An Automated Approach for Discriminating Hole Cleaning Efficiency While Predicting Penetration Rate in Egyptian Western Desert Wells

Abstract

Higher rate of penetration (ROP) indicates successful drilling operation but is not the only drilling success measure. However, Conventional ROP prediction methods focus on increasing ROP and neglect the hole cleaning state, which can be altered by ROP changes. Higher ROP in vertical and deviated wells may increase cutting concentration, leading to hole cleaning problems such as overpulling and stuck pipe. With this problem in mind, this paper utilized geological, rheological, and drilling data of 31 vertical wells across four oil fields located in the Egyptian Western Desert, developed intelligent ROP prediction model through back propagation neural network (BPNN), and compared the proposed BPNN results with an empirical model. Finally, the pattern recognition algorithms including discriminant analysis, support vector machines, and neural network pattern recognition (NNPR) were implemented to discriminate hole cleaning efficiency following the ROP prediction process. Recognition models were developed based on predicted ROP, bit wear rate, specific energy, and drilling fluid carrying capacity index to evaluate hole cleaning. The accuracy of the multi-strategy classifier was evaluated using area under curve, confusion matrix, and receiver operating characteristic. The BPNN model outperformed the empirical model in terms of linear correlation coefficient (R = 98.6%) and average absolute error (AAE = 5.5%). Additionally, the best classification performance was achieved using the NNPR algorithm with 91% accuracy and a cross-validation error equal to zero. For validity, the proposed approach predicted ROP and classified hole cleaning efficiency for new vertical well in adjacent oil field, resulting in a 6% improvement in ROP.