Predictive factors for the outcome of radioiodine therapy in patients with benign thyroid diseases.

Abstract

Purpose: Radioiodine therapy (RIT) of benign thyroid diseases is an established therapy. This study aimed to identify factors predictive for outcome in patients with non-toxic goiter (NTG), unifocal (UFA), multifocal (MUFA) or diffuse autonomy (DISA) and Graves' disease (GD).

Methods: Retrospective analysis of 205 patients with benign thyroid disease (54 NTG, 46 MUFA, 24 DISA, 26 UFA, 55 GD) who underwent RIT. Follow up time was 12 months for determining treatment outcome.

Results: The type of disease was predictive for volume reduction after 12 months (NTS 66%, DISA 67%, MUFA 58%, UFA 51%, GD 71%, p<0.001) and post-treatment hypothyroidism (NTS 48%, DISA 33%, MUFA 15%, UFA 15%, p=0.006). Initial volume, intra-therapeutic uptake and intra-therapeutic half-life were independent prognostic factors for volume reduction 12 months after RIT. In patients with NTG, UFA, MUFA, DISA post-treatment hypothyroidism was significantly correlated with extent of volume reduction 12 months after RIT, achieved dose, higher pre-therapeutic TSH values and younger age. Two different strategies for pre-therapeutic dosimetry used in MUFA showed no differences regarding the therapeutic outcome. In GD, effective half-life, initial volume and Graves' ophthalmopathy were predictive for treatment failure.

Conclusion: Reduction of thyroid volume and the percentage of hypothyroid patients one year after RIT was primarily dependent on the type of disease. In MUFA and DISA we could identify volume reduction after 3 months as a reliable predictor for hypothyroidism while in patients with GD a short intra-therapeutic half-life, a large pre-therapeutic volume and active Graves' ophtalmopathy were relevant predictors for treatment failure suggesting an intensified follow-up scheme in these patients.