Soil moisture and probe characteristics affect core integrity and soil test results

Abstract

Proper soil sampling is critical for accurate fertilizer recommendations. Samples collected in extremely wet or dry conditions may compromise the integrity of the sample and influence analytical results. We evaluated the effects of six soil moistures, two sampling depths (0–10 and 0–15 cm), and two soil probes on soil core uniformity and soil test results. Moisture treatments encompassed a range from dry (11.2%–18.5% moisture) to saturated conditions in Captina, Dewitt, Calhoun, and Calloway silt loam soils. Core depth and dry core weight were measured in all soils, and pH and Mehlich-3 extractable P, K, S, and Zn were assessed for Calhoun and Calloway soils. Soil moisture, probe, or their interaction influenced core depth and weight, while chemical properties were significantly affected only by soil moisture. Sampling very dry or saturated soils compromised the collection of uniform cores mainly for the 0- to 15-cm depth. Soil pH tended to increase with increasing moisture, but the mean values fluctuated only ±0.3 units. Across soils and depths, extractable S consistently decreased by 16%–48% as soil moisture at sampling time increased. Phosphorus was affected by soil moisture for 0–15 cm samples in both soils but showed no clear pattern. Soil moisture at the time of sampling affected soil test K for both soils and sample depths with individual cores varying up to 47 mg kg⁻¹ (i.e., 59–106 mg kg⁻¹). Greater soil test P and K variability occurred for very dry and wet conditions, which often prohibit collecting samples to the proper depth and could impact fertilizer rate recommendations.