The effects of soft vs. rigid back-support exoskeletons on trunk dynamic stability and trunk-pelvis coordination in young and old adults during repetitive lifting

Abstract

While back-support exoskeletons are increasing in popularity as an ergonomic intervention for manual material handling, they may cause alterations to neuromuscular control required for maintaining spinal stability. This study evaluated the effects of soft and rigid passive exoskeletons on trunk local dynamic stability and trunk-pelvis coordination. Thiry-two young (18–30 years) and old (45–60 years) men and women completed repetitive lifting and lowering tasks using two different exoskeletons and in a control condition. Both exoskeletons significantly reduced the short-term maximum Lyapunov exponent (LyE) of the trunk (p < 0.01), suggesting improved local dynamic stability. There was also a significant main effect of age (p = 0.05): older adults exhibited lower short-term LyE that young adults. Use of the soft exoskeleton significantly increased, while the rigid exoskeleton significantly decreased, long-term LyE, and these changes were more pronounced in the young group compared to the old group. Additionally, exoskeleton use resulted in significant increase (p < 0.001) of mean absolute relative phase (MARP) and deviation phase (DP) by ∼30–60 %, with greater increases due to the rigid than the soft device. Thus, trunk-pelvic coordination and coordination variability were negatively impacted by exoskeleton use. Potential reasons for these findings may include exoskeleton-induced changes in lifting strategy, reduced peak trunk flexion velocity, and cycle-to-cycle variability of trunk velocity. Furthermore, although the soft and rigid devices caused comparable changes in trunk-extensor muscle activity, they exhibited differential effects on long-term maximum Lyapunov exponents as well as trunk-pelvic coordination, indicating that exoskeleton design features can have complex effects on trunk neuromuscular control.