Comparison of Collagen-coated Polyethylene Terephthalate Disc Plate and Shell Vial Culture Method for the Isolation of Chlamydophila pneumoniae

Abstract

Background: Chlamydophila pneumoniae is one of the major respiratory infectious pathogens and can be accurately diagnosed by cell culturing. The author performed this study to compare the usefulness of the collagen-coated polyethylene terephthalate (PET) disc culture method and that of the shell vial method. Methods: Twenty-nine sputums and 17 blood specimens collected from 46 patients for C. pneumoniae culture were inoculated into HeLa-229 cell monolayers cultured in shell vials and polyester plates. After incubation, they were stained using the indirect immunofluorescent method with genus-specific FITC-conjugated anti-chlamydia antibody. When both results were inconsistent, microimmunofluorescence results were used. Results: HeLa-229 cells successfully formed monolayers in shell vials and collagen-coated PET plates in all cases. Positive inclusion bodies in HeLa-229 cells of shell vials and PET plates for C. pneumoniae culture were similarly stained with the indirect immunofluorescent method. Both methods showed consistent results with 20 positive and 22 negative cases. The total agreement between the PET plate and shell vial was excellent (91.3%, k=0.826). Conclusion: The collagen-coated PET disc culture method showed highly consistent results with that of the shell vial method, and no technical differences were experienced between the two methods. Therefore, the author concluded that the shell vial method could be replaced by the PET plate method for detection of C. pneumoniae. (Korean J Clin Microbiol 2010;13:73-78)