Cai-Ming Liu, Rong Sun, Bing-Wu Wang, Fan Wu, Xiang Hao, Zhen Shen
{"title":"Correction to “Homochiral Ferromagnetic Coupling Dy2 Single-Molecule Magnets with Strong Magneto-Optical Faraday Effects at Room Temperature”","authors":"Cai-Ming Liu, Rong Sun, Bing-Wu Wang, Fan Wu, Xiang Hao, Zhen Shen","doi":"10.1021/acs.inorgchem.4c05545","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Page 12045. Because of the bias in the understanding of the formula <i>g</i><sub>MCD</sub> = 2(ε<sub>+</sub>(<i>B</i>) – ε<sub>+</sub>(−<i>B</i>))/(ε<sub>+</sub>(<i>B</i>) + ε<sub>+</sub>(−<i>B</i>)), the <i>g</i><sub>MCD</sub> values in the original paper were calculated with <i>g</i><sub>MCD</sub> = 2{Δε(<i>B+</i>) – Δε(<i>B–</i>)}/{Δε(<i>B+</i>) + Δε(<i>B–</i>)} = {Δε(<i>B+</i>) – Δε(<i>B–</i>)}/Δε in Figure 7(top), i.e., <i>g</i><sub>MCD</sub> = 2Δε(MCD)/Δε(CD), which may reflect the degree to which the Faraday effect of chiral compounds varies with the direction of the magnetic field. This formula is different from the common <i>g</i><sub>MCD</sub> = Δε(MCD)/ε. The paragraph “The anisotropy factor of MCD, <i>g</i><sub>MCD</sub> = 2(ε<sub>+</sub>(<i>B</i>) – ε<sub>+</sub>(−<i>B</i>))/(ε<sub>+</sub>(<i>B</i>) + ε<sub>+</sub>(−<i>B</i>)),<sup>92</sup> was calculated for both <span>l</span>-<b>1</b> and <span>d</span>-<b>1</b> (Figure 8), which have a roughly mirror symmetry in the 250–350 nm range. Notably, the values of <i>g</i><sub>max(MCD)</sub> for <span>l</span>-<b>1</b> and <span>d</span>-<b>1</b> at room temperature are 1.27 and −1.72 T<sup>–1</sup>, respectively, whose absolute values are remarkably large values, much larger than those of 3d–4f complexes [Co<sub>2</sub>Ln[(<i>R</i>)/(<i>S</i>)-L]<sub>4</sub>]·Cl<sub>5</sub>·2H<sub>2</sub>O·MeOH·EtOH (Ln = Gd, Dy) (0.02 T<sup>–1</sup>)<sup>45</sup> and 4f complexes (≤0.24 T<sup>–1</sup>).<sup>93</sup> The large absolute value of <i>g</i><sub>max(MCD)</sub> for the chiral Dy<sub>2</sub> enantiomers <span>d</span>-<b>1</b> and <span>l</span>-<b>1</b> indicates a very strong magneto-optical Faraday effect. Recent studies have shown that, for lanthanide (III) compounds, the strength of MCD can be enhanced by increasing the magnetic dipole moment of the ground states and the excited states. <sup>93</sup> The Dy(III) ion itself has a large magnetic moment (<i>S</i> = 7/2), and the ferromagnetic interaction between the two Dy(III) ions corresponds to large magnetic dipole moments of the ground state and the excited states; therefore, a strong magneto-optical Faraday effect for <span>d</span>-<b>1</b> and <span>l</span>-<b>1</b> appears as expected. This implies that they have potential application prospects in magneto-optical devices. By the way, because <i>g</i><sub>MChD</sub> and <i>g</i><sub>MCD</sub> are directly proportional,<sup>37</sup> it is possible for these chiral Dy<sub>2</sub> SMMs to have large <i>g</i><sub>MChD</sub> values.<sup>45</sup>” should be corrected as follows: Replacing Δε(CD) in <i>g</i><sub>(CD)</sub> = Δε(CD)/ε with Δε(MCD) gives <i>g</i><sub>(MCD)</sub> = Δε(MCD)/ε,<sup>92,93</sup> i.e., <i>g</i><sub>(MCD)</sub> = {Δε(<i>B</i>+) – Δε(<i>B</i>−)}/(2ε); the <i>g</i><sub>(MCD)</sub> values of <span>d</span>-<b>1</b> and <span>l</span>-<b>1</b> are calculated to be −5.68 × 10<sup>–5</sup> and −5.53 × 10<sup>–5</sup> (after being normalized to 1.0 T) at 303 nm, respectively, the |<i>g</i><sub>(MCD)</sub>| values are small because their corresponding <i>g</i><sub>(CD)</sub> values are small too (2.79 × 10<sup>–4</sup> and <i>–</i>2.65 × 10<sup>–4</sup>, respectively). For chiral molecular materials, the Δε(MCD)/Δε(CD) value means the increment percentage of the CD signal intensity in the presence of a magnetic field relative to the absence of a magnetic field. Therefore, such values at the CD signal peaks (in order to ensure that the measurement error is minimized) may reflect changes in the Faraday effect of chiral compounds.<sup>94</sup> The Δε(MCD)/Δε(CD) values at 1.6 T are −32.5% for <span>d</span>-<b>1</b> and 33.6% for <span>l</span>-<b>1</b> at 303 nm, suggesting that <span>d</span>-<b>1</b> and <span>l</span>-<b>1</b> have a strong magneto-optical Faraday effect. However, the |Δε(MCD)/Δε(CD)| values of <span>d</span>-<b>1</b> and <span>l</span>-<b>1</b> at 303 nm are smaller than those of <i>R</i>/<i>S</i>-[Mn<sub>10</sub>Dy<sub>6</sub>] (70% at 1.6 T) at 281 nm.<sup>94</sup> Figure 8 should be deleted accordingly. Page 12048. Reference 94: Wang, X.; Du, M.-H.; Xu, H.; Long, L.-S.; Kong, X.-J.; Zheng, L.-S. <i>Inorg. Chem.