Comparison of time-to-detection of Mindray TDR and BacT/ALERT®3D blood culture systems using simulated blood cultures.

Abstract

Purpose: Blood culture (BC) is the standard for diagnosing bloodstream infections. Available blood culture (BC) systems have been developed to shorten the time to detection (TTD) of positive BCs. This study aimed to evaluate the performance of the Mindray TDR automatic BC system by comparing it with the BacT/ALERT®3D system.

Methods: Sixteen reference strains and 14 clinical isolates were used. Serial dilutions were prepared from all bacterial and yeast colonies with a final concentration of 100 CFU/ml and 10 CFU/ml. The prepared solutions were simultaneously inoculated into the bottles of both systems and placed in blood culture devices.

Results: Three hundred and fifty-two (176 BacT/ALERT®3D and 176 Mindray TDR-X060) blood culture bottles were evaluated, 336 aerobic and 16 anaerobic. At both 10 CFU/ml and 100 CFU/ml dilution, there was no significant difference between the two systems in terms of mean detection times for all isolates (p = 0.965, p = 0.245). When evaluated according to the type of organism, the detection time of gram-positive bacteria at 10 CFU/ml dilution was significantly shorter in the BacT/ALERT system (p = 0.019), whereas detection time for yeasts was significantly shorter with the Mindray system (p = 0.047). The number of anaerobic bacteria was too small to draw statistical conclusions, but we observed a trend of shorter detection times in the Mindray TDR-X060 system.

Conclusion: Two systems with similar operating principles showed different concentrations-dependent performances in terms of positivity detection times depending on the type of microorganism. Mindray TDR-X060 system has been found to be safe to use at high concentrations with this at lower concentrations further comparative studies are needed on the newly introduced Mindray system.