{"title":"El Trabajo Social Crítico","authors":"Carlos Montaño","doi":"10.29035/pai.5.2.8","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"espanolMucho se ha hablado, en nuestra profesion, de un Trabajo Social “transformador”, “revolucionario”, “popular”, “alternativo”. El analisis critico muestra que estas expresiones representan mucho mas un anhelo y un deseo, que una expresion de la realidad. Hoy hablamos de un Trabajo Social “critico”; pero no podemos con esto cometer los mismos errores, de imaginar que con un nuevo adjetivo podemos alterar el sentido historico de la practica profesional. Es preciso caracterizar claramente de que “critica” se trata cuando hablamos del Trabajo Social critico, y que lugar tiene la critica en el ejercicio (teorico, politico o practico) profesional. En este articulo analizaremos los sentidos de la critica y la critica radical en el Trabajo Social, en que consiste el Trabajo Social critico, y la posibilidad de una practica profesional critica. EnglishMuch has been said, in our profession, of a “transformative”, “revolutionary”, “popular”, “alternative” Social Work. The critical analysis shows that these expressions represent much more a yearning and a desire, than an expression of reality. Today we talk about a “critical” Social Work; but with this we cannot make the same mistakes, to imagine that with a new adjective we can alter the historical sense of professional practice. It is necessary to clearly characterize what “criticism” is when we talk about critical Social Work, and what place criticism has in the professional (theoretical, political or practical) exercise. In this article we will analyze the senses of criticism and radical criticism in Social Work, which is the critical Social Work, and the possibility of a critical professional practice.","PeriodicalId":431889,"journal":{"name":"Revista Pensamiento y Acción Interdisciplinaria","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2019-12-02","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"4","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Revista Pensamiento y Acción Interdisciplinaria","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.29035/pai.5.2.8","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 4
Abstract
espanolMucho se ha hablado, en nuestra profesion, de un Trabajo Social “transformador”, “revolucionario”, “popular”, “alternativo”. El analisis critico muestra que estas expresiones representan mucho mas un anhelo y un deseo, que una expresion de la realidad. Hoy hablamos de un Trabajo Social “critico”; pero no podemos con esto cometer los mismos errores, de imaginar que con un nuevo adjetivo podemos alterar el sentido historico de la practica profesional. Es preciso caracterizar claramente de que “critica” se trata cuando hablamos del Trabajo Social critico, y que lugar tiene la critica en el ejercicio (teorico, politico o practico) profesional. En este articulo analizaremos los sentidos de la critica y la critica radical en el Trabajo Social, en que consiste el Trabajo Social critico, y la posibilidad de una practica profesional critica. EnglishMuch has been said, in our profession, of a “transformative”, “revolutionary”, “popular”, “alternative” Social Work. The critical analysis shows that these expressions represent much more a yearning and a desire, than an expression of reality. Today we talk about a “critical” Social Work; but with this we cannot make the same mistakes, to imagine that with a new adjective we can alter the historical sense of professional practice. It is necessary to clearly characterize what “criticism” is when we talk about critical Social Work, and what place criticism has in the professional (theoretical, political or practical) exercise. In this article we will analyze the senses of criticism and radical criticism in Social Work, which is the critical Social Work, and the possibility of a critical professional practice.
在我们的职业中,有很多关于“变革”、“革命”、“大众”和“另类”社会工作的说法。批判性分析表明,这些表达更多的是一种渴望和欲望,而不是现实的表达。今天我们谈论的是“批判性”社会工作;但我们不能犯同样的错误,想象一个新的形容词可以改变职业实践的历史意义。在这种情况下,我们必须清楚地说明,当我们谈论批判性社会工作时,我们指的是什么“批评”,以及批评在专业实践(理论的、政治的或实践的)中的地位。在这篇文章中,我们将分析批判和激进批判在社会工作中的意义,批判社会工作是什么,以及批判专业实践的可能性。在我们的职业中,很多英国人都说过“变革”、“革命”、“大众”、“另类”的社会工作。The critical analysis节目这些expressions蒯庆华much more提供and a desire, than an expression of reality。今天我们谈论的是“批判性的”社会工作;but with this we不能make the same, mistakes to想象that with a new adjective we can alter the历史sense of professional practice。It is必要to一再characterize what“批评”is when we talk about critical Social Work, and what place批评声音你in the professional(理论、政治或practical)行使。在这篇文章中,我们将分析批评和激进批评在社会工作中的意义,即批判社会工作,以及批判专业实践的可能性。