Comparison of carboplatin-based chemotherapy versus cisplatin-based chemotherapy in the treatment of malignant gonadal germ cell tumor: a systematic review and meta-analysis.

Abstract

To evaluate the role of carboplatin-based chemotherapy in patients diagnosed with malignant gonadal germ cell tumors (GCTs), we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis. We searched PubMed, MEDLINE, Embase, Cochrane library, and Web of Science. Randomized controlled trials or cohort studies on gonadal GCTs between January 1, 1970 and April 26, 2023 were enrolled. The treatment failure rate and mortality rate were the primary outcomes. Subgroup analysis based on the primary tumor site and dose of carboplatin was also conducted. In total, 8 studies with 1,409 patients were included. Compared to cisplatin-based chemotherapy, carboplatin-based chemotherapy had an increased treatment failure rate (odds ratio [OR]=2.23; 95% confidence interval [CI]=1.61-3.08; p<0.001), but similar overall survival outcomes (OR=1.68; 95% CI=0.61-4.61; p=0.315). Subgroup analysis revealed that carboplatin-based chemotherapy did not increase the risk of treatment failure and death in ovarian GCT, while a higher risk of treatment failure and a similar risk of death were observed in testicular GCT. Patients treated with high-dose carboplatin calculated 400 or 600 mg/m² (area under the curve=7.9) obtained similar failure-free survival to the cisplatin group (OR=0.84; 95% CI=0.40-1.73; p=0.629). Compared to the cisplatin group, milder nausea and vomiting, nephrotoxicity, ototoxicity, and more severe myelosuppression were observed in the carboplatin group. In conclusion, carboplatin-based chemotherapy achieves a comparable overall survival outcome to cisplatin-based chemotherapy in gonadal GCT patients, suggesting that carboplatin is a candidate substitute for cisplatin. The efficacy of carboplatin is dose-dependent. High-dose carboplatin can obtain better therapeutic effects with more tolerable toxicities than cisplatin.