{"title":"Ethical education: Ways of moral consciousness development (understanding experience through Tyumen ethical and philosophical tradition)","authors":"E. Yarkova, A. G. Ivanov, Y. Maltsev","doi":"10.17853/1994-5639-2022-6-11-40","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Introduction. The methodology of ethical education is an ever-relevant topic of research. This is due to the fact that the person’s moral consciousness is an extremely subtle matter; the ways of its development are complex and non-linear. The question “How should the process of ethical education be organised?” is of great concern to both theorists, who construct various models of ethical education, and, practitioners, who implement these models in life.A serious source of knowledge concerning the methodology of ethical education is the concept of the individual moral consciousness development, created by well-known ethicists A. Selivanov, V. I. Bakshtanovsky, Yu. M. Fedorov, who are the representatives of Tyumen ethical and philosophical tradition. The methodological ideas and principles proposed by the Tyumen ethicists can be regarded as a significant contribution to the development of modern ethical and pedagogical thought, aimed at overcoming both total relativism and total fundamentalism, by cultivating the principle of communication as a way of the individual moral consciousness development and as a method of ethical education.Aim. The aim of the present article is to represent the concepts of ethical education, developed within the framework of the Tyumen ethical and philosophical tradition; and also to comprehend their axiological and praxeological potential in relation to modern ethical education.Methodology and research methods. The methodological apparatus of the research is a synthesis of such approaches as: qualitative content analysis, hermeneutics, comparative studies, and also the theories of cognitive constructivism by J. Piaget, L. Kohlberg and communicative rationality by J. Habermas. Thus, this study is interdisciplinary, created at the junction of ethics, sociology of morals, and pedagogy.Results. The research results can be presented as follows: the models of ethical education created within the framework of the Tyumen ethical and philosophical tradition were reconstructed, which can be designated as the model of “development of the ability of true moral judgments” (F. A. Selivanov); the model of “shaping the ability of free choice and moral creativity” (V. I. Bakshtanovsky); the model of “immersion in the universe of morality” (V. M. Fedorov). The main methodological ideas were identified: the conjugation of the processes of the development of moral consciousness and a culture of thinking (F. A. Selivanov), the formation of moral consciousness through the actualisation of the opportunity to be a co-creator of public morality (V. I. Bakshtanovsky); the co-existence of man and the Cosmos (Yu. M. Fedorov). The main methods are presented: ethical and logical exercises (F. A. Selivanov), ethical-applied (business) games, humanitarian expertise (V. I. Bakshtanovsky), dialogue education, the implementation of a creative principle, the practice of freedom (Yu. M. Fedorov), etc.The novelty and practical significance of the study lies in the fact that the methodological concepts of ethical education proposed by the Tyumen ethicists are practically not studied and there is a very real danger of losing valuable experience for the development of modern ethical education strategies.","PeriodicalId":278157,"journal":{"name":"The Education and science journal","volume":"1 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2022-06-14","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"The Education and science journal","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.17853/1994-5639-2022-6-11-40","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Introduction. The methodology of ethical education is an ever-relevant topic of research. This