A. Danielisová, Daniel Bursák, L. Strnad, J. Trubač, Hana Čižmářová, David Daněček, Kamil Smíšek, Archeologický ústav Zelný trh Brno Czech Republic Moravské zemské muzeum, Zámek Roztoky Czech Republic Středočeské muzeum v Roztokách u Prahy
{"title":"仪式、囤积和旅行者?铁器时代青铜轮护身符的考古测量","authors":"A. Danielisová, Daniel Bursák, L. Strnad, J. Trubač, Hana Čižmářová, David Daněček, Kamil Smíšek, Archeologický ústav Zelný trh Brno Czech Republic Moravské zemské muzeum, Zámek Roztoky Czech Republic Středočeské muzeum v Roztokách u Prahy","doi":"10.24916/iansa.2020.1.3","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"This paper aims to discuss the origin and significance of the so-called spoked-wheel amulets from the late Iron Age (3rd to 1st century BC). The type with eight spokes, which most resembles a real chariot wheel, was discovered to be made of a specific alloy containing a large amount of lead and a significant amount of antimony, plus traces of silver and arsenic. This combination of elements signifies the use of a copper known as fahlore (tetrahedrite). Its use in Bohemia after the early Bronze Age is rarely observed, if at all. These amulets are therefore a conspicuous exception. Research in Bavaria has revealed other objects made from fahlore copper. Another connection to Bavaria may be indicated by coin hoards accompanied by bronze closure rings of a similar alloy design. Other cases may suggest that antimony was added as a separate component. Here we discuss the composition and provenance of these objects from the perspective of compositional and lead isotope analysis. IANSA 2020 ● XI/1 ● 33–45 Alžběta Danielisová, Daniel Bursák, Ladislav Strnad, Jakub Trubač, Hana Čižmářová, David Daněček, Kamil Smíšek: Rituals, Hoards and Travellers? Archaeometry of the Iron Age Bronze Wheel Amulets 34 which imitate chariot wheels. They are usually made entirely from lead or from a heavily-leaded alloy (Schwab, 2011). The eight spokes are a regular feature; sometimes there are multiples of eight, as with the sixteen-spoked wheel depicted on a Gundestrup cauldron (Green, 1986). Fourand sixspoked wheels make up a larger and more heterogeneous group. These wheels appear only to suggest rather than imitate chariot wheels and have a simpler design that is perhaps more decorative in the context of late La Tène art. Archaeometric analysis of large assemblages from the La Tène period revealed the recurrence of a particular material composition of the eight-spoked wheels (Danielisová et al., 2018b), which included a large amount of lead, unusually large amounts of antimony, and increased amounts of arsenic and sometimes silver. It was noteworthy that this chemical composition was found only in these amulets and not in the other types of object. West of Bohemia, however, particularly in Bavaria, antimony bronzes have regularly been recorded and associated with the alloying of fahlore copper (Schwab, 2011; 2014a; 2014b). It was not until we detected the same composition in two bronze rings with a rhombic section, used as a closure mechanism in the context of a Celtic coin hoard from Libčice nad Vltavou (Figures 2 and 3), that the connection with Bavaria became worth considering. We therefore decided to give more attention to this matter and to investigate the alloy design and provenance of these objects and to explore the broader socio-cultural or political implications. In addition to “official” commercial Figure 1. Types of wheel amulet from the La Tène period (the oppidum of Stradonice), after Píč, 1903. Figure 2. Map of sites mentioned in the text and main deposits of fahlore coppers and antimonites in central Europe. Filled symbols: wheel amulets; hollow symbols: rings with a rhombic section; sites represent coin hoards, oppida, and lowland