Repeated Early Holocene eruptions of Katla, Iceland, limit the temporal resolution of the Vedde Ash

Abstract

The Vedde Ash, originating from the Katla central volcano, Iceland, and taken to be dispersed across the North Atlantic and Europe at ~ 12 ka BP, is widely used as a geochronological marker. However, distal tephra layers with compositions like the Vedde Ash but of younger ages question the reliability of Vedde-like tephra layers as robust age control. Vedde-like tephra layers are rare in Icelandic sedimentary sequences and, where present, lack firm age control. Providing well-constrained local records of Early Holocene Katla layers is therefore critical to assess uncertainties related to the use of the Vedde Ash. Here we report three visible and stratigraphically separated Early Holocene Katla tephra layers from Torfdalsvatn, a lake in north Iceland, each with chemistry similar to the Vedde Ash. Using high-resolution ¹⁴C chronologies, we provide ages (± 1σ) for these tephra layers of 11,315 ± 180, 11,295 ± 195, and 11,170 ± 195 cal a BP. These observations reinforce that multiple explosive eruptions of Katla occurred over a 1000-year interval in the Early Holocene and challenge the precision of some paleoclimate records using the Vedde Ash as a geochronometer where age control is equivocal. This may lead to a re-evaluation of age models for some Early Holocene North Atlantic records.