{"title":"Urbanized Rural Women: A Study in Rural Areas of Gilan, Isfahan, and Semnan Provinces","authors":"Sohelia Alirezanejad, Nafiseh Azad","doi":"10.1080/19436149.2023.2267768","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Abstract:Considering the changing circumstances of Iranian rural women’s lives, do they still fulfill traditional roles? Have their lifestyles and expectations of themselves changed? To answer these questions, this long-term anthropological research was conducted in seven villages in three different and diverse provinces: Gilan, Isfahan, and Semnan. Our findings showed that some female roles in the villages have been eliminated or shifted to men due to developmental interventions. Women do not consider themselves in charge of the family’s economic activities. Instead, they tend to share the values of middle-class urban homemakers. They have pushed to abandon some of their traditional economic production roles, and consequently, they have lost access to financial resources and the public arena of the village. In a sense, they might have lost their bargaining power after some developmental interventions.Key Words: Iranrural developmentwomen AcknowledgmentsWe would like to express our sincere gratitude to the men and women in these seven villages who always welcomed us to their communities over the years. They kindly answered our questions and familiarized us with their situation.Disclosure StatementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Notes1 Iranian Population Indexes between Demographic indicators of Iran over time (1956–2016), Statistical Centre of Iran, Available online at: https://bit.ly/3HlPE98, Accessed May 14, 2022.2 H. Soroushmehr, M. Azami, N. Mehregan, & A. Yaghobi Farani (Citation2011) Investigation of Socioeconomic Status of Rural Women and Effective Factors on its Improvement (Case Study: Hamedan County), Rural Research, 1(1), pp. 141–163.3 H. Soroushmehr, M. Azami, N. Mehregan & A. Yaghobi Farani (Citation2018) The Role of Government Investments in the Sustainable Quality of Rural Life, Research & Rural Planning, 7(2), pp. 63–77.4 S. Moshiri, M. Mahdavei, & M. Sadegh Olyaye (Citation2009) The Impact of Literacy and Labour of Women in the Rural Households’ Income (A Case Study: The Divandareh Town, Kordestan Province), Geography and Development, 7(14), p. 71.5 F. Pasban (2006) Economic and Social Factors of Rural Women in Iran (1967 to 2004), Agricultural Economics and Development, 53 (14), pp. 153–176.6 F. Dadvarkhani. (Citation2006) Rural Development and Women’s Work Challenges in Iran, Geographical Researches, 53(38), p. 182.7 S. Alirezanejad & F. Banihashem (Citation2012) Gender and Development: A Glimpse on Demographic Changes in Iranian Rural Areas, Iranian Social Development Studies, 4(2), 81–93.8 E. SamAram (Citation2002) Re-socialization of Rural Women in the Process of Economic Development (Tehran: Office of Rural Women, Ministry of Jihad Agriculture), pp. 384–385.9 S. Sheibani (Citation2020) The Prominent Role of Women’s Employment in Reverse Migration to Villages Available online at: https://bit.ly/3Ho770V, accessed January14, 2023.10 S. Moshiri, M. Mahdavei, & M. Olyaye (Citation2009) The Impact of Literacy and Labor of Women in the Rural Households’ Income: A Case Study: Divandareh Town, Kordestan Province. Geography and Development, 7(14). p. 78.11 N. Azad (Citation2009) Differences and Similarities of Urban and Rural Poverty; A Gender Analysis, Master Dissertation, Tehran: Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch, pp. 93–97.12 E. Hooglund (Citation1997) Letter from an Iranian