settlements. IANSA 2020 ● XI/1 ● 33–45 Alžběta Danielisová, Daniel Bursák, Ladislav Strnad, Jakub Trubač, Hana Čižmářová, David Daněček, Kamil Smíšek: Rituals, Hoards and Travellers? Archaeometry of the Iron Age Bronze Wheel Amulets 35 Figure 3. a) Analysed spoked-wheel amulets from selected sites (cf. Figure 2). The numbers in the picture correspond to the numbers in Table 1 (some objects were not available for documentation). Photo by D. Bursák and A. Danielisová. b) Rings with a rhombic section from coin hoards at Libčice (LIB1–2) and Manching (485–486), and a ring of the same composition from the oppidum of Staré Hradisko (SH 136). Photo by D. Bursák and D. Daněček (LIB1–2); Manching rings (485–486) from Zieghaus, 2013. 0 5 cm","PeriodicalId":38054,"journal":{"name":"Interdisciplinaria Archaeologica","volume":"69 1","pages":"33-45"},"PeriodicalIF":0.2000,"publicationDate":"2020-08-10","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"2","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Rituals, Hoards and Travellers? Archaeometry of the Iron Age Bronze Wheel Amulets\",\"authors\":\"A. Danielisová, Daniel Bursák, L. Strnad, J. Trubač, Hana Čižmářová, David Daněček, Kamil Smíšek, Archeologický ústav Zelný trh Brno Czech Republic Moravské zemské muzeum, Zámek Roztoky Czech Republic Středočeské muzeum v Roztokách u Prahy\",\"doi\":\"10.24916/iansa.2020.1.3\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"This paper aims to discuss the origin and significance of the so-called spoked-wheel amulets from the late Iron Age (3rd to 1st century BC). The type with eight spokes, which most resembles a real chariot wheel, was discovered to be made of a specific alloy containing a large amount of lead and a significant amount of antimony, plus traces of silver and arsenic. This combination of elements signifies the use of a copper known as fahlore (tetrahedrite). Its use in Bohemia after the early Bronze Age is rarely observed, if at all. These amulets are therefore a conspicuous exception. Research in Bavaria has revealed other objects made from fahlore copper. Another connection to Bavaria may be indicated by coin hoards accompanied by bronze closure rings of a similar alloy design. Other cases may suggest that antimony was added as a separate component. Here we discuss the composition and provenance of these objects from the perspective of compositional and lead isotope analysis. IANSA 2020 ● XI/1 ● 33–45 Alžběta Danielisová, Daniel Bursák, Ladislav Strnad, Jakub Trubač, Hana Čižmářová, David Daněček, Kamil Smíšek: Rituals, Hoards and Travellers? Archaeometry of the Iron Age Bronze Wheel Amulets 34 which imitate chariot wheels. They are usually made entirely from lead or from a heavily-leaded alloy (Schwab, 2011). The eight spokes are a regular feature; sometimes there are multiples of eight, as with the sixteen-spoked wheel depicted on a Gundestrup cauldron (Green, 1986). Fourand sixspoked wheels make up a larger and more heterogeneous group. These wheels appear only to suggest rather than imitate chariot wheels and have a simpler design that is perhaps more decorative in the context of late La Tène art. Archaeometric analysis of large assemblages from the La Tène period revealed the recurrence of a particular material composition of the eight-spoked wheels (Danielisová et al., 2018b), which included a large amount of lead, unusually large amounts of antimony, and increased amounts of arsenic and sometimes silver. It was noteworthy that this chemical composition was found only in these amulets and not in the other types of object. West of Bohemia, however, particularly in Bavaria, antimony bronzes have regularly been recorded and associated with the alloying of fahlore copper (Schwab, 2011; 2014a; 2014b). It was not until we detected