Inhibition of Clostridium perfringens and Bacillus cereus by Dry Vinegar and Cultured Sugar Vinegar During Extended Cooling of Uncured Beef and Poultry Products

Abstract

The 2021 FSIS Stabilization Guidelines for Meat and Poultry Products (Appendix B) Option 1.2 limits Phase 1 cooling from 48.8 to 26.7 °C in uncured meats to 1 h. However, this time restriction is impractical to achieve in large−diameter whole−muscle products. The objective of this study was to compare the inhibitory effect of commercial dry vinegars (DVs) and cultured sugar-vinegar blends (CSVs) on Clostridium perfringens and Bacillus cereus in uncured beef and poultry products during extended cooling. Treatments (beef: 72–73% moisture, pH 6.2–6.3, 0.85–0.95% NaCl; turkey: 76–77% moisture, pH 6.5–6.7, 1.3–1.6% NaCl) included Controls without antimicrobials, and four DV and four CSV, each tested at 0.75 and 1.25%. Batches were inoculated with 2.5-log C. perfringens or B. cereus spores, vacuum-packaged, and cooked to 73 °C. Packages were cooled from 48.8 to 27 °C (Phase 1) in 3, 4, or 5 h; Phase 2 (27–12.8 °C) and Phase 3 (12.8–4 °C) were standardized for 5-h cooling each. Pathogens were enumerated on selective agar in triplicate samples assayed at precook, postcook, and at the end of Phase 1, 2, and 3 cooling. Experiments were conducted twice. B. cereus did not grow (<0.5-log increase) in any treatment when Phase 1 cooling was extended to 5 h. C. perfringens grew rapidly (2.5 to >4.5 log) in Control treatments when Phase 1 cooling was extended to ≥3 h. All 1.25% DV ingredients limited C. perfringens growth to ≤1-log when Phase 1 cooling was extended to 3 h but supported a >1-log increase when Phase 1 cooling was extended to 5 h. All 1.25% CSV inhibited growth under 3-h Phase 1 cooling; 1.25% CSV-A and ≥0.75% CSV-D inhibited growth in turkey during 5-h Phase 1 cooling, but inhibition with 1.25% CSV-C was inconsistent in beef. This study revealed that formulating uncured meats with 1.25% DV or certain CSV can extend Phase 1 cooling to 3 h. Although all ingredients inhibited growth when used at 0.75% or greater compared to a control, greater variability of inhibition was observed among CSV than for DV.