环境研究的研究方法:一种社会科学方法

IF 0.5 0 ARCHITECTURE
Connie Svabo
{"title":"环境研究的研究方法:一种社会科学方法","authors":"Connie Svabo","doi":"10.1080/24751448.2022.2116244","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"to inquire into complex environmental issues. Author Mark Kanazawa asserts there has been a growing interest in environmental studies across colleges in the US, with many new programs focusing on environmental studies. This book is a resource well-suited for introductory educational purposes. It provides coherent and easily accessible accounts of research history and paradigms. It provides accessible examples of research questions and research projects from environmental studies. The author draws on his experience as an economist working in interdisciplinary research teams to highlight and provide examples of environmental research problems explored in disciplinary collaboration. The book consists of 19 chapters with content that roughly falls into three categories: quantitative research, methods for qualitative research, and themes that crosscut the qualitative/quantitative divide. The book includes basic methodological approaches of ethnography, spatial analysis, and GIS and approaches to data collection such as sampling, interviewing, and surveying. The book provides chapters on ethics and on writing a research proposal. The strength of the book is its accessibility, tone, and breadth. It provides a relevant historical framing of research methods and history of knowledge, describes a range of research methods, makes them accessible for student projects in environmental studies, and supports educators and students with suggestions for exercises and discussion points. The book has a friendly and easy-going tone and includes helpful boxes that frame essential learning points, including summaries of key points. For example, on page 3: “Bottom line: It took a series of scientists, doing painstaking research and building on previous scientific findings, to give us the knowledge of global warming that we have today.” The topics mentioned as potential research foci are “ongoing climate change, air, and water pollution, increasingly scarce freshwater resources, production of hazardous wastes, depleted natural resources, destruction of rain forests, habitat destruction, [and] growing lists of endangered species.”1 These are complex and dynamic phenomena of intraand intersystemic characters. They are wicked problems—problems with no easy solutions and problems typically characterized by disagreement among stakeholders about what has caused them, how they should be perceived and how we might handle them.2 The wicked nature of environmental problems forms the basis of a book critique. The presented methods aim at academic discussion and policy more than actual change-making for real-world impact. The book does not engage with designerly ways of producing knowledge through making, prototyping, or other cyclical, constructive, and generative processes. Nor with process-oriented design approaches such as participatory design. Students of technology, architecture, design, and engineering most likely will want to supplement the book with designand practice-oriented methods that teach one how to intervene in the world, work with stakeholders, communicate clearly, and practice creative problem-solving. These are all competencies of great importance when dealing with the wicked challenges. The chapter that comes closest to such approaches is on Action Research, a research method where knowledge creation processes are extended to cocreation and participatory approaches. In the description of Action Research, projects by both students and more senior researchers are described, which involve working with communities to identify and improve particular environmental issues through research, such as environment related health risks. The book passes over transdisciplinary research by subsuming it under the header of Interdisciplinarity. However, a significant feature of transdisciplinarity is that it engages with real-world actors in real-world situations. Transdisciplinary approaches excel in helping build competence to work with messy knowledge processes and productions. Education scholar Julie Thompson Klein connects transdisciplinarity with increasing awareness about a need for action in academic and scientific communities and connecting sciences of sustainability, climate change, environmental risk, and pollution in research that seeks to make a difference, seeking small and large-scale change that is ethically Research Methods for Environmental Studies: A Social Science Approach","PeriodicalId":36812,"journal":{"name":"Technology Architecture and Design","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":0.5000,"publicationDate":"2022-07-03","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Research Methods for Environmental Studies: A Social Science Approach\",\"authors\":\"Connie Svabo\",\"doi\":\"10.1080/24751448.2022.2116244\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"to inquire into complex environmental issues. Author Mark Kanazawa asserts there has been a growing interest in environmental studies across colleges in the US, with many new programs focusing on environmental studies. This book is a resource well-suited for introductory educational purposes. It provides coherent and easily accessible accounts of research history and paradigms. It