</i> <b>2021</b>, <i>60</i>, 5925. These corrections do not affect the overall findings and conclusions of the paper. We apologize for any confusion these errors may cause and appreciate the opportunity to correct them. We appreciate the understanding of the editors and readers. This article has not yet been cited by other publications.","PeriodicalId":40,"journal":{"name":"Inorganic Chemistry","volume":"3 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":4.7000,"publicationDate":"2025-01-15","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Inorganic Chemistry","FirstCategoryId":"92","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.inorgchem.4c05545","RegionNum":2,"RegionCategory":"化学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"CHEMISTRY, INORGANIC & NUCLEAR","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Page 12045. Because of the bias in the understanding of the formula gMCD = 2(ε+(B) – ε+(−B))/(ε+(B) + ε+(−B)), the gMCD values in the original paper were calculated with gMCD = 2{Δε(B+) – Δε(B–)}/{Δε(B+) + Δε(B–)} = {Δε(B+) – Δε(B–)}/Δε in Figure 7(top), i.e., gMCD = 2Δε(MCD)/Δε(CD), which may reflect the degree to which the Faraday effect of chiral compounds varies with the direction of the magnetic field. This formula is different from the common gMCD = Δε(MCD)/ε. The paragraph “The anisotropy factor of MCD, gMCD = 2(ε+(B) – ε+(−B))/(ε+(B) + ε+(−B)),92 was calculated for both l-1 and d-1 (Figure 8), which have a roughly mirror symmetry in the 250–350 nm range. Notably, the values of gmax(MCD) for l-1 and d-1 at room temperature are 1.27 and −1.72 T–1, respectively, whose absolute values are remarkably large values, much larger than those of 3d–4f complexes [Co2Ln[(R)/(S)-L]4]·Cl5·2H2O·MeOH·EtOH (Ln = Gd, Dy) (0.02 T–1)45 and 4f complexes (≤0.24 T–1).93 The large absolute value of gmax(MCD) for the chiral Dy2 enantiomers d-1 and l-1 indicates a very strong magneto-optical Faraday effect. Recent studies have shown that, for lanthanide (III) compounds, the strength of MCD can be enhanced by increasing the magnetic dipole moment of the ground states and the excited states. 93 The Dy(III) ion itself has a large magnetic moment (S = 7/2), and the ferromagnetic interaction between the two Dy(III) ions corresponds to large magnetic dipole moments of the ground state and the excited states; therefore, a strong magneto-optical Faraday effect for d-1 and l-1 appears as expected. This implies that they have potential application prospects in magneto-optical devices. By the way, because gMChD and gMCD are directly proportional,37 it is possible for these chiral Dy2 SMMs to have large gMChD values.45” should be corrected as follows: Replacing Δε(CD) in g(CD) = Δε(CD)/ε with Δε(MCD) gives g(MCD) = Δε(MCD)/ε,92,93 i.e., g(MCD) = {Δε(B+) – Δε(B−)}/(2ε); the g(MCD) values of d-1 and l-1 are calculated to be −5.68 × 10–5 and −5.53 × 10–5 (after being normalized to 1.0 T) at 303 nm, respectively, the |g(MCD)| values are small because their corresponding g(CD) values are small too (2.79 × 10–4 and –2.65 × 10–4, respectively). For chiral molecular materials, the Δε(MCD)/Δε(CD) value means the increment percentage of the CD signal intensity in the presence of a magnetic field relative to the absence of a magnetic field. Therefore, such values at the CD signal peaks (in order to ensure that the measurement error is minimized) may reflect changes in the Faraday effect of chiral compounds.94 The Δε(MCD)/Δε(CD) values at 1.6 T are −32.5% for d-1 and 33.6% for l-1 at 303 nm, suggesting that d-1 and l-1 have a strong magneto-optical Faraday effect. However, the |Δε(MCD)/Δε(CD)| values of d-1 and l-1 at 303 nm are smaller than those of R/S-[Mn10Dy6] (70% at 1.6 T) at 281 nm.94 Figure 8 should be deleted accordingly. Page 12048. Reference 94: Wang, X.; Du, M.-H.; Xu, H.; Long, L.-S.; Kong, X.-J.; Zheng, L.-S. Inorg. Chem.2021, 60, 5925. These corrections do not affect the overall findings and conclusions of the paper. We apologize for any confusion these errors may cause and appreciate the opportunity to correct them. We appreciate the understanding of the editors and readers. This article has not yet been cited by other publications.
期刊介绍:
Inorganic Chemistry publishes fundamental studies in all phases of inorganic chemistry. Coverage includes experimental and theoretical reports on quantitative studies of structure and thermodynamics, kinetics, mechanisms of inorganic reactions, bioinorganic chemistry, and relevant aspects of organometallic chemistry, solid-state phenomena, and chemical bonding theory. Emphasis is placed on the synthesis, structure, thermodynamics, reactivity, spectroscopy, and bonding properties of significant new and known compounds.