Nurses’ Relational Leadership Struggles on Positioning in Strategic Hospital Crisis Management

Abstract

Aim(s): To understand how nurses experience their positioning amidst hospital crises.

Background: Nursing leadership literature is predominantly focused on the skills and competencies of nurses and less on the relations in practice with nurses. Nurses are often valued for bedside care but are overlooked in strategic decision-making during crises. Foundational research emphasizes the need for nurses’ equal participation in interprofessional healthcare practices and governance.

Methods: We conducted a qualitative interpretive interview and focus group study, amidst the COVID-19 crisis. We interviewed 64 chairs of nurse councils and deepened our understanding of our initial findings in four focus groups with 34 participants.

Results: Nurses differ widely on (a) what is important to them in crisis management, (b) how they can contribute to crisis management, and (c) how they value their involvement or lack of it. Furthermore, we uncovered three relational leadership struggles for nurses concerning (1) navigating, (2) positioning, and (3) collaborating, in crisis management structures.

Conclusion: The ailing positioning and representation of nurses in crisis management result from their limited participation in strategic decision-making, and the lack of intervention on this by board members, physicians, and managers.

Implications for Nursing Management: This study highlights the need for agents such as board members, managers, physicians, and nurses themselves to create clear frameworks and policies that define nurses’ roles in crisis situations, emphasizing the importance of addressing power dynamics and enhancing communication and collaboration in hospital settings. Effective crisis management requires involving nurses from the start, providing regular training, and promoting a more equal approach to teamwork. Understanding relational leadership and its impact during crises can empower nurses and improve overall hospital crisis response.