Using an integrated motor imagery and physical training intervention after knee injury: an interim analysis of the MOTIFS randomised controlled trial.

Abstract

Objectives: Physical function is often a main focus of knee injury rehabilitation, but recent recommendations include increasing attention to psychological factors. We have developed the MOTor Imagery to Facilitate Sensorimotor re-learning (MOTIFS) training model which integrates dynamic motor imagery into physical rehabilitation. The objective is to report interim analysis results of an adaptive randomised controlled trial regarding the pre-defined continuation criteria.

Methods: Following a 12-week intervention in which participants were randomised to either MOTIFS or Care-as-Usual training, n=42 people undergoing rehabilitation for a traumatic knee injury were assessed for change from baseline to follow-up in psychological readiness to return to activity, using the ACL Return to Sport after Injury Scale (ACL-RSI), and side hop limb symmetry index. Continuation criteria included differences of ≥5 points in ACL-RSI and ≥8 points in side hop limb symmetry index in favour of the MOTIFS group. If these were not met, ≥5 points change in enjoyment was acceptable.

Results: Pre-defined continuation criteria were not met for ACL-RSI (mean difference -8.1 (SE 4.1)), side hop limb symmetry index (mean difference 4.4 (SE 7.8)), nor enjoyment (mean difference 3.9 (SE 4.5)), indicating that major modifications are required for continuation of the MOTIFS trial.

Conclusion: While results of this interim analysis did not show differences in psychological readiness to return to activity or side hop performance, previous research shows that the MOTIFS model is positive and enjoyable. Further research is warranted to evaluate more appropriate outcomes related to the holistic nature of physical and psychological readiness to return to activity.

Trial registration number: NCT03473821.