A Mixed-Methods Study Examining Guideline-Concordant Colposcopy Practices Among a National Cohort of US Colposcopists.

Abstract

Objectives: The 2017 ASCCP Colposcopy Standards guidelines were designed to maximize the diagnostic yield of colposcopy. However, guideline adoption is often slow, and few studies have examined management of patients undergoing colposcopy.

Methods: To elucidate factors associated with utilization of the 2017 ASCCP Colposcopy Standards guidelines for patients undergoing colposcopic cervical biopsy, the authors cross-sectionally surveyed and interviewed physicians and advanced practice providers who perform colposcopy. Clinicians responded to a clinical vignette describing a common colposcopy scenario. Clinicians were asked to describe where they would biopsy and why. Binomial logistic regression models determined factors associated with guideline concordance. Qualitative interviews further explored practice patterns.

Results: A total of 671 colposcopists participated from across the United States. A total of 541 (81%) participants reported colposcopy practice concordant with the 2017 ASCCP Colposcopy Standards guidelines. A total of 490 (73%) participants reported that they were using the 2017 ASCCP Colposcopy Standards guidelines. Male colposcopists and those who were internal and family medicine clinicians were less likely to report guideline-concordant management than females and obstetrician-gynecologists. Colposcopists discussed the rationale behind guideline-concordant aspects of care, including taking targeted biopsies and using excisional rather than ablation procedures.

Conclusions: Most colposcopists perform biopsies and treatment consistent with the 2017 ASCCP Colposcopy Standards guidelines and understand the rationale behind multiple targeted biopsies.