J. Nováčková, Otakara Řebounová, D. Kvítková, M. Omelka, V. Stenzl, Czech Republic Prague
{"title":"原奥博拉村(位于布拉格小城区Šporkova街)的一个废弃墓地中发现的早期现代人类遗骸的遗传亲缘关系和性别测定","authors":"J. Nováčková, Otakara Řebounová, D. Kvítková, M. Omelka, V. Stenzl, Czech Republic Prague","doi":"10.24916/iansa.2019.2.4","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"The main aim of this study was to determine genetic kinship and genetic sex of individuals buried either in the same grave, multi-level grave, or neighbourhood grave. Success of genetic analyses is based on the quantity and quality of extracted aDNA, which can be compromised by degradation of DNA and possible contamination by modern DNA. We analysed archaeological skeletal remains from an Early Modern period graveyard belonging to the Church of St. John the Baptist in the former village of Obora, one of the most honourable Early Modern period archaeological sites in the Czech Republic. Most of the 906 excavated anatomically-laid burials are dated to the years 1730s–1770s. The results of 23 analysed individuals (divided into 4 groups) revealed that individuals are not blood relatives. Studies of historical written sources provide information that the parish affiliation at the time of death had a crucial role in choosing the place for burial. Genetic analyses increased success rate of sex determination to 91% compared to 61% determined by morphological methods. We were thus able to determine the genetic sex of children, an evaluation that cannot be made by morphological methods. IANSA 2019 ● X/2 ● 143–152 Jana Nováčková, Otakara Řebounová, Dana Kvítková, Martin Omelka, Vlastimil Stenzl: Genetic Kinship and Sex Determination of Early Modern Period Human Remains from a Defunct Graveyard in the Former Village of Obora (Located on Šporkova Street in Prague’s Lesser Town District) 144 (Deguilloux et al., 2014; Juras et al., 2017; Melchior et al., 2010; Simón et al., 2011). Each marker has its own unique mechanism of heritability from parent to offspring, and can reveal or exclude genetic relationships at different levels. We analysed the skeletal remains from a defunct graveyard of the Church of St. John the Baptist in the former village of Obora, situated at Šporkova Street no. 322/III in Prague, the capital of the Czech Republic. Genetic kinship and genetic sex was determined from the results of autosomal and Y-chromosomal STR markers. The site of Obora used to be a village located near Prague castle in the quarter known as Prague’s Lesser Town. The first written record referencing Obora is dated to the years 1278– 1282, but previous excavation has uncovered fragments dated to between the 9th–10th century (Dragoun, 1988a; 1988b; 1991). Obora was assigned to Prague in the 1650s, and its Church of St. John the Baptist was incorporated into the parish district of the Church of St. Wenceslas. The church with its graveyard was closed in 1784, and rebuilt into a residential building (Omelka, 2009). Skeletal remains of 906 anatomically-laid burials or parts thereof, that were dated to the years 1730s–1770s according to their grave goods, were excavated and documented during the archaeological rescue excavation conducted by the Department of Archaeology of the National Heritage Institute in Prague in the year 2002 (study no. 30/02) and 2004 (study no. 30/04) – Figure 1. The archaeological location in Šporkova Street is one of the most valuable Early Modern period archaeological sites in the Czech Republic due to the assemblage collection of grave goods and preserved written historical sources, providing great possibilities to study: funerary customs among the burgher citizens of the time (Omelka, Řebounová, 2017); other manifestations of Baroque religiousness (Omelka, Řebounová, 2011; 2014); as well as social and demographic structures among this population (Omelka, Řebounová, 2012b). Several articles were published (mainly in Czech peer-reviewed journals) regarding artefacts found in the grave, including goods such as rings (Omelka, Šlancarová, 2007), beads (Omelka, Řebounová, 