Pilot study on high-resolution radiological methods for the analysis of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) shunt valves

Abstract

Objectives

Despite their life-saving capabilities, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) shunts exhibit high failure rates, with a large fraction of failures attributed to the regulating valve. Due to a lack of methods for the detailed analysis of valve malfunctions, failure mechanisms are not well understood, and valves often have to be surgically explanted on the mere suspicion of malfunction.

The presented pilot study aims to demonstrate radiological methods for comprehensive analysis of CSF shunt valves, considering both the potential for failure analysis in design optimization, and for future clinical in-vivo application to reduce the number of required shunt revision surgeries. The proposed method could also be utilized to develop and support in situ repair methods (e.g. by lysis or ultrasound) of malfunctioning CSF shunt valves.

Materials and methods

The primary methods described are contrast-enhanced radiographic time series of CSF shunt valves, taken in a favorable projection geometry at low radiation dose, and the machine-learning-based diagnosis of CSF shunt valve obstructions. Complimentarily, we investigate CT-based methods capable of providing accurate ground truth for the training of such diagnostic tools. Using simulated test and training data, the performance of the machine-learning diagnostics in identifying and localizing obstructions within a shunt valve is evaluated regarding per-pixel sensitivity and specificity, the Dice similarity coefficient, and the false positive rate in the case of obstruction free test samples.

Results

Contrast enhanced subtraction radiography allows high-resolution, time-resolved, low-dose analysis of fluid transport in CSF shunt valves. Complementarily, photon-counting micro-CT allows to investigate valve obstruction mechanisms in detail, and to generate valid ground truth for machine learning-based diagnostics.

Machine-learning-based detection of valve obstructions in simulated radiographies shows promising results, with a per-pixel sensitivity >70%, per-pixel specificity >90%, a median Dice coefficient >0.8 and <10% false positives at a detection threshold of 0.5.

Conclusions

This ex-vivo study demonstrates obstruction detection in cerebro-spinal fluid shunt valves, combining radiological methods with machine learning under conditions compatible to future in-vivo application.

Results indicate that high-resolution contrast-enhanced subtraction radiography, possibly including time-series data, combined with machine-learning image analysis, has the potential to strongly improve the diagnostics of CSF shunt valve failures. The presented method is in principle suitable for in-vivo application, considering both measurement geometry and radiological dose. Further research is needed to validate these results on real-world data and to refine the employed methods.

In combination, the presented methods enable comprehensive analysis of valve failure mechanisms, paving the way for improved product development and clinical diagnostics of CSF shunt valves.