cheng等人[5]证明,TRIM21-NUP98界面可以容纳结构多样的MGs,如PRLX-93936和BMS-214662,这加强了TRIM21作为E3连接酶靶向多聚蛋白的治疗潜力。同时,Scemama de Gialluly 等人[4] 发现 PRLX-93936 和 BMS-214662 是利用 TRIM21 降解核蛋白的强效 MGs,揭示了它们的高细胞效力和潜在的临床应用。这些发现进一步凸显了 TRIM21 在最初确定的 (S)-ACE-OH 化合物之外介导靶向降解的多功能性。这项研究还就选择性降解的局限性提出了令人信服的问题--例如在不产生脱靶效应的情况下实现特异性活性--这就需要对 TRIM21 或类似的连接酶进行进一步工程化,以实现更广泛的应用。通过提高我们靶向多聚蛋白的能力,Lu 等人[1]提供了 TPD 的概念转变,为解决复杂疾病分子基础的新疗法铺平了道路。A. Z. 绘制了图表。X. Z.提出了构思并编辑了手稿。所有作者均已阅读并批准最终手稿。作者声明无利益冲突。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
求助全文
约1分钟内获得全文 求助全文
来源期刊
CiteScore
6.70
自引率
0.00%
发文量
0
审稿时长
10 weeks
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信