Village, Journal of Palestine Studies, 27(1), p. 78.13 M. Azkia & H. Imanijajarmi (Citation2011) Applied Methods; Grounded Theory (Tehran: Keyhan), pp.177–179.14 S. Leder (Citation2019) What does Male Out-Migration Mean For Women in Rural Sout Asia, Available online at: https://www.siani.se/news-story/what-does-male-out-migration-mean-for-women-in-rural-south-asia/, accessed June 3, 2022.15 V. Agadjanian, C. Menjivar & A. Sevoyan (Citation2007) Reshaping the Post-Soviet Periphery: The Impact of Men’s Labor Migration on Women’s Lives and Aspirations in Rural Armenia, In Annual meeting of Population Association of America, Available online at: https://paa2007.populationassociation.org/papers/71032, accessed April 27, 2022.16 C. Deere (Citation1985) Rural Women and State Policy: The Latin American Agrarian Experience, World Development, 13 (9), pp. 1037–1053.17 M. Grace & J. Lennie (Citation1998) Constructing and Reconstructing Rural Women in Australia: The Politics of Change, Diversity, and Identity, Sociologia Ruralis, 38(3), pp. 353–354.18 Brandth Berit (Citation2002) Gender Identity in European Family Farming: A Literature Review, Sociologia Ruralis, 42(3), p. 184.19 I. A. Morel, & B. Bock (Citation2008) Gender Regimes, Citizen Participation and Rural restructuring (Amsterdam: Elsevier), pp. 34–45.20 D. Kandiyoti (Citation1990) Women and Rural Development Policies: The Changing Agenda, Development and Change, 21(1), p. 19.21 Dadvarkhani, “Rural Development and Women’s Work Challenges,” p. 186.22 S. Shahshahani (Citation1997) The Necessity of Development, Sexual Balance of Work and Knowledge (Tehran: Ministry of Agriculture Publications), p. 200.23 Dadvarkhani, “Rural Development and Women’s Work Challenges,” p. 186.24 Azkia & Imanijajarmi (2011) “Applied Methods; Grounded Theory,” p. 198.25 SamAram, “Re-socialization of Rural Women in the Process of Economic Development,” pp. 384–385.26 A. Lahsaizadeh (Citation2005) A Study of Class Database of Rural Women in Iran (Tehran: Publications of Ministry of Agriculture), p. 58.27 In rural areas that are close to towns some residents usually chose to live there because they cannot afford the expenses of living in town.28 S. Alirezanejad (Citation2013) Saving or Spending Money: Women Making Decisions in Rural Iran, Journal of Middle East Women Studies, 9(1), pp. 115–117.29 Menarid Project’s report in Hamoon (Citation2012) Organizational Strengthening and Cohesion Report for Integrated Natural Resource Management, Unpublished hard copy.","PeriodicalId":44822,"journal":{"name":"Middle East Critique","volume":"76 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.8000,"publicationDate":"2023-10-20","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Middle East Critique","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1080/19436149.2023.2267768","RegionNum":3,"RegionCategory":"社会学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q2","JCRName":"AREA STUDIES","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Abstract:Considering the changing circumstances of Iranian rural women’s lives, do they still fulfill traditional roles? Have their lifestyles and expectations of themselves changed? To answer these questions, this long-term anthropological research was conducted in seven villages in three different and diverse provinces: Gilan, Isfahan, and Semnan. Our findings showed that some female roles in the villages have been eliminated or shifted to men due to developmental interventions. Women do not consider themselves in charge of the family’s economic activities. Instead, they tend to share the values