Impact of knowledge of HPV positivity on cervical cytology performance in latin america

Abstract

Background Cervical cytology is recommended by WHO as a triage option in HPV-based cervical cancer screening programmes. We assessed the performance of cytology to detect CIN3+ without and with knowledge of HPV positivity. Methods Women were screened with cytology and HPV across ESTAMPA study centres in Latin America. Screen-positives were referred to colposcopy with biopsy and treatment as needed. Cytology was initially interpreted without knowing HPV results. A subset of cytologies from HPV-positive women were re-interpreted at the same laboratories, with knowledge of HPV status, blinded to previous cytology and histological diagnosis. Performance indicators for cytology to detect CIN3+ without and with knowledge of HPV positivity were estimated. Findings A total of 4,087 women were included, of which 490 had histologically confirmed CIN3 + (455 CIN3 and 35 cancers). Cytology sensitivity without knowledge of HPV positivity for CIN3+ was 47.2% (95% CI: 42.5-51.9), whereas with knowledge of HPV positivity, the sensitivity was higher (58.9%, 95% CI: 54.2-63.5), p < .0001. The specificity without knowledge of HPV was 89.4% (95% CI: 88.2-90.5), while with knowledge of HPV positivity was 78.9% (95% CI: 77.4-80.4), p < .0001. Performance estimates varied by study centre for cytology without knowing the HPV positivity, (range from 32.8% to 61.5% for sensitivity; range 80.7% to 98.6% for specificity). Similarly, performance varied with knowledge of HPV positivity (36.1% to 93.4% for sensitivity; 39.6% to 98.6% for specificity). Conclusion The increase in sensitivity of cytology with HPV knowledge was limited and highly variable, reinforcing the need for alternative triage methods to support cervical cancer elimination goals.