provides accessible examples of research questions and research projects from environmental studies. The author draws on his experience as an economist working in interdisciplinary research teams to highlight and provide examples of environmental research problems explored in disciplinary collaboration. The book consists of 19 chapters with content that roughly falls into three categories: quantitative research, methods for qualitative research, and themes that crosscut the qualitative/quantitative divide. The book includes basic methodological approaches of ethnography, spatial analysis, and GIS and approaches to data collection such as sampling, interviewing, and surveying. The book provides chapters on ethics and on writing a research proposal. The strength of the book is its accessibility, tone, and breadth. It provides a relevant historical framing of research methods and history of knowledge, describes a range of research methods, makes them accessible for student projects in environmental studies, and supports educators and students with suggestions for exercises and discussion points. The book has a friendly and easy-going tone and includes helpful boxes that frame essential learning points, including summaries of key points. For example, on page 3: “Bottom line: It took a series of scientists, doing painstaking research and building on previous scientific findings, to give us the knowledge of global warming that we have today.” The topics mentioned as potential research foci are “ongoing climate change, air, and water pollution, increasingly scarce freshwater resources, production of hazardous wastes, depleted natural resources, destruction of rain forests, habitat destruction, [and] growing lists of endangered species.”1 These are complex and dynamic phenomena of intraand intersystemic characters. They are wicked problems—problems with no easy solutions and problems typically characterized by disagreement among stakeholders about what has caused them, how they should be perceived and how we might handle them.2 The wicked nature of environmental problems forms the basis of a book critique. The presented methods aim at academic discussion and policy more than actual change-making for real-world impact. The book does not engage with designerly ways of producing knowledge through making, prototyping, or other cyclical, constructive, and generative processes. Nor with process-oriented design approaches such as participatory design. Students of technology, architecture, design, and engineering most likely will want to supplement the book with designand practice-oriented methods that teach one how to intervene in the world, work with stakeholders, communicate clearly, and practice creative problem-solving. These are all competencies of great importance when dealing with the wicked challenges. The chapter that comes closest to such approaches is on Action Research, a research method where knowledge creation processes are extended to cocreation and participatory approaches. In the description of Action Research, projects by both students and more senior researchers are described, which involve working with communities to identify and improve particular environmental issues through research, such as environment related health risks. The book passes over transdisciplinary research by subsuming it under the header of Interdisciplinarity. However, a significant feature of transdisciplinarity is that it engages with real-world actors in real-world situations. Transdisciplinary approaches excel in helping build competence to work with messy knowledge processes and productions. Education scholar Julie Thompson Klein connects transdisciplinarity with increasing awareness about a need for action in academic and scientific communities and connecting sciences of sustainability, climate change, environmental risk, and pollution in research that seeks to make a difference, seeking small and large-scale change that is ethically Research Methods for Environmental Studies: A Social Science Approach\",\"PeriodicalId\":36812,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Technology Architecture and Design\",\"volume\":null,\"pages\":null},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.5000,\"publicationDate\":\"2022-07-03\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Technology Architecture and Design\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.1080/24751448.2022.2116244\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"0\",\"JCRName\":\"ARCHITECTURE\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Technology Architecture and Design","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1080/24751448.2022.2116244","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"ARCHITECTURE","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

