The survey of bone allograft transplantation in a Japanese regional bone bank

Background

In reconstructive surgery for large bone defects, the demand for bone allografts has increased over the years; however, it is unclear how the supply and demand in Japanese regional bone banks have evolved over time. This study investigated the 15-year supply and demand of bone allografts stored in a regional bone bank, along with assessing the screening process's effectiveness.

Methods

The target period was 15 years from April 2005 to March 2020. The period was subdivided into three 5-year periods: first, second, and third. The study items included the number of bone allografts donated, the number of bone allografts used, donor and user facilities, surgical methods using bone allografts, and the number of bone allografts discarded. We used the Cochran-Armitage test for statistical analysis.

Results

A total of 1852 bone allografts were donated to the bone bank, and a total of 1721 were used. A total of 677 bone allografts grafts were provided in the first period, 738 in the second period, and 525 in the third period, indicating a decreasing trend. The average number of allografts per surgery was 2.8 in the first, 3.1 in the second, and 1.7 in the third, showing a decreasing trend. Concerning the percentage of each surgery using bone allografts, spine fusion decreased in the third period but not significantly, whereas primary hip arthroplasty increased significantly in the third period. The total number of discarded bone allografts was 4.8% of the total number of donated bone allografts, largely because of a lack of screening tests.

Conclusion

Although the number of allogeneic bone surgeries has been increasing over time, the number of allogeneic bone donations has shown a decreasing trend, and there is a need to develop a system that can provide surgeons with sufficient bone allografts.