Technical skills of endoscopic sinus surgery for performance assessment using the Delphi methodology.

Abstract

Background: In surgical residency, competence has traditionally been defined by a specified number of surgical procedures. Modern advances in medical education and surgical fellowships have challenged this approach. It is widely accepted that a definition of a skill set, enabling a systematic, competency-based assessment is mandatory in surgical education.

Methodology: We conducted an international Delphi study with panelists from the European Rhinologic Society, representing 27 countries. Through four rounds, the panel reached consensus on the phrasing of an assessment tool-, for the technical skills of endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS).

Results: Thirty panelists participated throughout the study. The median age of the panelists was 54 years (range 31-66 years) with a median experience of 25 years (range 6-40 years). All were experts in the field of endoscopic sinus surgery. Consensus was reached. The final assessment tool consists of 21 items with descriptive anchors.

Conclusion: The assessment tool, European Endoscopic Sinus Surgery â€" Technical Skills Assessment (EE-TSA), enables a competency-based approach to acquiring and maintaining essential elements of endoscopic sinus surgery. The international Delphi panel makes the tool internationally applicable. Further research should gather validity evidence for EE-TSA, enhancing the assessment of ESS by setting a pass/fail-standard ultimately improving surgical outcomes and patient safety.