The optimal duration of continuous respiratory rate monitoring to predict in-hospital mortality within seven days of admission – A pilot study in a low resource setting

Abstract

Background

Currently there are no established benefits from the continuous monitoring of vital signs, and the optimal time period for respiratory rate measurement is unknown.

Setting

Low resource Ugandan hospital,

Methods

Prospective observational study. Respiratory rates of acutely ill patients were continuously measured by a piezoelectric device for up to seven hours after admission to hospital.

Results

22 (5.5%) out of 402 patients died within 7 days of hospital admission. The highest c-statistic of discrimination for 7-day mortality (0.737 SE 0.078) was obtained after four hours of continuously measured respiratory rates transformed into a weighted respiratory rate score (wRRS). After seven hours of measurement the c-statistic of the wRRS fell to 0.535 SE 0.078. 20% the patients who died within seven days did not have an elevated National Early Warning Score (NEWS) on admission but were identified by the 4-hour wRRS. None of the 88 patients whose average respiratory rate remained between 12 and 20 bpm throughout four hours of observation died within 7 days of admission. A simple predictive model that included the four-hour wRRS, Shock Index and altered mental status had a c-statistic for 7-day in-hospital mortality of 0.843 SE. 0.057.

Conclusion

Four hours of continuously measured respiratory rates was the observation period that best predicted 7-day in-hospital mortality. After four hours the discrimination of a weighted respiratory rate score deteriorated rapidly.