Fan Yang, Samuel W. Brady, Huiying Sun, Chao Tang, L. Du, M. Barz, Xiaotu Ma, Yao Chen, Houshun Fang, Xiaomeng Li, Pandurang Kolekar, Omkar Pathak, J. Cai, Lixia Ding, Tianyi Wang, A. Stackelberg, S. Shen, C. Duan, C. Eckert, Hongzhuan Chen, Yu Liu, J. Klco, Hui Li, Ben-shang Li, Jinghui Zhang, R. Kirschner-Schwabe, Bin-Bing S. Zhou
{"title":"摘要:硫嘌呤和错配修复缺陷共同促进TP53突变和ALL复发","authors":"Fan Yang, Samuel W. Brady, Huiying Sun, Chao Tang, L. Du, M. Barz, Xiaotu Ma, Yao Chen, Houshun Fang, Xiaomeng Li, Pandurang Kolekar, Omkar Pathak, J. Cai, Lixia Ding, Tianyi Wang, A. Stackelberg, S. Shen, C. Duan, C. Eckert, Hongzhuan Chen, Yu Liu, J. Klco, Hui Li, Ben-shang Li, Jinghui Zhang, R. Kirschner-Schwabe, Bin-Bing S. Zhou","doi":"10.1158/1538-7445.AM2021-633","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Chemotherapy is curative for most children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Here we provide direct evidence that thiopurine chemotherapeutics can also directly induce drug resistance mutations leading to relapse. Using a large relapsed ALL cohort assembled from Chinese, US and German patients, we found that TP53 R248Q mutations were highly enriched at relapse compared to diagnosis. Relapse-specific TP53 R248Q was associated with the acquisition of MMR deficiency mutations in MSH2, MSH6, or PMS2 and a novel relapse-specific mutational signature. Using isogenic MCF10A cells with or without engineered MSH2 knockout, and the Nalm6 ALL cell line which has native MMR deficiency, we found that this novel signature was caused by a synergistic mutagenic interaction between thiopurine treatment and mismatch repair (MMR) deficiency (called the thio-dMMR signature) that contributes to a hypermutator phenotype and acquisition of TP53 R248Q in residual ALL during remission. Treatment-induced TP53-mutant clones then expand due to broad chemoresistance, leading to eventual relapse. Indeed, thiopurines preferentially induced C>T mutations at the center of NCG trinucleotides, which can lead to TP53 R248Q, and the thiopurine mutation rate was accelerated 2- to 10-fold in MMR-deficient ALL and cell lines. Thiopurine treatment induced C>T mutations preferentially on the transcribed strand, rather than the untranscribed strand, of mRNAs, which further increased the likelihood of TP53 R248Q induction. Further, experimental thiopurine treatment was able to directly induce TP53 R248Q variants in MMR-deficient cultured cells, including Nalm6 and MCF10A MSH2-/-, by activating the thio-dMMR mutational signature, while MMR-proficient MCF10A cells did not experience R248Q induction. The sequential acquisition of MMR deficiency mutations, followed by TP53 mutations, during post-diagnosis ALL evolution was supported by clonal evolution analysis of serial patient samples. p53 R248Q promoted resistance to multiple ALL chemotherapeutic agents, and was associated with on-treatment relapse and poor relapse-treatment response. Our findings indicate that the enrichment of TP53 R248Q in relapsed ALL is due to synergistic mutagenesis from thiopurine treatment and MMR deficiency, followed by selection for TP53 R248Q9s chemoresistance phenotype. This suggests that cancer drug resistance mutations may not always pre-exist subclonally at diagnosis, but may be therapy-induced in some patients. Additionally, the qualitative and quantitative mutational signature output of a mutagen (e.g., thiopurines) can vary based on the genetic background. Finally, our findings suggest potential therapeutic strategies, including avoiding thiopurine treatment