2008), crosses (Omelka et al., 2009; 2010), pins (Omelka et al., 2011), a medallion (Omelka, 2006a; Omelka, Řebounová, 2012a; 2016) and buttons (Omelka et al., 2018). Pilot results of genetic analyses of 11 individuals were presented at the International conference “Internationale Tagung der Österreichischen Gesellschaft für Mittelalterarchäologie 2018” in Sankt Pölten (Austria) (Nováčková et al., in press). In the present study, we increased the number of analysed individuals to confirm or reject the hypothesis that the pattern of funerary practices of Early Modern society, as suggested by the pilot study, would hold up under further examination. 2. Material and methods We analysed a total of 46 samples (bones and teeth) from 23 individuals (Table 1), of which 12 individuals (group 3 and group 4) are newly published, and 11 individuals (group 1 and group 2) were previously published (Nováčková et al., in press). Individuals were divided into four groups (Table 1) according to their stratigraphic relationships in the graveyard (Figure 2). The groups contain the genetic material of men, women and children, except for group 2, where two children (newborn and 18 months old) were buried just above an adult woman. Multi-level graves contained skeletal remains of adult women, men and children and so there is a high probability that they are members of one family (for example, Figure 1. The plan of three phases of excavations at the defunct graveyard of the Church of St. John the Baptist and ground plan of the church. The archaeological rescue excavation was carried out only on the part of graveyard in which construction work took place on (Omelka, 2006b, unpublished). Drawn by Martin Omelka.","PeriodicalId":38054,"journal":{"name":"Interdisciplinaria Archaeologica","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":0.2000,"publicationDate":"2019-12-31","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"4","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Genetic Kinship and Sex Determination of Early Modern Period Human Remains from a Defunct Graveyard in the Former Village of Obora (Located on Šporkova Street in Prague’s Lesser Town District)\",\"authors\":\"J. Nováčková, Otakara Řebounová, D. Kvítková, M. Omelka, V. Stenzl, Czech Republic Prague\",\"doi\":\"10.24916/iansa.2019.2.4\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"The main aim of this study was to determine genetic kinship and genetic sex of individuals buried either in the same grave, multi-level grave, or neighbourhood grave. Success of genetic analyses is based on the quantity and quality of extracted aDNA, which can be compromised by degradation of DNA and possible contamination by modern DNA. We analysed archaeological skeletal remains from an Early Modern period graveyard belonging to the Church of St. John the Baptist in the former village of Obora, one of the most honourable Early Modern period archaeological sites in the Czech Republic. Most of the 906 excavated anatomically-laid burials are dated to the years 1730s–1770s. The results of 23 analysed individuals (divided into 4 groups) revealed that individuals are not blood relatives. Studies of historical written sources provide information that the parish affiliation at the time of death had a crucial role in choosing the place for burial. Genetic analyses increased success rate of sex determination to 91% compared to 61% determined by morphological methods. We were thus able to determine the genetic sex of children, an evaluation that cannot be made by morphological methods. IANSA 2019 ● X/2 ● 143–152 Jana Nováčková, Otakara Řebounová, Dana Kvítková, Martin Omelka, Vlastimil Stenzl: Genetic Kinship and Sex Determination of Early Modern Period Human Remains from a Defunct Graveyard in the Former Village of Obora (Located on Šporkova Street in Prague’s Lesser Town District) 144 (Deguilloux et al., 2014; Juras et al., 2017; Melchior et al., 2010; Simón et al., 2011). Each marker has its own unique mechanism of heritability from parent to offspring, and can