Tom Bbosa, Dorothy Nakimbugwe, Christophe Matthys, Mik Van Der Borght
{"title":"A systematic review of zinc, iron and vitamin B<sub>12</sub> content of edible insects and comparison with dietary reference values.","authors":"Tom Bbosa, Dorothy Nakimbugwe, Christophe Matthys, Mik Van Der Borght","doi":"10.1017/S0954422425000071","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p><p>Entomophagy (eating edible insects) could potentially address human deficiencies of iron, zinc and vitamin B<sub>12</sub>. This article aims to summarise available evidence about the iron, zinc and vitamin B<sub>12</sub> content of raw and processed edible insects and compare these with the nutritional needs of different human life stages. A systematic literature search using specific keywords (edible insects, iron content, zinc content, vitamin B<sub>12</sub> content and nutritional composition) in Web of Science and Scopus databases was performed. Forty-six studies were reviewed. To ensure standardised comparisons, articles with nutrient-enriched edible insects were excluded. The quality of records was assessed using standardised protocols. Results indicate that edible insects are generally either 'sources of' or 'rich in' iron, zinc and vitamin B<sub>12</sub> required for optimal nutrition and health of different human life stages. Moreover, iron, zinc and vitamin B<sub>12</sub> contents of edible insect species were generally either comparable to or higher than that of (lean) beef, (lean) pork, poultry and kidney beans. Most insect species were oven processed with little/no species-specific data for other processing methods. Variations in micronutrient content existed between processing methods and among oven-processed edible insects. Data inaccuracies, poor data quality control and lack of insect-specific official analytical methods contributed to fairly high variations and made comparisons difficult. Based on available data, edible insects can potentially address human deficiencies of iron, zinc and vitamin B<sub>12</sub> despite the observed variations, data gaps and lack of edible insect matrix-specific official methods, in addition to limited human bioavailability and efficacy studies.</p>","PeriodicalId":54703,"journal":{"name":"Nutrition Research Reviews","volume":" ","pages":"1-17"},"PeriodicalIF":5.1000,"publicationDate":"2025-03-27","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Nutrition Research Reviews","FirstCategoryId":"3","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954422425000071","RegionNum":2,"RegionCategory":"医学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"NUTRITION & DIETETICS","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Entomophagy (eating edible insects) could potentially address human deficiencies of iron, zinc and vitamin B12. This article aims to summarise available evidence about the iron, zinc and vitamin B12 content of raw and processed edible insects and compare these with the nutritional needs of different human life stages. A systematic literature search using specific keywords (edible insects, iron content, zinc content, vitamin B12 content and nutritional composition) in Web of Science and Scopus databases was performed. Forty-six studies were reviewed. To ensure standardised comparisons, articles with nutrient-enriched edible insects were excluded. The quality of records was assessed using standardised protocols. Results indicate that edible insects are generally either 'sources of' or 'rich in' iron, zinc and vitamin B12 required for optimal nutrition and health of different human life stages. Moreover, iron, zinc and vitamin B12 contents of edible insect species were generally either comparable to or higher than that of (lean) beef, (lean) pork, poultry and kidney beans. Most insect species were oven processed with little/no species-specific data for other processing methods. Variations in micronutrient content existed between processing methods and among oven-processed edible insects. Data inaccuracies, poor data quality control and lack of insect-specific official analytical methods contributed to fairly high variations and made comparisons difficult. Based on available data, edible insects can potentially address human deficiencies of iron, zinc and vitamin B12 despite the observed variations, data gaps and lack of edible insect matrix-specific official methods, in addition to limited human bioavailability and efficacy studies.
食虫(吃可食用的昆虫)可以潜在地解决人类缺乏铁、锌和维生素B12的问题。本文旨在总结有关生食和加工食用昆虫中铁、锌和维生素B12含量的现有证据,并将这些含量与人类不同生命阶段的营养需求进行比较。在Web of Science和Scopus数据库中以特定的关键词(食用昆虫、铁含量、锌含量、维生素B12含量、营养成分)进行系统的文献检索。我们回顾了46项研究。为了确保标准化比较,排除了含有营养丰富的食用昆虫的文章。使用标准化方案评估记录的质量。结果表明,食用昆虫通常是人类不同生命阶段最佳营养和健康所需的铁、锌和维生素B12的“来源”或“丰富”。此外,食用昆虫种类的铁、锌和维生素B12含量普遍与瘦肉(牛肉、猪肉)、家禽和芸豆相当或更高。大多数昆虫种类都是用烘箱处理的,其他处理方法很少或没有特定物种的数据。不同加工方法和烤炉加工的食用昆虫微量营养素含量存在差异。数据不准确、数据质量控制不佳以及缺乏针对昆虫的官方分析方法造成了相当大的差异,使比较变得困难。根据现有数据,食用昆虫有可能解决人类铁、锌和维生素B12缺乏症,尽管存在观察到的差异、数据缺口、缺乏针对食用昆虫基质的官方方法,以及有限的人类生物利用度和功效研究。
期刊介绍:
Nutrition Research Reviews offers a comprehensive overview of nutritional science today. By distilling the latest research and linking it to established practice, the journal consistently delivers the widest range of in-depth articles in the field of nutritional science. It presents up-to-date, critical reviews of key topics in nutrition science advancing new concepts and hypotheses that encourage the exchange of fundamental ideas on nutritional well-being in both humans and animals.