Advancing health professions education: a review of holistic admissions and competency-based admissions practices.

Abstract

In this review, we gathered information about competency-based admissions and holistic admissions related to healthcare education to understand current practices better and offer recommendations within the healthcare education field. A literature search was conducted to gather peer-reviewed articles detailing information related to competency-based admissions and holistic admissions that have been implemented in healthcare education, including medical schools, nursing schools, dental schools, and other allied health fields. After screening and the addition of articles through ancestral search, 166 articles were included in this systematic review. The articles were coded for information related to definitions of competency-based admissions and holistic admissions, specific desired competencies, procedures to evaluate these competencies, outcomes of these practices, and the success of admitting well-prepared students using these practices. Results show there is wide variation in established definitions and desired competencies. Similarly, there was some variation in methods for evaluating these competencies with some common practices identified. Lastly, little evidence demonstrates the effectiveness of admitting students who are well-prepared for their programs when competency-based or holistic admissions are employed. There is a need for future research to establish a standard definition for both competency-based admissions and holistic admissions. Desired competencies should be established based on the program's mission and vision statements for what type of students they want to admit. Lastly, future research needs to focus on the long-term outcomes of implementing these practices.