reveal or exclude genetic relationships at different levels. We analysed the skeletal remains from a defunct graveyard of the Church of St. John the Baptist in the former village of Obora, situated at Šporkova Street no. 322/III in Prague, the capital of the Czech Republic. Genetic kinship and genetic sex was determined from the results of autosomal and Y-chromosomal STR markers. The site of Obora used to be a village located near Prague castle in the quarter known as Prague’s Lesser Town. The first written record referencing Obora is dated to the years 1278– 1282, but previous excavation has uncovered fragments dated to between the 9th–10th century (Dragoun, 1988a; 1988b; 1991). Obora was assigned to Prague in the 1650s, and its Church of St. John the Baptist was incorporated into the parish district of the Church of St. Wenceslas. The church with its graveyard was closed in 1784, and rebuilt into a residential building (Omelka, 2009). Skeletal remains of 906 anatomically-laid burials or parts thereof, that were dated to the years 1730s–1770s according to their grave goods, were excavated and documented during the archaeological rescue excavation conducted by the Department of Archaeology of the National Heritage Institute in Prague in the year 2002 (study no. 30/02) and 2004 (study no. 30/04) – Figure 1. The archaeological location in Šporkova Street is one of the most valuable Early Modern period archaeological sites in the Czech Republic due to the assemblage collection of grave goods and preserved written historical sources, providing great possibilities to study: funerary customs among the burgher citizens of the time (Omelka, Řebounová, 2017); other manifestations of Baroque religiousness (Omelka, Řebounová, 2011; 2014); as well as social and demographic structures among this population (Omelka, Řebounová, 2012b). Several articles were published (mainly in Czech peer-reviewed journals) regarding artefacts found in the grave, including goods such as rings (Omelka, Šlancarová, 2007), beads (Omelka, Řebounová, 2008), crosses (Omelka et al., 2009; 2010), pins (Omelka et al., 2011), a medallion (Omelka, 2006a; Omelka, Řebounová, 2012a; 2016) and buttons (Omelka et al., 2018). Pilot results of genetic analyses of 11 individuals were presented at the International conference “Internationale Tagung der Österreichischen Gesellschaft für Mittelalterarchäologie 2018” in Sankt Pölten (Austria) (Nováčková et al., in press). In the present study, we increased the number of analysed individuals to confirm or reject the hypothesis that the pattern of funerary practices of Early Modern society, as suggested by the pilot study, would hold up under further examination. 2. Material and methods We analysed a total of 46 samples (bones and teeth) from 23 individuals (Table 1), of which 12 individuals (group 3 and group 4) are newly published, and 11 individuals (group 1 and group 2) were previously published (Nováčková et al., in press). Individuals were divided into four groups (Table 1) according to their stratigraphic relationships in the graveyard (Figure 2). The groups contain the genetic material of men, women and children, except for group 2, where two children (newborn and 18 months old) were buried just above an adult woman. Multi-level graves contained skeletal remains of adult women, men and children and so there is a high probability that they are members of one family (for example, Figure 1. The plan of three phases of excavations at the defunct graveyard of the Church of St. John the Baptist and ground plan of the church. The archaeological rescue excavation was carried out only on the part of graveyard in which construction work took place on (Omelka, 2006b, unpublished). Drawn by Martin Omelka.\",\"PeriodicalId\":38054,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Interdisciplinaria Archaeologica\",\"volume\":null,\"pages\":null},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.2000,\"publicationDate\":\"2019-12-31\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"4\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Interdisciplinaria Archaeologica\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.24916/iansa.2019.2.4\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q4\",\"JCRName\":\"ANTHROPOLOGY\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Interdisciplinaria Archaeologica","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.24916/iansa.2019.2.4","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q4","JCRName":"ANTHROPOLOGY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 4