of middle-class urban homemakers. They have pushed to abandon some of their traditional economic production roles, and consequently, they have lost access to financial resources and the public arena of the village. In a sense, they might have lost their bargaining power after some developmental interventions.Key Words: Iranrural developmentwomen AcknowledgmentsWe would like to express our sincere gratitude to the men and women in these seven villages who always welcomed us to their communities over the years. They kindly answered our questions and familiarized us with their situation.Disclosure StatementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Notes1 Iranian Population Indexes between Demographic indicators of Iran over time (1956–2016), Statistical Centre of Iran, Available online at: https://bit.ly/3HlPE98, Accessed May 14, 2022.2 H. Soroushmehr, M. Azami, N. Mehregan, & A. Yaghobi Farani (Citation2011) Investigation of Socioeconomic Status of Rural Women and Effective Factors on its Improvement (Case Study: Hamedan County), Rural Research, 1(1), pp. 141–163.3 H. Soroushmehr, M. Azami, N. Mehregan & A. Yaghobi Farani (Citation2018) The Role of Government Investments in the Sustainable Quality of Rural Life, Research & Rural Planning, 7(2), pp. 63–77.4 S. Moshiri, M. Mahdavei, & M. Sadegh Olyaye (Citation2009) The Impact of Literacy and Labour of Women in the Rural Households’ Income (A Case Study: The Divandareh Town, Kordestan Province), Geography and Development, 7(14), p. 71.5 F. Pasban (2006) Economic and Social Factors of Rural Women in Iran (1967 to 2004), Agricultural Economics and Development, 53 (14), pp. 153–176.6 F. Dadvarkhani. (Citation2006) Rural Development and Women’s Work Challenges in Iran, Geographical Researches, 53(38), p. 182.7 S. Alirezanejad & F. Banihashem (Citation2012) Gender and Development: A Glimpse on Demographic Changes in Iranian Rural Areas, Iranian Social Development Studies, 4(2), 81–93.8 E. SamAram (Citation2002) Re-socialization of Rural Women in the Process of Economic Development (Tehran: Office of Rural Women, Ministry of Jihad Agriculture), pp. 384–385.9 S. Sheibani (Citation2020) The Prominent Role of Women’s Employment in Reverse Migration to Villages Available online at: https://bit.ly/3Ho770V, accessed January14, 2023.10 S. Moshiri, M. Mahdavei, & M. Olyaye (Citation2009) The Impact of Literacy and Labor of Women in the Rural Households’ Income: A Case Study: Divandareh Town, Kordestan Province. Geography and Development, 7(14). p. 78.11 N. Azad (Citation2009) Differences and Similarities of Urban and Rural Poverty; A Gender Analysis, Master Dissertation, Tehran: Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch, pp. 93–97.12 E. Hooglund (Citation1997) Letter from an Iranian Village, Journal of Palestine Studies, 27(1), p. 78.13 M. Azkia & H. Imanijajarmi (Citation2011) Applied Methods; Grounded Theory (Tehran: Keyhan), pp.177–179.14 S. Leder (Citation2019) What does Male Out-Migration Mean For Women in Rural Sout Asia, Available online at: https://www.siani.se/news-story/what-does-male-out-migration-mean-for-women-in-rural-south-asia/, accessed June 3, 2022.15 V. Agadjanian, C. Menjivar & A. Sevoyan (Citation2007) Reshaping the Post-Soviet Periphery: The Impact of Men’s Labor Migration on Women’s Lives and Aspirations in Rural Armenia, In Annual meeting of Population Association of America, Available online at: https://paa2007.populationassociation.org/papers/71032, accessed April 27, 2022.16 C. Deere (Citation1985) Rural Women and State Policy: The Latin American Agrarian Experience, World