Alexandra S Koutsoubis, Emily Fishbein, Megan Stobart-Gallagher, Behzad B Pavri, Jennifer White
{"title":"一种基于模块的急诊住院医师心电图解读教学新方法。","authors":"Alexandra S Koutsoubis, Emily Fishbein, Megan Stobart-Gallagher, Behzad B Pavri, Jennifer White","doi":"10.21980/J8Z06J","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p><strong>Audience: </strong>This online learning module is designed for PGY 1-3 emergency medicine (EM) residents.</p><p><strong>Introduction: </strong>Interpretation of the 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) is an essential skill for EM residents. The traditional approach to ECG interpretation in medical school is primarily didactic, teaching: \"rate, rhythm, axis,\" etc. Throughout residency, EM residents continue to receive lectures and practical ECG teaching to independently interpret ECGs with accuracy and efficiency. In addition to basic rhythm interpretation, physicians must be able to identify cardiac ischemia, abnormal rhythms, and subtle ECG findings that could herald sudden death.1 Life-threatening diagnoses such as digitalis toxicity or hyperkalemia can be made promptly through ECG evaluation and catastrophic if missed. If correctly diagnosed through ECG, many channelopathies can be treated and cardiac events can be prevented.2,3 Lecture-based learning is a necessary part of medical education, but there is a need to supplement the traditional teaching approach with online learning modules. Online learning modules provide learners with an accessible and efficient tool that allows them to improve their ECG skills on their own time.</p><p><strong>Educational objectives: </strong>After completion of the module learners should be able to: 1) correctly recognize and identify ECG abnormalities including but not limited to abnormal or absent P waves, widened QRS intervals, ST elevations, abnormal QT intervals, and dysrhythmias that can lead to sudden cardiac death; and 2) synthesize findings into a succinct but accurate interpretation of the ECG findings.</p><p><strong>Educational methods: </strong>An online module was developed using Articulate 360 and was implemented with EM residents. The module covers common ECG findings seen in the emergency department including ischemia, atrioventricular blocks, and bundle branch blocks. The module uniquely emphasizes ECG findings of arrythmias that could lead to sudden cardiac death and highlights that diagnosing sudden cardiac death syndromes relies on both clinical presentation and specific ECG findings. Online modules have proven to be as effective as lecture-based learning at improving ECG interpretation among healthcare professionals and are convenient and easily accessible to the busy EM resident.4,5 Additionally, the module is self-paced, can be completed at any time, and includes elements of active learning by incorporating knowledge checks throughout. This allows learners in real time to see where individualized improvement is needed. The ease of embedment of self-paced questions into the module is one of the salient reasons why module-based learning can be superior to lecture-based learning. This allows for real time retrieval practice, feedback, and repetition, all of which can be powerful and effective tools for learning.6.</p><p><strong>Research methods: </strong>This module was offered at a single academic institution with a 3-year residency program. The investigation was reviewed and approved for exemption by the Institutional Review Board of Sydney Kimmel Medical College. The module was evaluated using survey data; before the module was disseminated, residents were given a pre-module survey. The survey was used to evaluate the methods residents used to interpret ECGs prior to completion of the module and to evaluate their baseline confidence in ECG interpretation. The residents were then given access to the module and had two weeks to complete it. After the two-week period, the post-module survey was used to evaluate resident satisfaction with the delivery of the module, the methods residents used to interpret ECGs after the module, and resident confidence in ECG interpretation. The objective efficacy of the educational content in the module was assessed using a pre- and post-module assessment. The assessments consisted of 15 ECGs.Residents were asked to provide a one-sentence interpretation for each of the 15 ECGs and the final answers were based on interpretation by an electrophysiologist.