摘要
本研究的主要目的是确定埋葬在同一坟墓、多层坟墓或邻居坟墓中的个体的遗传亲缘关系和遗传性别。遗传分析的成功是基于提取的aDNA的数量和质量,这可能会受到DNA降解和现代DNA可能污染的损害。我们分析了一个早期现代时期墓地的考古骨骼遗骸,该墓地属于施洗者圣约翰教堂,位于前奥博拉村,这是捷克共和国最光荣的早期现代考古遗址之一。906个经解剖解剖出土的墓葬中,大多数可以追溯到1730 - 1770年。23个被分析的个体(分为4组)的结果显示,个体不是血亲。对历史文献资料的研究提供的信息表明,死者死亡时所属的教区在选择埋葬地点方面起着至关重要的作用。遗传分析将性别决定的成功率提高到91%,而形态学方法的成功率为61%。因此,我们能够确定儿童的遗传性别,这是无法通过形态学方法进行的评估。IANSA 2019●X/2●143-152 Jana Nováčková, Otakara Řebounová, Dana Kvítková, Martin Omelka, Vlastimil Stenzl:来自前Obora村(位于布拉格小城区Šporkova街)墓地的早期现代人类遗骸的遗传亲缘关系和性别确定144 (Deguilloux等人,2014;Juras et al., 2017;Melchior et al., 2010;Simón et al., 2011)。每个标记都有自己独特的遗传机制,可以揭示或排除不同层次的遗传关系。我们分析了位于Šporkova街5号的前Obora村圣约翰浸信会教堂墓地的骨骼残骸。322/III在捷克共和国首都布拉格。根据常染色体和y染色体STR标记的结果确定遗传亲缘关系和遗传性别。奥博拉的遗址曾经是布拉格城堡附近的一个村庄,位于被称为布拉格小城镇的地区。有关奥博拉的第一个书面记录可以追溯到1278 - 1282年,但之前的挖掘已经发现了9 - 10世纪之间的碎片(Dragoun, 1988a;1988 b;1991)。17世纪50年代,奥博拉被分配到布拉格,它的施洗约翰教堂被并入圣瓦茨拉夫教堂的教区。教堂及其墓地于1784年关闭,并重建为住宅楼(Omelka, 2009)。在2002年布拉格国家遗产研究所考古部门进行的考古救援挖掘中,发现了906具解剖结构的墓葬遗骸或其部分遗骸,根据其墓葬的物品可以追溯到1730年至1770年。30/02)及2004年(研究编号:30/04) -图1。Šporkova街的考古位置是捷克共和国最有价值的早期现代考古遗址之一,因为它汇集了墓葬物品和保存下来的书面历史资料,为研究提供了很大的可能性:当时市民的丧葬习俗(Omelka, Řebounová, 2017);巴洛克宗教信仰的其他表现形式(Omelka, Řebounová, 2011;2014);以及这一人群的社会和人口结构(Omelka, Řebounová, 2012b)。关于在坟墓中发现的文物,发表了几篇文章(主要是在捷克同行评审的期刊上),包括戒指(Omelka, Šlancarová, 2007)、珠子(Omelka, Řebounová, 2008)、十字架(Omelka等人,2009;2010),大头针(Omelka et al., 2011),奖章(Omelka, 2006a;Omelka, Řebounová, 2012a;2016)和按钮(Omelka et al., 2018)。11个个体遗传分析的初步结果在santkt Pölten(奥地利)举行的“Internationale Tagung der Österreichischen Gesellschaft f<e:1> Mittelalterarchäologie 2018”国际会议上发表(Nováčková等人,出版中)。在目前的研究中,我们增加了分析个体的数量,以证实或拒绝一个假设,即早期现代社会的丧葬习俗模式,正如试点研究所表明的那样,将在进一步的研究中得到证实。2. 材料和方法我们共分析了23个个体的46个样本(骨骼和牙齿)(表1),其中12个个体(第3组和第4组)是新发表的,11个个体(第1组和第2组)是以前发表的(Nováčková et al., in press)。根据个体在墓地中的地层关系(图2),将其分为四组(表1)。各组包含男性、女性和儿童的遗传物质,除了组2,其中两个孩子(新生儿和18个月大)被埋在一名成年妇女的上方。 多层墓穴中有成年女性、男性和儿童的骨骼遗骸,因此它们很有可能是一个家庭的成员(例如,图1)。施洗者圣约翰教堂墓地的三阶段挖掘计划和教堂的平面图。考古救援挖掘只在建筑施工的墓地部分进行(Omelka, 2006b,未发表)。由Martin Omelka绘制。
Genetic Kinship and Sex Determination of Early Modern Period Human Remains from a Defunct Graveyard in the Former Village of Obora (Located on Šporkova Street in Prague’s Lesser Town District)
The main aim of this study was to determine genetic kinship and genetic sex of individuals buried either in the same grave, multi-level grave, or neighbourhood grave. Success of genetic analyses is based on the quantity and quality of extracted aDNA, which can be compromised by degradation of DNA and possible contamination by modern DNA. We analysed archaeological skeletal remains from an Early Modern period graveyard belonging to the Church of St. John the Baptist in the former village of Obora, one of the most honourable Early Modern period archaeological sites in the Czech Republic. Most of the 906 excavated anatomically-laid burials are dated to the years 1730s–1770s. The results of 23 analysed individuals (divided into 4 groups) revealed that individuals are not blood relatives. Studies of historical written sources provide information that the parish affiliation at the time of death had a crucial role in choosing the place for burial. Genetic analyses increased success rate of sex determination to 91% compared to 61% determined by morphological methods. We were thus able to determine the genetic sex of children, an evaluation that cannot be made by morphological methods. IANSA 2019 ● X/2 ● 143–152 Jana Nováčková, Otakara Řebounová, Dana Kvítková, Martin Omelka, Vlastimil Stenzl: Genetic Kinship and Sex Determination of Early Modern Period Human