in MMR-deficient relapses, and therapeutic p53 mutant reactivation, to deal with this genetically-unstable, chemoresistant disease. Citation Format: Fan Yang, Samuel W. Brady, Huiying Sun, Chao Tang, Lijuan Du, Malwine Barz, Xiaotu Ma, Yao Chen, Houshun Fang, Xiaomeng Li, Pandurang Kolekar, Omkar Pathak, Jiaoyang Cai, Lixia Ding, Tianyi Wang, Arend von Stackelberg, Shuhong Shen, Caiwen Duan, Cornelia Eckert, Hongzhuan Chen, Yu Liu, Jeffery M. Klco, Hui Li, Benshang Li, Jinghui Zhang, Renate Kirschner-Schwabe, Bin-Bing S. Zhou. Thiopurines and mismatch repair deficiency cooperate to fuel TP53 mutagenesis and ALL relapse [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2021; 2021 Apr 10-15 and May 17-21. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2021;81(13_Suppl):Abstract nr 633.","PeriodicalId":10518,"journal":{"name":"Clinical Research (Excluding Clinical Trials)","volume":"32 4 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2021-07-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Abstract 633: Thiopurines and mismatch repair deficiency cooperate to fuel TP53 mutagenesis and ALL relapse\",\"authors\":\"Fan Yang, Samuel W. Brady, Huiying Sun, Chao Tang, L. Du, M. Barz, Xiaotu Ma, Yao Chen, Houshun Fang, Xiaomeng Li, Pandurang Kolekar, Omkar Pathak, J. Cai, Lixia Ding, Tianyi Wang, A. Stackelberg, S. Shen, C. Duan, C. Eckert, Hongzhuan Chen, Yu Liu, J. Klco, Hui Li, Ben-shang Li, Jinghui Zhang, R. Kirschner-Schwabe, Bin-Bing S. Zhou\",\"doi\":\"10.1158/1538-7445.AM2021-633\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Chemotherapy is curative for most children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Here we provide direct evidence that thiopurine chemotherapeutics can also directly induce drug resistance mutations leading to relapse. Using a large relapsed ALL cohort assembled from Chinese, US and German patients, we found that TP53 R248Q mutations were highly enriched at relapse compared to diagnosis. Relapse-specific TP53 R248Q was associated with the acquisition of MMR deficiency mutations in MSH2, MSH6, or PMS2 and a novel relapse-specific mutational signature. Using isogenic MCF10A cells with or without engineered MSH2 knockout, and the Nalm6 ALL cell line which has native MMR deficiency, we found that this novel signature was caused by a synergistic mutagenic interaction between thiopurine treatment and mismatch repair (MMR) deficiency (called the thio-dMMR signature) that contributes to a hypermutator phenotype and acquisition of TP53 R248Q in residual ALL during remission. Treatment-induced TP53-mutant clones then expand due to broad chemoresistance, leading to eventual relapse. Indeed, thiopurines preferentially induced C>T mutations at the center of NCG trinucleotides, which can lead to TP53 R248Q, and the thiopurine mutation rate was accelerated 2- to 10-fold in MMR-deficient ALL and cell lines. Thiopurine treatment induced C>T mutations preferentially on the transcribed strand, rather than the untranscribed strand, of mRNAs, which further increased the likelihood of TP53 R248Q induction. Further, experimental thiopurine treatment was able to directly induce TP53 R248Q variants in MMR-deficient cultured cells, including Nalm6 and MCF10A MSH2-/-, by activating the thio-dMMR mutational signature, while MMR-proficient MCF10A cells did not experience R248Q induction. The sequential acquisition of MMR deficiency mutations, followed by TP53 mutations, during post-diagnosis ALL evolution was supported by clonal evolution analysis of serial patient samples. p53 R248Q