C. Warret Rodrigues, F. Wang, N. M. Halden, P. Yang, J. D. Roth
{"title":"How reliably do keratinous tissues predict total mercury concentration in internal tissues of a highly mobile carnivore with a terrestrial diet?","authors":"C. Warret Rodrigues, F. Wang, N. M. Halden, P. Yang, J. D. Roth","doi":"10.1111/jzo.13238","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p>Hair offers a non-invasive way to assess mercury exposure in diverse species, but variable and poorly understood molt patterns in wildlife may hamper the interpretation of tracer levels in hair. The reliability of using hair to precisely assess internal mercury burden, thus, varies across species, but few studies have assessed the reliability of using claw. Claws grow continuously, and growth rate may be easier to monitor than molt patterns. We quantified total mercury concentration (THg) in internal and keratinous tissues of 55 red foxes (<i>Vulpes vulpes</i>) legally harvested near Arctic tree line in Canada in winter (i.e., when mobility and opportunistic foraging are maximal) to compare the performance of hair and claw in predicting internal mercury burden, and examine the overall capacity of THg in keratinous tissues to predict internal THg at low exposure. Red foxes are widespread, occur at high densities and occupy a high trophic position, and thus could be a good sentinel species for monitoring mercury in the less-studied terrestrial food webs. We found generally low levels of THg in all fox tissues (range: 0.06 mg kg<sup>−1</sup> in brain to 1.13 mg kg<sup>−1</sup> in hair) indicating overall low contamination of this low-Arctic terrestrial food web. Relationships between THg of diverse internal organs were strong, but THg in both claws and hair were poor predictors of THg in internal organs. We thus advise caution when interpreting mercury levels in keratinous tissues of highly mobile species, as they may over- or underestimate the overall levels of exposure of a population because of non-continuous or seasonal growth. Adding a time component using segmental analysis of continuously growing keratinous tissues, or associating multiple tissues reflecting diverse timeframes and physiological processes, may offer a more accurate and complete understanding of toxicological risks.</p>","PeriodicalId":17600,"journal":{"name":"Journal of Zoology","volume":"325 2","pages":"102-114"},"PeriodicalIF":1.9000,"publicationDate":"2024-11-20","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/jzo.13238","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Journal of Zoology","FirstCategoryId":"99","ListUrlMain":"https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jzo.13238","RegionNum":3,"RegionCategory":"生物学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"ZOOLOGY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Hair offers a non-invasive way to assess mercury exposure in diverse species, but variable and poorly understood molt patterns in wildlife may hamper the interpretation of tracer levels in hair. The reliability of using hair to precisely assess internal mercury burden, thus, varies across species, but few studies have assessed the reliability of using claw. Claws grow continuously, and growth rate may be easier to monitor than molt patterns. We quantified total mercury concentration (THg) in internal and keratinous tissues of 55 red foxes (Vulpes vulpes) legally harvested near Arctic tree line in Canada in winter (i.e., when mobility and opportunistic foraging are maximal) to compare the performance of hair and claw in predicting internal mercury burden, and examine the overall capacity of THg in keratinous tissues to predict internal THg at low exposure. Red foxes are widespread, occur at high densities and occupy a high trophic position, and thus could be a good sentinel species for monitoring mercury in the less-studied terrestrial food webs. We found generally low levels of THg in all fox tissues (range: 0.06 mg kg−1 in brain to 1.13 mg kg−1 in hair) indicating overall low contamination of this low-Arctic terrestrial food web. Relationships between THg of diverse internal organs were strong, but THg in both claws and hair were poor predictors of THg in internal organs. We thus advise caution when interpreting mercury levels in keratinous tissues of highly mobile species, as they may over- or underestimate the overall levels of exposure of a population because of non-continuous or seasonal growth. Adding a time component using segmental analysis of continuously growing keratinous tissues, or associating multiple tissues reflecting diverse timeframes and physiological processes, may offer a more accurate and complete understanding of toxicological risks.
毛发为评估不同物种的汞暴露提供了一种非侵入性的方法,但野生动物的变化和对蜕皮模式的了解甚少,可能会妨碍对毛发中示踪剂水平的解释。因此,使用毛发精确评估体内汞负荷的可靠性因物种而异,但很少有研究评估使用爪子的可靠性。爪子不断生长,生长速度可能比蜕皮模式更容易监测。本研究对55只在加拿大北极林木线附近合法采集的红狐(Vulpes Vulpes)进行了体内和角质组织总汞浓度(THg)的定量分析,比较了毛发和爪子在预测体内汞负荷方面的表现,并考察了角化组织中THg在低暴露下预测体内THg的总体能力。红狐分布广泛,密度高,营养地位高,因此可能是监测研究较少的陆地食物网中汞的良好哨兵物种。我们发现所有狐狸组织中THg含量普遍较低(范围:大脑0.06 mg kg - 1至毛发1.13 mg kg - 1),表明这种低北极陆地食物网总体污染较低。各脏器THg之间的相关性较强,但爪子和毛发的THg不能很好地预测脏器THg。因此,我们建议在解释高度流动物种角状组织中的汞水平时要谨慎,因为它们可能过高或低估了由于非连续性或季节性生长而导致的种群总体暴露水平。通过对持续生长的角质组织进行分段分析来增加时间分量,或将反映不同时间框架和生理过程的多个组织联系起来,可以更准确、更全面地了解毒理学风险。
期刊介绍:
The Journal of Zoology publishes high-quality research papers that are original and are of broad interest. The Editors seek studies that are hypothesis-driven and interdisciplinary in nature. Papers on animal behaviour, ecology, physiology, anatomy, developmental biology, evolution, systematics, genetics and genomics will be considered; research that explores the interface between these disciplines is strongly encouraged. Studies dealing with geographically and/or taxonomically restricted topics should test general hypotheses, describe novel findings or have broad implications.
The Journal of Zoology aims to maintain an effective but fair peer-review process that recognises research quality as a combination of the relevance, approach and execution of a research study.