Remains from a Defunct Graveyard in the Former Village of Obora (Located on Šporkova Street in Prague’s Lesser Town District) 144 (Deguilloux et al., 2014; Juras et al., 2017; Melchior et al., 2010; Simón et al., 2011). Each marker has its own unique mechanism of heritability from parent to offspring, and can reveal or exclude genetic relationships at different levels. We analysed the skeletal remains from a defunct graveyard of the Church of St. John the Baptist in the former village of Obora, situated at Šporkova Street no. 322/III in Prague, the capital of the Czech Republic. Genetic kinship and genetic sex was determined from the results of autosomal and Y-chromosomal STR markers. The site of Obora used to be a village located near Prague castle in the quarter known as Prague’s Lesser Town. The first written record referencing Obora is dated to the years 1278– 1282, but previous excavation has uncovered fragments dated to between the 9th–10th century (Dragoun, 1988a; 1988b; 1991). Obora was assigned to Prague in the 1650s, and its Church of St. John the Baptist was incorporated into the parish district of the Church of St. Wenceslas. The church with its graveyard was closed in 1784, and rebuilt into a residential building (Omelka, 2009). Skeletal remains of 906 anatomically-laid burials or parts thereof, that were dated to the years 1730s–1770s according to their grave goods, were excavated and documented during the archaeological rescue excavation conducted by the Department of Archaeology of the National Heritage Institute in Prague in the year 2002 (study no. 30/02) and 2004 (study no. 30/04) – Figure 1. The archaeological location in Šporkova Street is one of the most valuable Early Modern period archaeological sites in the Czech Republic due to the assemblage collection of grave goods and preserved written historical sources, providing great possibilities to study: funerary customs among the burgher citizens of the time (Omelka, Řebounová, 2017); other manifestations of Baroque religiousness (Omelka, Řebounová, 2011; 2014); as well as social and demographic structures among this population (Omelka, Řebounová, 2012b). Several articles were published (mainly in Czech peer-reviewed journals) regarding artefacts found in the grave, including goods such as rings (Omelka, Šlancarová, 2007), beads (Omelka, Řebounová, 2008), crosses (Omelka et al., 2009; 2010), pins (Omelka et al., 2011), a medallion (Omelka, 2006a; Omelka, Řebounová, 2012a; 2016) and buttons (Omelka et al., 2018). Pilot results of genetic analyses of 11 individuals were presented at the International conference “Internationale Tagung der Österreichischen Gesellschaft für Mittelalterarchäologie 2018” in Sankt Pölten (Austria) (Nováčková et al., in press). In the present study, we increased the number of analysed individuals to confirm or reject the hypothesis that the pattern of funerary practices of Early Modern society, as suggested by the pilot study, would hold up under further examination. 2. Material and methods We analysed a total of 46 samples (bones and teeth) from 23 individuals (Table 1), of which 12 individuals (group 3 and group 4) are newly published, and 11 individuals (group 1 and group 2) were previously published (Nováčková et al., in press). Individuals were divided into four groups (Table 1) according to their stratigraphic relationships in the graveyard (Figure 2). The groups contain the genetic material of men, women and children, except for group 2, where two children (newborn and 18 months old) were buried just above an adult woman. Multi-level graves contained skeletal remains of adult women, men and children and so there is a high probability that they are members of one family (for example, Figure 1. The plan of three phases of excavations at the defunct graveyard of the Church of St. John the Baptist and ground plan of the church. The archaeological rescue excavation was carried out only on the part of graveyard in which construction work took place on (Omelka, 2006b, unpublished). Drawn by Martin Omelka.