A qualitative examination of how direct and indirect police violence shapes perceptions of police, sense of safety, and the mental health of Black adults in Chicago

Abstract

Police violence remains a significant public health issue, with detrimental effects on the mental health and well-being of Black communities. While public health research documenting the health consequences of police violence has been increasing, there has been considerably less qualitative research in this space. We conducted in-depth phenomenological interviews with 50 Black adults in Chicago to understand the mental health impacts of police violence. Data were analyzed using a team-based approach to thematic analysis. We developed several themes that demonstrate participants’ experiences: 1) direct and indirect exposure to police violence shaped perceptions of policing and feelings of safety; 2) police violence contributed to poor mental health and lack of trust in police; 3) Black women feared for the lives of their Black sons and male loved ones; and 4) individuals identified potential solutions, including racial concordance in policing and reduction or re-allocation of police investments. Overall, this study underscores the increased need for comprehensive police reform to address police violence and diverse representation of police. We also highlight the need for continued research to understand and address the implications of police violence, mental health, and community well-being.