is due to the fact that the person’s moral consciousness is an extremely subtle matter; the ways of its development are complex and non-linear. The question “How should the process of ethical education be organised?” is of great concern to both theorists, who construct various models of ethical education, and, practitioners, who implement these models in life.A serious source of knowledge concerning the methodology of ethical education is the concept of the individual moral consciousness development, created by well-known ethicists A. Selivanov, V. I. Bakshtanovsky, Yu. M. Fedorov, who are the representatives of Tyumen ethical and philosophical tradition. The methodological ideas and principles proposed by the Tyumen ethicists can be regarded as a significant contribution to the development of modern ethical and pedagogical thought, aimed at overcoming both total relativism and total fundamentalism, by cultivating the principle of communication as a way of the individual moral consciousness development and as a method of ethical education.Aim. The aim of the present article is to represent the concepts of ethical education, developed within the framework of the Tyumen ethical and philosophical tradition; and also to comprehend their axiological and praxeological potential in relation to modern ethical education.Methodology and research methods. The methodological apparatus of the research is a synthesis of such approaches as: qualitative content analysis, hermeneutics, comparative studies, and also the theories of cognitive constructivism by J. Piaget, L. Kohlberg and communicative rationality by J. Habermas. Thus, this study is interdisciplinary, created at the junction of ethics, sociology of morals, and pedagogy.Results. The research results can be presented as follows: the models of ethical education created within the framework of the Tyumen ethical and philosophical tradition were reconstructed, which can be designated as the model of “development of the ability of true moral judgments” (F. A. Selivanov); the model of “shaping the ability of free choice and moral creativity” (V. I. Bakshtanovsky); the model of “immersion in the universe of morality” (V. M. Fedorov). The main methodological ideas were identified: the conjugation of the processes of the development of moral consciousness and a culture of thinking (F. A. Selivanov), the formation of moral consciousness through the actualisation of the opportunity to be a co-creator of public morality (V. I. Bakshtanovsky); the co-existence of man and the Cosmos (Yu. M. Fedorov). The main methods are presented: ethical and logical exercises (F. A. Selivanov), ethical-applied (business) games, humanitarian expertise (V. I. Bakshtanovsky), dialogue education, the implementation of a creative principle, the practice of freedom (Yu. M. Fedorov), etc.The novelty and practical significance of the study lies in the fact that the methodological concepts of ethical education proposed by the Tyumen ethicists are practically not studied and there is a very real danger of losing valuable experience for the development of modern ethical education strategies.
介绍。伦理教育的方法论是一个始终相关的研究课题。这是因为人的道德意识是一件极其微妙的事情;其发展方式是复杂的、非线性的。“如何组织道德教育的过程?”既是构建各种伦理教育模式的理论家,也是在生活中实施这些模式的实践者所关注的问题。关于伦理教育方法论的一个重要知识来源是由著名伦理学家A. Selivanov、V. I. Bakshtanovsky、Yu所提出的个体道德意识发展的概念。费多罗夫先生,他们是秋明伦理和哲学传统的代表。秋明伦理学家所提出的方法论思想和原则,是对现代伦理教育思想发展的重大贡献,旨在克服完全相对主义和完全原教旨主义,将交往原则培育为个体道德意识发展的途径和伦理教育的方法。本文的目的是代表伦理教育的概念,在秋明伦理和哲学传统的框架内发展;并了解它们在现代伦理教育中的价值论和行为学潜力。方法论和研究方法。本研究的方法论是综合了定性内容分析、解释学、比较研究等方法,以及皮亚杰、科尔伯格的认知建构主义理论和哈贝马斯的交往理性理论。因此,本研究是跨学科的,建立在伦理学,道德社会学和教育学的交界处。研究结果如下:重构秋明伦理哲学传统框架下的伦理教育模式,可称之为“真正道德判断能力的发展”模式(F. A. Selivanov);“塑造自由选择能力和道德创造力”的模式(v·i·巴克什塔诺夫斯基);“沉浸在道德世界里”的模式(v·m·费多罗夫)。确定了主要的方法论思想:道德意识的发展过程与思维文化的结合(F. a . Selivanov),通过实现成为公共道德的共同创造者的机会来形成道德意识(V. I. Bakshtanovsky);人与宇宙的共存(余)。m . Fedorov)。提出了主要的方法:伦理和逻辑练习(F. a . Selivanov),伦理应用(商业)游戏,人道主义专业知识(V. I. Bakshtanovsky),对话教育,创造性原则的实施,自由的实践(Yu。本研究的新颖性和现实意义在于,秋明伦理学家提出的伦理教育方法论概念在实践中没有得到研究,很有可能失去现代伦理教育战略发展的宝贵经验。