</p><p><strong>Results: </strong>A group of 37 EM residents had two weeks to complete the module between pre- and post-tests. There was an 18.2% absolute increase in the mean percent correct after the module, a 42.5% relative increase from pre-test (t= -8.0, <i>p</i> < 0.001). Subjective data demonstrated that after completing the module, residents utilized the novel approach, were more confident in interpreting ECGs, and would use the module as a resource in the future.</p><p><strong>Discussion: </strong>Most participants were not confident in their ability to interpret an ECG prior to completing the module, despite most of the participants having ECG training in the six months prior to the study. Almost all the participants reported using \"rate, rhythm, axis\" as their method of ECG interpretation. Even with recent training, and an understanding of \"rate, rhythm, axis,\" there was a very low accuracy on the pre-test and lack of perceived baseline confidence in this skill. These findings highlight the need for a concise, effective supplemental ECG tool that can be incorporated into residency program curricula.The online learning module was effective at increasing confidence of ECG interpretation skills in residents as well as increasing accuracy of interpretation. Overall, participants were satisfied with the module as a resource for practicing their ECG interpretation, and most participants reported that they would use the module in the future as a reference. Implementation of the module as an additional resource in resident education is very simple. It can be accessed through any device that has internet and can be completed in a short period of time. Additionally, most experienced ECG readers will speak about \"pattern recognition\" as an important tool in ECG interpretation. This ability goes above and beyond the \"rate, rhythm, axis\" approach, but is acquired over time, often after many years of ECG interpretation. It is possible that the modular method may accelerate such pattern recognition abilities.</p><p><strong>Topics: </strong>Electrocardiogram, online module, sudden cardiac death, ischemia.</p>","PeriodicalId":73721,"journal":{"name":"Journal of education & teaching in emergency medicine","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2022-10-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10332672/pdf/","citationCount":"1","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"A Novel Module Based Method of Teaching Electrocardiogram Interpretation for Emergency Medicine Residents.\",\"authors\":\"Alexandra S Koutsoubis, Emily Fishbein, Megan Stobart-Gallagher, Behzad B Pavri, Jennifer White\",\"doi\":\"10.21980/J8Z06J\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"<p><strong>Audience: </strong>This online learning module is designed for PGY 1-3 emergency medicine (EM) residents.</p><p><strong>Introduction: </strong>Interpretation of the 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) is an essential skill for EM residents. The traditional approach to ECG interpretation in medical school is primarily didactic, teaching: \\\"rate, rhythm, axis,\\\" etc. Throughout residency, EM residents continue to receive lectures and practical ECG teaching to independently interpret ECGs with accuracy and efficiency. In addition to basic rhythm interpretation, physicians must be able to identify cardiac ischemia, abnormal rhythms, and subtle ECG findings that could herald sudden death.1 Life-threatening diagnoses such as digitalis toxicity or hyperkalemia can be made promptly through ECG evaluation and catastrophic if missed. If correctly diagnosed through ECG, many channelopathies can be treated and cardiac events can be prevented.2,3 Lecture-based learning is a necessary part of medical education, but there is a need to supplement the traditional teaching approach with online learning modules. Online learning modules provide learners with an accessible and efficient tool that allows them to improve their ECG skills on their own time.