Development, 13 (9), pp. 1037–1053.17 M. Grace & J. Lennie (Citation1998) Constructing and Reconstructing Rural Women in Australia: The Politics of Change, Diversity, and Identity, Sociologia Ruralis, 38(3), pp. 353–354.18 Brandth Berit (Citation2002) Gender Identity in European Family Farming: A Literature Review, Sociologia Ruralis, 42(3), p. 184.19 I. A. Morel, & B. Bock (Citation2008) Gender Regimes, Citizen Participation and Rural restructuring (Amsterdam: Elsevier), pp. 34–45.20 D. Kandiyoti (Citation1990) Women and Rural Development Policies: The Changing Agenda, Development and Change, 21(1), p. 19.21 Dadvarkhani, “Rural Development and Women’s Work Challenges,” p. 186.22 S. Shahshahani (Citation1997) The Necessity of Development, Sexual Balance of Work and Knowledge (Tehran: Ministry of Agriculture Publications), p. 200.23 Dadvarkhani, “Rural Development and Women’s Work Challenges,” p. 186.24 Azkia & Imanijajarmi (2011) “Applied Methods; Grounded Theory,” p. 198.25 SamAram, “Re-socialization of Rural Women in the Process of Economic Development,” pp. 384–385.26 A. Lahsaizadeh (Citation2005) A Study of Class Database of Rural Women in Iran (Tehran: Publications of Ministry of Agriculture), p. 58.27 In rural areas that are close to towns some residents usually chose to live there because they cannot afford the expenses of living in town.28 S. Alirezanejad (Citation2013) Saving or Spending Money: Women Making Decisions in Rural Iran, Journal of Middle East Women Studies, 9(1), pp. 115–117.29 Menarid Project’s report in Hamoon (Citation2012) Organizational Strengthening and Cohesion Report for Integrated Natural Resource Management, Unpublished hard copy.
摘要:考虑到伊朗农村妇女生活环境的变化,她们是否还在履行传统的角色?他们的生活方式和对自己的期望改变了吗?为了回答这些问题,这项长期的人类学研究在吉兰、伊斯法罕和塞姆南三个不同省份的七个村庄进行。我们的研究结果表明,由于发展干预,村庄中的一些女性角色已经被消除或转移到男性身上。妇女不认为自己负责家庭的经济活动。相反,他们倾向于分享城市中产阶级家庭主妇的价值观。他们被迫放弃了一些传统的经济生产角色,因此,他们失去了获得财政资源和村庄公共舞台的机会。从某种意义上说,在一些发展干预之后,他们可能失去了议价能力。关键词:伊朗农村发展妇女致谢我们向这七个村庄的男男女女表示衷心的感谢,多年来他们一直欢迎我们到他们的社区做客。他们友好地回答了我们的问题,并使我们熟悉了他们的情况。披露声明作者未报告潜在的利益冲突。注1伊朗各时期人口指标间的人口指数(1956-2016),伊朗统计中心,网址:https://bit.ly/3HlPE98, 2015年5月14日获取。2.2 H. Soroushmehr, M. Azami, N. Mehregan, A. Yaghobi Farani (Citation2011)农村妇女社会经济地位及其改善的有效因素调查(案例研究:H. Soroushmehr, M. Azami, N. Mehregan和A. Yaghobi Farani (Citation2018)政府投资在农村生活可持续质量中的作用,研究与农村规划,7(2),pp. 63-77.4 S. Moshiri, M. Mahdavei, M. Sadegh Olyaye (Citation2009)妇女识字和劳动对农村家庭收入的影响(以Kordestan省Divandareh镇为例),地理与发展,7(14),p. 71.5 F。Pasban(2006),伊朗农村妇女的经济和社会因素(1967 - 2004),农业经济与发展,53(14),页153-176.6 F。Dadvarkhani。S. Alirezanejad & F. Banihashem (Citation2012)性别与发展:一瞥伊朗农村地区的人口变化,伊朗社会发展研究,4(2),81-93.8 . E. SamAram (Citation2002)经济发展过程中农村妇女的再社会化(德黑兰:S. Sheibani (Citation2020)《妇女就业在农村逆向移民中的突出作用》,可在线查阅:https://bit.ly/3Ho770V, 2023.1月14日。S. Moshiri, M. Mahdavei, M. Olyaye (Citation2009)《识字和妇女劳动对农村家庭收入的影响:以Kordestan省Divandareh镇为例》。地理与发展,7(14)。p. 78.11 N. Azad (Citation2009)城乡贫困的异同;E. Hooglund (Citation1997)《来自一个伊朗村庄的信》,Journal of Palestine Studies, 27(1), p. 78.13 M. Azkia & H. Imanijajarmi (Citation2011)应用方法;李志强(Citation2019):《南亚农村地区男性外迁对女性的影响》,载于:https://www.siani.se/news-story/what-does-male-out-migration-mean-for-women-in-rural-south-asia/, 2012.06月3日。Agadjanian, C. Menjivar和A. Sevoyan (Citation2007),重塑后苏联外围:男性劳动力迁移对亚美尼亚农村妇女生活和愿望的影响,美国人口协会年会上,可在线查阅:https://paa2007.populationassociation.org/papers/71032, 2022.4月27日。M. Grace & J. Lennie (Citation1998)澳大利亚农村妇女的建构与重构:变革、多样性与认同的政治,《农村社会学》,38(3),pp. 353-354.18I. A. Morel, & B. Bock (Citation2008)性别制度、公民参与和农村重组(阿姆斯特丹:Elsevier), pp. 34-45.20 D. Kandiyoti (Citation1990)妇女和农村发展政策:不断变化的议程,发展和变化,21(1),p. 19.21 Dadvarkhani,“农村发展和妇女的工作挑战,”p. 186.22 S。