promoted resistance to multiple ALL chemotherapeutic agents, and was associated with on-treatment relapse and poor relapse-treatment response. Our findings indicate that the enrichment of TP53 R248Q in relapsed ALL is due to synergistic mutagenesis from thiopurine treatment and MMR deficiency, followed by selection for TP53 R248Q9s chemoresistance phenotype. This suggests that cancer drug resistance mutations may not always pre-exist subclonally at diagnosis, but may be therapy-induced in some patients. Additionally, the qualitative and quantitative mutational signature output of a mutagen (e.g., thiopurines) can vary based on the genetic background. Finally, our findings suggest potential therapeutic strategies, including avoiding thiopurine treatment in MMR-deficient relapses, and therapeutic p53 mutant reactivation, to deal with this genetically-unstable, chemoresistant disease. Citation Format: Fan Yang, Samuel W. Brady, Huiying Sun, Chao Tang, Lijuan Du, Malwine Barz, Xiaotu Ma, Yao Chen, Houshun Fang, Xiaomeng Li, Pandurang Kolekar, Omkar Pathak, Jiaoyang Cai, Lixia Ding, Tianyi Wang, Arend von Stackelberg, Shuhong Shen, Caiwen Duan, Cornelia Eckert, Hongzhuan Chen, Yu Liu, Jeffery M. Klco, Hui Li, Benshang Li, Jinghui Zhang, Renate Kirschner-Schwabe, Bin-Bing S. Zhou. Thiopurines and mismatch repair deficiency cooperate to fuel TP53 mutagenesis and ALL relapse [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2021; 2021 Apr 10-15 and May 17-21. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2021;81(13_Suppl):Abstract nr 633.\",\"PeriodicalId\":10518,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Clinical Research (Excluding Clinical Trials)\",\"volume\":\"32 4 1\",\"pages\":\"\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2021-07-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Clinical Research (Excluding Clinical Trials)\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.1158/1538-7445.AM2021-633\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Clinical Research (Excluding Clinical Trials)","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1158/1538-7445.AM2021-633","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
化疗是治疗大多数儿童急性淋巴细胞白血病(ALL)。在这里,我们提供了直接的证据,证明硫嘌呤化疗也可以直接诱导耐药突变导致复发。通过对来自中国、美国和德国的复发性ALL患者的大型队列研究,我们发现与诊断相比,复发时TP53 R248Q突变高度富集。复发特异性TP53 R248Q与MSH2、MSH6或PMS2中MMR缺陷突变的获得以及一种新的复发特异性突变特征相关。通过对等基因MCF10A细胞进行或不进行MSH2基因敲除,以及对具有天然MMR缺陷的Nalm6 ALL细胞系进行研究,我们发现这种新的特征是由硫嘌呤治疗和错配修复(MMR)缺陷(称为硫代- dmmr特征)之间的协同诱变相互作用引起的,这种相互作用导致了缓解期间残留ALL的超突变表型和TP53 R248Q的获得。治疗诱导的tp53突变克隆随后由于广泛的化疗耐药而扩增,导致最终复发。事实上,硫嘌呤优先诱导NCG三核苷酸中心的C>T突变,从而导致TP53 R248Q,并且在mmr缺陷ALL和细胞系中,硫嘌呤突变率加快了2- 10倍。硫嘌呤处理优先诱导mrna转录链上的C>T突变,而不是非转录链上的突变,这进一步增加了TP53 R248Q诱导的可能性。此外,实验硫嘌呤处理能够通过激活硫代dmmr突变特征,在mmr缺陷培养细胞(包括Nalm6和MCF10A MSH2-/-)中直接诱导TP53 R248Q变异,而mmr熟练的MCF10A细胞则没有R248Q诱导。在诊断后ALL进化过程中,MMR缺陷突变和TP53突变的顺序获取得到了一系列患者样本克隆进化分析的支持。p53 R248Q促进对多种ALL化疗药物的耐药,并与治疗中复发和复发治疗不良反应相关。我们的研究结果表明,复发性ALL中TP53 R248Q的富集是由于硫嘌呤治疗和MMR缺乏的协同诱变,然后选择TP53 R248Q9s化疗耐药表型。这表明癌症耐药突变可能并不总是在诊断时预先存在亚克隆,但在一些患者中可能是治疗诱导的。此外,诱变原(例如,硫嘌呤)的定性和定量突变特征输出可以根据遗传背景而变化。最后,我们的研究结果提出了潜在的治疗策略,包括避免在mmr缺陷复发时使用硫嘌呤治疗,以及治疗性p53突变体再激活,以应对这种遗传不稳定,耐药的疾病。引用格式:杨帆,Samuel W. Brady,孙慧颖,唐超,杜丽娟,Malwine Barz,马晓图,陈瑶,方厚顺,李晓萌,Pandurang Kolekar, Omkar Pathak,蔡焦阳,丁丽霞,王天一,Arend von Stackelberg,沈淑红,段彩文,Cornelia Eckert,陈红转,刘宇,Jeffery M. Klco,李辉,李本尚,张景辉,Renate Kirschner-Schwabe,周斌斌硫嘌呤和错配修复缺陷共同促进TP53突变和ALL复发[摘要]。见:美国癌症研究协会2021年年会论文集;2021年4月10日至15日和5月17日至21日。费城(PA): AACR;癌症杂志,2021;81(13 -增刊):摘要第633期。
Abstract 633: Thiopurines and mismatch repair deficiency cooperate to fuel TP53 mutagenesis and ALL relapse
