Symmetry-free routing and spectrum assignment: a universal algorithm based on first-fit

Abstract

First-fit (FF) is a well-known and widely deployed algorithm for spectrum assignment (SA), but until our recent study [J. Opt. Commun. Netw.14, 165 (2022)], investigations of the algorithm had been experimental in nature and no formal properties of the algorithm with respect to SA were known. In this work, we make two contributions. First, we show that FF is a universal algorithm for the SA problem in the sense that, for any variant, 1) it can be used to construct solutions equivalent to, or better than, any solution obtained by any other algorithm, and 2) it can construct an optimal solution. This universality property applies to both the min-max and min-frag objectives and to variants of the SA problem with or without guard band constraints. Consequently, the spectrum symmetry-free model of our recent study [J. Opt. Commun. Netw.14, 165 (2022)] extends to all known SA variants, which therefore reduce to permutation problems. Second, we extend the spectrum symmetry-free model to the routing and spectrum assignment (RSA) problem in general topologies. This model allows for the design of more efficient algorithms as it eliminates from consideration an exponential number of equivalent symmetric solutions. By sidestepping symmetry, the RSA solution space is naturally and optimally decomposed into a routing space and a connection permutation space. Building upon this property, we introduce a two-parameter, symmetry-free universal algorithm that can be used to tackle any RSA variant in a uniform manner. The algorithm is amenable to multi-threaded execution to speed up the search process, and the value of the parameters can be adjusted to strike a balance between running time and solution quality. Our evaluation provides insight into the relative benefits of path diversity (which determines the size of the routing space) and connection diversity (which determines the size of the permutation space).