Conventional chemotherapy: millions of cures, unresolved therapeutic index

Abstract

In recent decades, millions of patients with cancer have been cured by chemotherapy alone. By ‘cure’, we mean that patients with cancers that would be fatal if left untreated receive a time-limited course of chemotherapy and their cancer disappears, never to return. In an era when hundreds of thousands of cancer genomes have been sequenced, a remarkable fact persists: in most patients who have been cured, we still do not fully understand the mechanisms underlying the therapeutic index by which the tumour cells are killed, but normal cells are somehow spared. In contrast, in more recent years, patients with cancer have benefited from targeted therapies that usually do not cure but whose mechanisms of therapeutic index are, at least superficially, understood. In this Perspective, we will explore the various and sometimes contradictory models that have attempted to explain why chemotherapy can cure some patients with cancer, and what gaps in our understanding of the therapeutic index of chemotherapy remain to be filled. We will summarize principles which have benefited curative conventional chemotherapy regimens in the past, principles which might be deployed in constructing combinations that include modern targeted therapies.