</p><p><strong>Educational objectives: </strong>After completion of the module learners should be able to: 1) correctly recognize and identify ECG abnormalities including but not limited to abnormal or absent P waves, widened QRS intervals, ST elevations, abnormal QT intervals, and dysrhythmias that can lead to sudden cardiac death; and 2) synthesize findings into a succinct but accurate interpretation of the ECG findings.</p><p><strong>Educational methods: </strong>An online module was developed using Articulate 360 and was implemented with EM residents. The module covers common ECG findings seen in the emergency department including ischemia, atrioventricular blocks, and bundle branch blocks. The module uniquely emphasizes ECG findings of arrythmias that could lead to sudden cardiac death and highlights that diagnosing sudden cardiac death syndromes relies on both clinical presentation and specific ECG findings. Online modules have proven to be as effective as lecture-based learning at improving ECG interpretation among healthcare professionals and are convenient and easily accessible to the busy EM resident.4,5 Additionally, the module is self-paced, can be completed at any time, and includes elements of active learning by incorporating knowledge checks throughout. This allows learners in real time to see where individualized improvement is needed. The ease of embedment of self-paced questions into the module is one of the salient reasons why module-based learning can be superior to lecture-based learning. This allows for real time retrieval practice, feedback, and repetition, all of which can be powerful and effective tools for learning.6.</p><p><strong>Research methods: </strong>This module was offered at a single academic institution with a 3-year residency program. The investigation was reviewed and approved for exemption by the Institutional Review Board of Sydney Kimmel Medical College. The module was evaluated using survey data; before the module was disseminated, residents were given a pre-module survey. The survey was used to evaluate the methods residents used to interpret ECGs prior to completion of the module and to evaluate their baseline confidence in ECG interpretation. The residents were then given access to the module and had two weeks to complete it. After the two-week period, the post-module survey was used to evaluate resident satisfaction with the delivery of the module, the methods residents used to interpret ECGs after the module, and resident confidence in ECG interpretation. The objective efficacy of the educational content in the module was assessed using a pre- and post-module assessment. The assessments consisted of 15 ECGs.Residents were asked to provide a one-sentence interpretation for each of the 15 ECGs and the final answers were based on interpretation by an electrophysiologist.</p><p><strong>Results: </strong>A group of 37 EM residents had two weeks to complete the module between pre- and post-tests. There was an 18.2% absolute increase in the mean percent correct after the module, a 42.5% relative increase from pre-test (t= -8.0, <i>p</i> < 0.001). Subjective data demonstrated that after completing the module, residents utilized the novel approach, were more confident in interpreting ECGs, and would use the module as a resource in the future.