Multivariable fragility surfaces for earthquake-induced damage assessment of buildings integrating structural features

Abstract

This study introduces three types of multivariable fragility surfaces, integrating effective structural features to improve damage assessment. The incorporation of additional information such as building occupancies, structural responses, and underlying soil types enhances the accuracy of conventional fragility curve predictions. Additionally, three modification factors are proposed to further refine conventional fragility curves and provide more precise predictions. The multivariable fragility surfaces are developed for eccentric brace frames modeled in Opensees software which is validated by experimental results and subjected to incremental dynamic analysis with 44 far-field ground motions. The influence of soil flexibilities on structural responses is incorporated through Winkler springs, representing soil-structure interaction. Diverse occupancies, such as hospitals, museums, and residential structures, are assessed using various peak floor acceleration thresholds and story drift ratios, employing multidimensional limit state functions to consider both structural and nonstructural losses. To account for uncertainties in structural responses and a single intensity measurement, a damage-sensitive feature derived from roof acceleration response, obtained through signal processing and system identification techniques, is introduced. The results for the proposed multivariable fragility surfaces indicate that the spectral acceleration corresponding to a 50% probability of exceedance could vary between 10.2 and 89%, in comparison to the corresponding conventional fragility curves. Finally, to evaluate the application of the enhanced fragility surface and modification factors, two instrumented EBF buildings, a 4-story EBF building, and a real 5-story hospital EBF, are selected as case studies. With additional details on soil types, occupancies, and structural responses, the process of employing modification factors resulting in enhanced fragility curves is demonstrated.