Persistent interactive effects of developmental salinity and temperature in Atlantic killifish (Fundulus heteroclitus)

Abstract

Climate change alters multiple abiotic environmental factors in aquatic environments but relatively little is known about their interacting impacts, particularly in developing organisms where these exposures have the potential to cause long-lasting effects. To explore these issues, we exposed developing killifish embryos (Fundulus heteroclitus) to 26 °C or 20 °C and 20 ppt or 3 ppt salinity in a fully-factorial design. After hatching, fish were transferred to common conditions of 20 °C and 20 ppt to assess the potential for persistent developmental plasticity. Warm temperature increased hatching success and decreased hatch time, whereas low salinity negatively affected hatching success, but this was only significant in fish developed at 20 °C. Temperature, salinity, or their interaction affected mRNA levels of genes typically associated with thermal and hypoxia tolerance (hif1a, hsp90b, hsp90a, hsc70, and hsp70.2) across multiple developmental timepoints. These differences were persistent into the juvenile stage, where the fish that developed at 26 °C had higher expression of hif1a, hsp90b, hsp90a, and hsp70.2 than fish developed at 20 °C, and this was particularly evident for the group developed at both high temperature and salinity. There were also long-lasting effects of developmental treatments on body size after four months of rearing under common conditions. Fish developed at low salinity or temperature were larger than fish developed at high temperature or salinity, but there was no interaction between the two factors. These data highlight the complex nature of the developmental effects of interacting stressors which has important implications for predicting the resilience of fishes in the context of climate change.