Comparison of Preimplantation Mouse Embryos with Different Genetic Backgrounds as Models for Evaluating Human Embryo Culture Media Composition.

Abstract

Can the best culture medium be determined by mouse embryo testing? Zygotes/embryos of four different mouse strains: inbred Balb/c (n = 79) and C57Bl/6 (n = 95), F1 hybrid DBA/2*C57Bl/6 (n = 133), and outbred ICR (n = 69) were incubated in vitro in four culture media: 1-Step Culture Medium (VitaVitro), CSC medium (Irvine Scientific), Sage 1-Step medium (Origio), G-TL medium (Vitrolife). The embryos were cultured under standard conditions at atmospheric oxygen: 37℃; 6% CO2, 100% humidity. Standard MEA-test parameters (number of expanded blastocysts on E4.5), as well as additional characteristics (embryo development on E2.5-E4.5, number of hatching and hatched blastocysts on E4.5, embryo arrest and degeneration) were assessed for each of the strain-medium combinations. The results were compared across strains as well as across media. Embryo development depended on both the media and the mouse strain. Embryos from inbred and outbred mice were more sensitive to suboptimal culture conditions compared to the hybrid strain; this was reflected in reduced blastocyst and hatching rates, as well as an increased percentage of arrested and degraded embryos. The choice of optimal media depended strongly on the strain: CSC was better for Balb/c, Sage 1-step for C57Bl/6, while both were preferred for hybrids, and G-TL for outbreds. VitaVitro was quite good for hybrids and performed worse for other strains. Overall, the embryos of each strain behaved differently in different media, and it was not possible to make a real preference for any of them over human embryos based on the results of any single mouse strain. Only a pooled sample of different mouse strains can be used for comprehensive media MEA testing. MEA testing with any strain of mice is doomed to error due to their specific culture requirements. Hybrid mice are too reproductively efficient and cannot be used to distinguish media based on their subtle differences. Outbred and inbred mice are too sensitive and may be delayed or degraded in culture media that is well suited to the requirements of human embryos. Combined analysis of multiple mouse strains should be used to test media more fully and may serve as a model for the heterogeneity of human embryos in IVF clinics.