Chemotherapy is curative for most children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Here we provide direct evidence that thiopurine chemotherapeutics can also directly induce drug resistance mutations leading to relapse. Using a large relapsed ALL cohort assembled from Chinese, US and German patients, we found that TP53 R248Q mutations were highly enriched at relapse compared to diagnosis. Relapse-specific TP53 R248Q was associated with the acquisition of MMR deficiency mutations in MSH2, MSH6, or PMS2 and a novel relapse-specific mutational signature. Using isogenic MCF10A cells with or without engineered MSH2 knockout, and the Nalm6 ALL cell line which has native MMR deficiency, we found that this novel signature was caused by a synergistic mutagenic interaction between thiopurine treatment and mismatch repair (MMR) deficiency (called the thio-dMMR signature) that contributes to a hypermutator phenotype and acquisition of TP53 R248Q in residual ALL during remission. Treatment-induced TP53-mutant clones then expand due to broad chemoresistance, leading to eventual relapse. Indeed, thiopurines preferentially induced C>T mutations at the center of NCG trinucleotides, which can lead to TP53 R248Q, and the thiopurine mutation rate was accelerated 2- to 10-fold in MMR-deficient ALL and cell lines. Thiopurine treatment induced C>T mutations preferentially on the transcribed strand, rather than the untranscribed strand, of mRNAs, which further increased the likelihood of TP53 R248Q induction. Further, experimental thiopurine treatment was able to directly induce TP53 R248Q variants in MMR-deficient cultured cells, including Nalm6 and MCF10A MSH2-/-, by activating the thio-dMMR mutational signature, while MMR-proficient MCF10A cells did not experience R248Q induction. The sequential acquisition of MMR deficiency mutations, followed by TP53 mutations, during post-diagnosis ALL evolution was supported by clonal evolution analysis of serial patient samples. p53 R248Q promoted resistance to multiple ALL chemotherapeutic agents, and was associated with on-treatment relapse and poor relapse-treatment response. Our findings indicate that the enrichment of TP53 R248Q in relapsed ALL is due to synergistic mutagenesis from thiopurine treatment and MMR deficiency, followed by selection for TP53 R248Q9s chemoresistance phenotype. This suggests that cancer drug resistance mutations may not always pre-exist subclonally at diagnosis, but may be therapy-induced in some patients. Additionally, the qualitative and quantitative mutational signature output of a mutagen (e.g., thiopurines) can vary based on the genetic background. Finally, our findings suggest potential therapeutic strategies, including avoiding thiopurine treatment in MMR-deficient relapses, and therapeutic p53 mutant reactivation, to deal with this genetically-unstable, chemoresistant disease. Citation Format: Fan Yang, Samuel W. Brady, Huiying Sun, Chao Tang, Lijuan Du, Malwine Barz, Xiaotu Ma, Yao Chen, Houshun Fang, Xiaomeng Li, Pandurang Kolekar, Omkar Pathak, Jiaoyang Cai, Lixia Ding, Tianyi Wang, Arend von Stackelberg, Shuhong Shen, Caiwen Duan, Cornelia Eckert, Hongzhuan Chen, Yu Liu, Jeffery M. Klco, Hui Li, Benshang Li, Jinghui Zhang, Renate Kirschner-Schwabe, Bin-Bing S. Zhou. Thiopurines and mismatch repair deficiency cooperate to fuel TP53 mutagenesis and ALL relapse [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2021; 2021 Apr 10-15 and May 17-21. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2021;81(13_Suppl):Abstract nr 633.