the same composition in two bronze rings with a rhombic section, used as a closure mechanism in the context of a Celtic coin hoard from Libčice nad Vltavou (Figures 2 and 3), that the connection with Bavaria became worth considering. We therefore decided to give more attention to this matter and to investigate the alloy design and provenance of these objects and to explore the broader socio-cultural or political implications. In addition to “official” commercial Figure 1. Types of wheel amulet from the La Tène period (the oppidum of Stradonice), after Píč, 1903. Figure 2. Map of sites mentioned in the text and main deposits of fahlore coppers and antimonites in central Europe. Filled symbols: wheel amulets; hollow symbols: rings with a rhombic section; sites represent coin hoards, oppida, and lowland settlements. IANSA 2020 ● XI/1 ● 33–45 Alžběta Danielisová, Daniel Bursák, Ladislav Strnad, Jakub Trubač, Hana Čižmářová, David Daněček, Kamil Smíšek: Rituals, Hoards and Travellers? Archaeometry of the Iron Age Bronze Wheel Amulets 35 Figure 3. a) Analysed spoked-wheel amulets from selected sites (cf. Figure 2). The numbers in the picture correspond to the numbers in Table 1 (some objects were not available for documentation). Photo by D. Bursák and A. Danielisová. b) Rings with a rhombic section from coin hoards at Libčice (LIB1–2) and Manching (485–486), and a ring of the same composition from the oppidum of Staré Hradisko (SH 136). Photo by D. Bursák and D. Daněček (LIB1–2); Manching rings (485–486) from Zieghaus, 2013. 0 5 cm\",\"PeriodicalId\":38054,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Interdisciplinaria Archaeologica\",\"volume\":\"69 1\",\"pages\":\"33-45\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.2000,\"publicationDate\":\"2020-08-10\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"2\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Interdisciplinaria Archaeologica\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.24916/iansa.2020.1.3\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q4\",\"JCRName\":\"ANTHROPOLOGY\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Interdisciplinaria Archaeologica","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.24916/iansa.2020.1.3","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q4","JCRName":"ANTHROPOLOGY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 2
摘要
本文旨在探讨铁器时代晚期(公元前3世纪至公元前1世纪)所谓辐条轮护身符的起源和意义。有8条辐条的车轮,最像真正的战车车轮,被发现是由一种特殊的合金制成的,这种合金含有大量的铅和大量的锑,以及微量的银和砷。这种元素的组合表明使用了一种被称为fahore(四面体)的铜。在早期青铜时代之后的波西米亚,人们很少看到它的使用,如果有的话。因此,这些护身符是一个明显的例外。巴伐利亚州的研究发现了其他由fahore铜制成的物品。与巴伐利亚的另一个联系可能是由带有类似合金设计的青铜封闭环的硬币柜表明的。其他情况可能表明,锑是作为一个单独的成分添加的。本文从元素组成和铅同位素分析的角度探讨了这些遗物的组成和物源。铁器时代的青铜轮护身符,模仿战车的轮子。它们通常完全由铅或重铅合金制成(Schwab, 2011)。八个辐条是一个规则的特征;有时是8的倍数,就像Gundestrup大锅上描绘的16条轮辐车轮(Green, 1986)。四辐条和六辐条车轮组成了一个更大、更异质的群体。这些轮子似乎只是暗示而不是模仿战车的轮子,并且具有更简单的设计,在La t晚期艺术的背景下可能更具装饰性。对La t时期的大型组合进行的考古分析显示,八辐车轮的特定物质组成再次出现(danielisov等人,2018b),其中包括大量的铅,异常大量的锑,以及增加的砷,有时还有银。值得注意的是,这种化学成分只在这些护身符中发现,而在其他类型的物体中没有发现。然而,在波希米亚西部,特别是在巴伐利亚,锑青铜器经常被记录下来,并与fahore铜的合金化有关(Schwab, 2011;2014年;2014 b)。直到我们在lib ice nad Vltavou的凯尔特硬币窖藏中发现了两个具有方形部分的青铜环的相同成分(图2和3),我们才开始考虑与巴伐利亚的联系。因此,我们决定对这件事给予更多的关注,调查这些物品的合金设计和来源,并探索更广泛的社会文化或政治含义。除了“官方”商业图1。1903年Píč之后,La t时期(Stradonice的鸦片)的轮子护身符类型。图2。文中提到的地点地图,以及中欧法赫洛尔铜和古石的主要矿床。填充符号:轮子护身符;空心符号:菱形部分的圆环;遗址代表了钱币储藏、奥皮达和低地定居点。铁器时代青铜轮护身符的考古测量图3。a)对选定地点的辐条轮护身符进行分析(参见图2)。图片中的数字与表1中的数字相对应(有些物品没有记录)。图片由D. Bursák和A. danielisov提供。b)在lib冰(LIB1-2)和Manching(485-486)的硬币库中发现的菱形部分的环,以及在star Hradisko (SH 136)的oppidum中发现的相同成分的环。D. Bursák、D. dan ek (LIB1-2)摄;2013年齐格豪斯的Manching rings(485-486)。0 - 5厘米
Rituals, Hoards and Travellers? Archaeometry of the Iron Age Bronze Wheel Amulets