调查复杂的环境问题。作者马克·金泽(Mark Kanazawa)声称,美国大学对环境研究的兴趣越来越大,许多新项目都专注于环境研究。这本书是非常适合介绍性教育目的的资源。它提供了连贯和易于访问的研究历史和范式的帐户。它提供了来自环境研究的研究问题和研究项目的可访问示例。作者利用他作为一名在跨学科研究团队中工作的经济学家的经验,强调并提供了在学科合作中探索的环境研究问题的例子。本书共有19章,内容大致分为三类:定量研究、定性研究方法和贯穿定性/定量鸿沟的主题。这本书包括民族志,空间分析和地理信息系统的基本方法和方法的数据收集,如抽样,访谈和调查。这本书提供了关于伦理和撰写研究计划的章节。这本书的优势在于它的易读性、基调和广度。它提供了一个相关的历史框架的研究方法和知识的历史,描述了一系列的研究方法,使他们在环境研究的学生项目访问,并支持教育工作者和学生的建议练习和讨论点。这本书有一个友好和随和的基调,包括有用的框框架的基本学习要点,包括要点的总结。例如,在第3页:“底线:一系列科学家进行了艰苦的研究,并在以前的科学发现的基础上,为我们提供了今天的全球变暖知识。”潜在的研究重点是“持续的气候变化、空气和水污染、日益稀缺的淡水资源、有害废物的产生、自然资源的枯竭、雨林的破坏、栖息地的破坏,以及越来越多的濒危物种。”这些都是系统内部和系统间特征的复杂动态现象。这些都是棘手的问题——这些问题没有简单的解决方案,而且这些问题的典型特征是利益相关者在导致这些问题的原因、如何看待这些问题以及我们应该如何处理这些问题上存在分歧环境问题的邪恶本质构成了一本书评论的基础。所提出的方法旨在学术讨论和政策,而不是为现实世界的影响做出实际的改变。这本书没有通过制作,原型或其他周期性,建设性和生成过程的生产知识的设计师的方式参与。参与式设计等面向过程的设计方法也不适用。技术、建筑、设计和工程专业的学生最有可能想要用设计和实践为导向的方法来补充这本书,这些方法教人们如何干预世界,与利益相关者合作,清晰地沟通,以及实践创造性的问题解决方法。这些都是处理邪恶挑战时非常重要的能力。与这些方法最接近的一章是关于行动研究的,这是一种将知识创造过程扩展到共同创造和参与方法的研究方法。在行动研究的描述中,描述了学生和较资深研究人员的项目,这些项目涉及与社区合作,通过研究确定和改善特定的环境问题,例如与环境有关的健康风险。这本书通过将其归入跨学科的标题下而忽略了跨学科的研究。然而,跨学科的一个重要特征是它在现实世界的情况下与现实世界的参与者接触。跨学科方法在帮助建立处理混乱的知识过程和产品的能力方面表现出色。教育学者朱莉·汤普森·克莱因(Julie Thompson Klein)将跨学科与学术界和科学界日益增长的行动需求意识联系起来,并将可持续发展、气候变化、环境风险和污染等科学联系起来,寻求改变,寻求小规模和大规模的变化,这是合乎伦理的环境研究研究方法:一种社会科学方法
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
Research Methods for Environmental Studies: A Social Science Approach
to inquire into complex environmental issues. Author Mark Kanazawa asserts there has been a growing interest in environmental studies across colleges in the US, with many new programs focusing on environmental studies. This book is a resource well-suited for introductory educational purposes. It provides coherent and easily accessible accounts of research history and paradigms. It provides accessible examples of research questions and research projects from environmental studies. The author draws on his experience as an economist working in interdisciplinary research teams to highlight and provide examples of environmental research problems explored in disciplinary collaboration. The book consists of 19 chapters with content that roughly falls into three categories: quantitative research, methods for qualitative research, and themes that crosscut the qualitative/quantitative divide. The book includes basic methodological approaches of ethnography, spatial analysis, and GIS and approaches to data collection such as sampling, interviewing, and surveying. The book provides chapters on ethics and on writing a research proposal. The strength of the book is its accessibility, tone, and breadth. It provides a relevant historical framing of research methods and history of knowledge, describes a range of research methods, makes them accessible for student projects in environmental studies, and supports educators and students with suggestions for exercises and discussion points. The book has a friendly and easy-going tone and includes helpful boxes that frame essential learning points, including summaries of key points. For example, on page 3: “Bottom line: It took a series of scientists, doing painstaking research and building on previous scientific findings, to give us the knowledge of global warming that we have today.” The topics mentioned as potential research foci are “ongoing climate change, air, and water pollution, increasingly scarce freshwater resources, production of hazardous wastes, depleted natural resources, destruction of rain forests, habitat destruction, [and] growing lists of endangered species.”1 These are complex and dynamic phenomena of intraand intersystemic characters. They are wicked problems—problems with no easy solutions and problems typically characterized by disagreement among stakeholders about what has caused them, how they should be perceived and how we might handle them.2 The wicked nature of environmental problems forms the basis of a book critique. The presented methods aim at academic discussion and policy more than actual change-making for real-world impact. The book does not engage with designerly ways of producing knowledge through making, prototyping, or other cyclical, constructive, and generative processes. Nor with process-oriented design approaches such as participatory design. Students of technology, architecture, design, and engineering most likely will want to supplement the book with designand practice-oriented methods that teach one how to intervene in the world, work with stakeholders, communicate clearly, and practice creative problem-solving. These are all competencies of great importance when dealing with the wicked challenges. The chapter that comes closest to such approaches is on Action Research, a research method where knowledge creation processes are extended to cocreation and participatory approaches. In the description of Action Research, projects by both students and more senior researchers are described, which involve working with communities to identify and improve particular environmental issues through research, such as environment related health risks. The book passes over transdisciplinary research by subsuming it under the header of Interdisciplinarity. However, a significant feature of transdisciplinarity is that it engages with real-world actors in real-world situations. Transdisciplinary approaches excel in helping build competence to work with messy knowledge processes and productions. Education scholar Julie Thompson Klein connects transdisciplinarity with increasing awareness about a need for action in academic and scientific communities and connecting sciences of sustainability, climate change, environmental risk, and pollution in research that seeks to make a difference, seeking small and large-scale change that is ethically Research Methods for Environmental Studies: A Social Science Approach
求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
Technology Architecture and Design
Technology Architecture and Design Arts and Humanities-Visual Arts and Performing Arts
CiteScore
1.30
自引率
0.00%
发文量
18
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信