Diverse glacial ventilation in deep Pacific: An integrated record from Mariana Trench and Magellan Seamounts over the last 1.2 Myr [Global and Planetary Change, volume 230, November 2023, 104279]: Comment

Abstract

Yi (2023) proposed a new deep Western Pacific ventilation hypothesis using beryllium (¹⁰Be/⁹Be) and ²³⁰Th_ex dates, magnetostratigraphy, and element-based tuning data from two box cores and one gravity core. However, given the low sedimentation rates of these cores and uncertain stratigraphy, we suggest that some interpretations require further clarifications and corrections. The low sedimentation rates cast doubt on the validity of the millennial-scale western Pacific bottom-water oxygenation variability. The lack of unsupported explanations about the newly found periodicity in the Mariana Trench and Magellan Seamounts records raises concern about the confidence of the age models. The phasing between the North Atlantic deep water and Antarctic bottom water formation and atmospheric pCO₂ in the deep Western Pacific setting is unclear.