This paper aims to discuss the origin and significance of the so-called spoked-wheel amulets from the late Iron Age (3rd to 1st century BC). The type with eight spokes, which most resembles a real chariot wheel, was discovered to be made of a specific alloy containing a large amount of lead and a significant amount of antimony, plus traces of silver and arsenic. This combination of elements signifies the use of a copper known as fahlore (tetrahedrite). Its use in Bohemia after the early Bronze Age is rarely observed, if at all. These amulets are therefore a conspicuous exception. Research in Bavaria has revealed other objects made from fahlore copper. Another connection to Bavaria may be indicated by coin hoards accompanied by bronze closure rings of a similar alloy design. Other cases may suggest that antimony was added as a separate component. Here we discuss the composition and provenance of these objects from the perspective of compositional and lead isotope analysis. IANSA 2020 ● XI/1 ● 33–45 Alžběta Danielisová, Daniel Bursák, Ladislav Strnad, Jakub Trubač, Hana Čižmářová, David Daněček, Kamil Smíšek: Rituals, Hoards and Travellers? Archaeometry of the Iron Age Bronze Wheel Amulets 34 which imitate chariot wheels. They are usually made entirely from lead or from a heavily-leaded alloy (Schwab, 2011). The eight spokes are a regular feature; sometimes there are multiples of eight, as with the sixteen-spoked wheel depicted on a Gundestrup cauldron (Green, 1986). Fourand sixspoked wheels make up a larger and more heterogeneous group. These wheels appear only to suggest rather than imitate chariot wheels and have a simpler design that is perhaps more decorative in the context of late La Tène art. Archaeometric analysis of large assemblages from the La Tène period revealed the recurrence of a particular material composition of the eight-spoked wheels (Danielisová et al., 2018b), which included a large amount of lead, unusually large amounts of antimony, and increased amounts of arsenic and sometimes silver. It was noteworthy that this chemical composition was found only in these amulets and not in the other types of object. West of Bohemia, however, particularly in Bavaria, antimony bronzes have regularly been recorded and associated with the alloying of fahlore copper (Schwab, 2011; 2014a; 2014b). It was not until we detected the same composition in two bronze rings with a rhombic section, used as a closure mechanism in the context of a Celtic coin hoard from Libčice nad Vltavou (Figures 2 and 3), that the connection with Bavaria became worth considering. We therefore decided to give more attention to this matter and to investigate the alloy design and provenance of these objects and to explore the broader socio-cultural or political implications. In addition to “official” commercial Figure 1. Types of wheel amulet from the La Tène period (the oppidum of Stradonice), after Píč, 1903. Figure 2. Map of sites mentioned in the text and main deposits of fahlore coppers and antimonites in central Europe. Filled symbols: wheel amulets; hollow symbols: rings with a rhombic section; sites represent coin hoards, oppida, and lowland settlements. IANSA 2020 ● XI/1 ● 33–45 Alžběta Danielisová, Daniel Bursák, Ladislav Strnad, Jakub Trubač, Hana Čižmářová, David Daněček, Kamil Smíšek: Rituals, Hoards and Travellers? Archaeometry of the Iron Age Bronze Wheel Amulets 35 Figure 3. a) Analysed spoked-wheel amulets from selected sites (cf. Figure 2). The numbers in the picture correspond to the numbers in Table 1 (some objects were not available for documentation). Photo by D. Bursák and A. Danielisová. b) Rings with a rhombic section from coin hoards at Libčice (LIB1–2) and Manching (485–486), and a ring of the same composition from the oppidum of Staré Hradisko (SH 136). Photo by D. Bursák and D. Daněček (LIB1–2); Manching rings (485–486) from Zieghaus, 2013. 0 5 cm