A prospective study of the acquisition of vaginal examination skills using simulation.

Abstract

Objective: To determine the number of sessions required using procedural simulation to acquire the skill of vaginal examination, which is an essential part of obstetrics, but a difficult learned skill.

Methods: Using a high-fidelity simulator, we conducted a prospective, single-center, single-blind study, at the Angers School of Midwifery. A class of students completed a theory course, and took part in three simulation sessions. During the simulation sessions, each student was asked to describe five different cervixes, under five criteria: position, length, consistency, dilation, and head station. Each participant received individual feedback as part of a debrief session, after completing their description. A pass rate of 80% was set for the entire class.

Results: Twenty-six students participated. The class achieved a mean score of 70.77 ± 10.23% in the first session, 81.85 ± 9.91% in the second session, and 81.23 ± 8.63% in the third session. There was a significant improvement only between the first and second sessions (P < 0.001). Of the 26 participants, 6 (23%) scored over 80% in the first session, 17 participants (65%) scored above 80% in the first two sessions, and 21 participants (80%) scored above 80% over the three sessions.

Conclusion: Learning vaginal examination by procedural simulation with the aid of a high-fidelity simulator, and receiving individual feedback and debrief, resulted in an 80% pass rate in two practical sessions, working to describe 10 cervixes.