The Chronicles of 5G Non-Standalone: An Empirical Analysis of Performance and Service Evolution

Abstract

Fifth Generation (5G) systems have been commercially available worldwide for at least a couple of years, with mid-band Non-Standalone (NSA) being the deployment mode preferred by Mobile Network Operators (MNOs). Empirical analyses have provided so far key insights on 5G NSA performance from different perspectives, but most of these works consider short time periods to drive conclusions. In this paper, we investigate the evolution of 5G NSA considering deployment, performance, and services, including positioning. We perform a large-scale measurement campaign in two phases (2021 and 2023), covering six MNOs in two European countries, Italy and Sweden. Our results show significant differences in network deployment and performance, with increasing network density and frequencies but, at times, decreasing downlink throughput performance. For the latter, we identify worse radio coverage and connectivity issues as root causes. By using a standardized methodology, we also evaluate the performance of new services such as real-time gaming and augmented/virtual reality, and reveal that stable 5G connectivity is key to meet their requirements. Similarly, we highlight the negative effects of roaming on performance. Finally, we evaluate 5G fingerprinting positioning systems and show that a higher accuracy is achievable in denser 5G deployments.