A novel integrated testing strategy (ITS) for evaluating acute fish toxicity with new approach methodologies (NAMs)

Abstract

Acute fish toxicity (AFT) tests are performed in aquatic risk assessments of chemical compounds globally. However, the specific endpoint of in vivo AFT is based on the lethal concentration 50 (LC₅₀), which is a serious challenge in terms of animal welfare. To support the 3Rs principle of replacing, reducing, and refining use of animals, integrated testing strategies (ITS) have recently been developed for environmental risk assessment. ITS efficiently integrates multiple types of information, especially new approach methodologies (NAMs), and further supports regulatory decision-making. Currently, an effective ITS framework for evaluating aquatic toxicity is lacking. Therefore, we aimed to develop a promising ITS for AFT using in silico, in vitro, and in vivo data. We established the ITS via in silico (OECD QSAR Toolbox 4.6), fish cell line acute toxicity (FCT), and fish embryo acute toxicity (FET) tests and then validated the NAMs with AFT testing. The NAM data were derived from the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) dossier, toxicology databases, peer-reviewed research articles, and this study. For the first step in the ITS process, we aimed to design a high-throughput screening tool to identify non-toxic and toxic chemicals. We found that results of in silico, FCT, and FET tests alone were strongly correlated with AFT. Among the models, the in silico model was most suitable for identifying toxicants due to its high sensitivity and minimal animal use. Next, considering regulatory purposes and flexibility, we determined the predictive LC₅₀ of toxic chemicals by pursuing a preference-dependent strategy, sequential testing strategy, and sensitivity-dependent strategy. All the strategies demonstrated a predictive power equal to or greater than 73%. In addition, to meet user preferences, our ITS approach has high flexibility and supports animal welfare and environmental protection. We have therefore developed multiple powerful, flexible, and more humane ITS methods for acute fish toxicity assessment by integrating NAMs.