</p><p><strong>Discussion: </strong>Most participants were not confident in their ability to interpret an ECG prior to completing the module, despite most of the participants having ECG training in the six months prior to the study. Almost all the participants reported using \\\"rate, rhythm, axis\\\" as their method of ECG interpretation. Even with recent training, and an understanding of \\\"rate, rhythm, axis,\\\" there was a very low accuracy on the pre-test and lack of perceived baseline confidence in this skill. These findings highlight the need for a concise, effective supplemental ECG tool that can be incorporated into residency program curricula.The online learning module was effective at increasing confidence of ECG interpretation skills in residents as well as increasing accuracy of interpretation. Overall, participants were satisfied with the module as a resource for practicing their ECG interpretation, and most participants reported that they would use the module in the future as a reference. Implementation of the module as an additional resource in resident education is very simple. It can be accessed through any device that has internet and can be completed in a short period of time. Additionally, most experienced ECG readers will speak about \\\"pattern recognition\\\" as an important tool in ECG interpretation. This ability goes above and beyond the \\\"rate, rhythm, axis\\\" approach, but is acquired over time, often after many years of ECG interpretation. It is possible that the modular method may accelerate such pattern recognition abilities.</p><p><strong>Topics: </strong>Electrocardiogram, online module, sudden cardiac death, ischemia.</p>\",\"PeriodicalId\":73721,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Journal of education & teaching in emergency medicine\",\"volume\":null,\"pages\":null},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2022-10-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10332672/pdf/\",\"citationCount\":\"1\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Journal of education & teaching in emergency medicine\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.21980/J8Z06J\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Journal of education & teaching in emergency medicine","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.21980/J8Z06J","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 1
摘要
受众:这个在线学习模块是为PGY 1-3急诊医学(EM)住院医师设计的。导读:解读12导联心电图(ECG)是急诊住院医师的一项基本技能。医学院传统的心电判读方法主要是说教式的,讲授“频率、节奏、心轴”等。在住院期间,急诊住院医师继续接受讲座和实用心电教学,以准确和高效地独立解读心电图。除了基本的心律判读外,医生还必须能够识别心脏缺血、心律异常和可能预示猝死的细微心电图表现危及生命的诊断,如洋地黄毒性或高钾血症可以通过心电图评估及时做出,如果错过了灾难性的后果。如果通过心电图正确诊断,可以治疗许多通道病变并预防心脏事件。2,3以讲座为基础的学习是医学教育的必要组成部分,但需要用在线学习模块来补充传统的教学方法。在线学习模块为学习者提供了一个方便和有效的工具,使他们能够在自己的时间内提高他们的心电图技能。教学目标:完成模块学习后,学习者应能够:1)正确识别和识别心电图异常,包括但不限于异常或无P波,QRS间期加宽,ST段抬高,QT间期异常,以及可导致心源性猝死的心律失常;2)综合结果,对心电图结果作出简明而准确的解释。教育方法:使用articel360开发了一个在线模块,并在EM居民中实施。该模块涵盖急诊科常见的心电图表现,包括缺血、房室传导阻滞和束支传导阻滞。该模块独特地强调了可能导致心源性猝死的心律失常的心电图表现,并强调了心源性猝死综合征的诊断依赖于临床表现和特定的心电图表现。在线模块已被证明在改善医疗保健专业人员的心电图解释方面与基于讲座的学习一样有效,并且对于繁忙的急诊住院医生来说方便且容易访问。此外,该模块是自定进度的,可以在任何时间完成,并通过将知识检查贯穿始终,包括主动学习的元素。这使得学习者可以实时看到需要个性化改进的地方。在模块中嵌入自定进度问题的便利性是基于模块的学习优于基于讲座的学习的显著原因之一。这允许实时检索练习,反馈和重复,所有这些都可以成为强大而有效的学习工具。研究方法:该模块由一个学术机构提供,为期3年。悉尼金梅尔医学院的机构审查委员会对调查进行了审查并批准了豁免。该模块使用调查数据进行评估;在模块分发之前,对居民进行了模块前调查。该调查用于评估居民在完成该模块之前用于解释心电图的方法,并评估他们对心电图解释的基线信心。然后,居住者被允许进入这个模块,并有两周的时间来完成它。两周后,采用模块后调查来评估住院医师对模块交付的满意度,模块后住院医师解读心电图的方法,以及住院医师对心电解读的信心。通过模块前和模块后的评估来评估模块中教育内容的客观有效性。评估包括15个心电图。居民被要求对15个心电图中的每一个提供一句话的解释,最终的答案是基于电生理学家的解释。结果:一组37名EM居民有两周的时间来完成测试前后的模块。模块后平均正确率绝对增加18.2%,相对于测试前增加42.5% (t= -8.0, p < 0.001)。主观数据表明,完成该模块后,住院医生使用了新的方法,对心电图的解释更有信心,并将在未来将该模块作为一种资源。讨论:尽管大多数参与者在研究前6个月接受过心电图培训,但大多数参与者在完成该模块之前对自己解读心电图的能力没有信心。几乎所有的参与者报告使用“速率、节律、轴”作为他们的心电解释方法。即使是最近的训练,以及对“速度,节奏,轴”的理解,在预测试中也有非常低的准确性,并且缺乏对这项技能的基线信心。 这些发现强调需要一个简洁,有效的补充心电图工具,可以纳入住院医师计划课程。在线学习模块有效地提高了住院医师对心电解读技能的信心,并提高了解读的准确性。总体而言,参与者对该模块作为练习ECG解释的资源感到满意,并且大多数参与者报告说他们将来会使用该模块作为参考。该模块作为住院医师教育的附加资源的实施非常简单。它可以通过任何有互联网的设备访问,并可以在短时间内完成。此外,大多数有经验的心电解读者都会说“模式识别”是心电解读的重要工具。这种能力超越了“速率、节奏、轴”的方法,而是随着时间的推移而获得的,通常是在多年的心电图解读之后。模块化方法可能会加速这种模式识别能力。主题:心电图,在线模块,心源性猝死,缺血。
A Novel Module Based Method of Teaching Electrocardiogram Interpretation for Emergency Medicine Residents.
Audience: This online learning module is designed for PGY 1-3 emergency medicine (EM) residents.
