Long segment versus short segment stabilization in thoracolumbar spine fracture: A retrospective clinical and radiological analysis

Introduction: Thoracolumbar spine fracture is one of the commonest spinal fractures. The treatment of choice of surgery is still controversial. This is a retrospective analysis of clinical and radiological outcomes of long and short segment stabilization for patients admitted with thoracolumbar fracture in our hospitals. Material and Method: Inclusion criteria included a single level of thoracolumbar fracture, excluding pre-existing deformity or spinal surgery, osteoporosis, and pathological fracture. Clinical parameters included visual analogue scale (VAS), operative time, intraoperative blood loss, and postoperative length of stay. Radiological parameters included wedge angle and anterior and posterior vertebral height ratio. Results: From June 2007 to May 2020, 56 patients (male = 31, female = 25) were recruited. There were 25 patients in the short segment group (open = 11, minimal invasive surgery (MIS) = 14) and 31 patients in the long segment group. Clinically, significantly better VAS at 6 months (1 vs. 1.96; p = 0.041), shorter post-op length of stay (16 days vs. 25 days; p = 0.01), and less blood loss (178 ml vs. 824 ml; p < 0.01) were found in the short segment group. Radiologically, the short segment group showed significantly better wedge angle at immediate (5° vs. 9.23°; p = 0.002) and long-term follow-up (7.41° vs. 11.43°; p = 0.01). Moreover, the short segment group has significantly better post-op anterior and posterior vertebral height ratios. Within the short segment group, the MIS group showed significantly less blood loss (82 ml vs. 303 ml; p < 0.01). However radiological parameters favour the open group. Discussion and Conclusion: For single-level thoracolumbar fracture, both long and short stabilizations were effective in reducing and stabilizing the fracture. However, the short segment group showed significantly superior results. Moreover, a minimally invasive technique in short segment stabilization showed even less blood loss but less optimal radiological results. Therefore, short segment stabilization could be the treatment of choice for traumatic thoracolumbar spine fractures.