Introduction: Interpretation of the 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) is an essential skill for EM residents. The traditional approach to ECG interpretation in medical school is primarily didactic, teaching: "rate, rhythm, axis," etc. Throughout residency, EM residents continue to receive lectures and practical ECG teaching to independently interpret ECGs with accuracy and efficiency. In addition to basic rhythm interpretation, physicians must be able to identify cardiac ischemia, abnormal rhythms, and subtle ECG findings that could herald sudden death.1 Life-threatening diagnoses such as digitalis toxicity or hyperkalemia can be made promptly through ECG evaluation and catastrophic if missed. If correctly diagnosed through ECG, many channelopathies can be treated and cardiac events can be prevented.2,3 Lecture-based learning is a necessary part of medical education, but there is a need to supplement the traditional teaching approach with online learning modules. Online learning modules provide learners with an accessible and efficient tool that allows them to improve their ECG skills on their own time.
Educational objectives: After completion of the module learners should be able to: 1) correctly recognize and identify ECG abnormalities including but not limited to abnormal or absent P waves, widened QRS intervals, ST elevations, abnormal QT intervals, and dysrhythmias that can lead to sudden cardiac death; and 2) synthesize findings into a succinct but accurate interpretation of the ECG findings.
Educational methods: An online module was developed using Articulate 360 and was implemented with EM residents. The module covers common ECG findings seen in the emergency department including ischemia, atrioventricular blocks, and bundle branch blocks. The module uniquely emphasizes ECG findings of arrythmias that could lead to sudden cardiac death and highlights that diagnosing sudden cardiac death syndromes relies on both clinical presentation and specific ECG findings. Online modules have proven to be as effective as lecture-based learning at improving ECG interpretation among healthcare professionals and are convenient and easily accessible to the busy EM resident.4,5 Additionally, the module is self-paced, can be completed at any time, and includes elements of active learning by incorporating knowledge checks throughout. This allows learners in real time to see where individualized improvement is needed. The ease of embedment of self-paced questions into the module is one of the salient reasons why module-based learning can be superior to lecture-based learning. This allows for real time retrieval practice, feedback, and repetition, all of which can be powerful and effective tools for learning.6.
Research methods: This module was offered at a single academic institution with a 3-year residency program. The investigation was reviewed and approved for exemption by the Institutional Review Board of Sydney Kimmel Medical College. The module was evaluated using survey data; before the module was disseminated, residents were given a pre-module survey. The survey was used to evaluate the methods residents used to interpret ECGs prior to completion of the module and to evaluate their baseline confidence in ECG interpretation. The residents were then given access to the module and had two weeks to complete it. After the two-week period, the post-module survey was used to evaluate resident satisfaction with the delivery of the module, the methods residents used to interpret ECGs after the module, and resident confidence in ECG interpretation. The objective efficacy of the educational content in the module was assessed using a pre- and post-module assessment. The assessments consisted of 15 ECGs.Residents were asked to provide a one-sentence interpretation for each of the 15 ECGs and the final answers were based on interpretation by an electrophysiologist.
Results: A group of 37 EM residents had two weeks to complete the module between pre- and post-tests. There was an 18.2% absolute increase in the mean percent correct after the module, a 42.5% relative increase from pre-test (t= -8.0, p < 0.001). Subjective data demonstrated that after completing the module, residents utilized the novel approach, were more confident in interpreting ECGs, and would use the module as a resource in the future.
Discussion: Most participants were not confident in their ability to interpret an ECG prior to completing the module, despite most of the participants having ECG training in the six months prior to the study. Almost all the participants reported using "rate, rhythm, axis" as their method of ECG interpretation. Even with recent training, and an understanding of "rate, rhythm, axis," there was a very low accuracy on the pre-test and lack of perceived baseline confidence in this skill. These findings highlight the need for a concise, effective supplemental ECG tool that can be incorporated into residency program curricula.The online learning module was effective at increasing confidence of ECG interpretation skills in residents as well as increasing accuracy of interpretation. Overall, participants were satisfied with the module as a resource for practicing their ECG interpretation, and most participants reported that they would use the module in the future as a reference. Implementation of the module as an additional resource in resident education is very simple. It can be accessed through any device that has internet and can be completed in a short period of time. Additionally, most experienced ECG readers will speak about "pattern recognition" as an important tool in ECG interpretation. This ability goes above and beyond the "rate, rhythm, axis" approach, but is acquired over time, often after many years of ECG interpretation. It is possible that the modular method may accelerate such pattern recognition abilities.