{"title":"非洲豺狼故事:结构与内容的模式化","authors":"C. P. van der Vyver","doi":"10.17159/2224-7912/2022/v62n1a10","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"OPSOMMING In hierdie artikel word verslag gedoen van 'n deduktiewe ontleding van 'n versameling Jakkals-en-Wolfverhale met betrekking tot struktuurelemente, strukturele patrone, variasiepatrone en inhoud volgens die beginsels van strukturalistiese narratologie. Die struktuurmodelle wat reeds deur ander navorsers in volks- en trieksterverhale uitgewys is, is ook aan hierdie korpus getoets. Daar is bevind dat Afrikaanse Jakkals-en-Wolfverhale ooreenstem met die universele patrone van trieksterverhale. Dit het ook geblyk dat die held in hierdie verhale bepaal word deur die oogpunt waaruit die gebeure beskou word. Jakkals is onder meer 'n metafoor van die triekster wat in 'n sosiaal beter posisie geplaas word deur die feit dat hy slim is en daarin kan slaag om die fisiek sterkere te uitoorlê. Daar is bevind dat die struktuur van die Afrikaanse Jakkals-en-Wolfverhale in sekere opsigte uniek is - 'n universele verlede, unieke karakters, 'n beperkte ruimte, 'n verteller-fokalisator, gebeure waarvan die episodes op mekaar volg, episodes wat ingebed is in 'n handelingsreeks en vertellers wat ingestel is op die kindergehoor. Dit is duidelik dat die struktuur en algemene inhoud van Afrikaanse Jakkals-en-Wolftrieksterverhale dinamies gebly het. 'n Wyer soektog behoort geloods te word om meer volksverhale, in veral die Suid-Afrikaanse konteks, wetenskaplik te versamel sodat meer verhale met mekaar vergelyk kan word ten einde tot 'n algemener gevolgtrekking te kan kom oor die struktuur en patroonmatig-hede in Suid-Afrikaanse volksverhale. Trefwoorde: aktante, dieptestruktuur, narratief, ontleding, patroonmatighede, triekster, trieksterverhaal, struktuur, struktuurelemente, volksverhaal ABSTRACT This article explores characteristic or repetitive pattern formations in the structure and general content of selected Afrikaans Jackal and Wolf trickster stories. By using a specific methodology, a corpus of stories was first selected, followed by a comparative analysis of the different stories. An analysis of repetitive patterns necessitates both syntagmatic and paradigmatic readings of the stories, as demonstrated in both Bremond's (1977) model, dealing with the action in stories and Greimas's (1966) actantial model focusing on different functions of characters. By utilising these analytic models, the methods of storytelling and foregrounding, as well as the meaning of these relationships and of the stories as a whole could be discerned. Pre-existing structural readings of the folk tale, the trickster tale and Jackal and Wolf stories also added value to the research. Some examples from the corpus of stories are provided to illustrate and substantiate findings. The corpus consisted of sound recordings by a project team led by Du Plessis (1987:814), recordings made by the researcher in the Murraysburg district in June 2010, Jackal and Wolf stories told by Dana Niehaus (2011), and stories from the volumes Die Kaskenades van Jakkals en Wolf (Rousseau, 2011), Die Mooiste Afrikaanse Sprokies (Grobbelaar & Verster, 2007), and Jakkals en Wolf (Grobbelaar & Verster, 2011). Both Bremond's action logic and Greimas's actantial model proved valuable in describing the structure of the stories and the unique formations of patterns that emerged from the analysis. For example, the actantial roles (Greimas) in Jackal and Wolf stories represented indications of an underlying deep structure informing countless re-telling of the different stories. Regarding the structure of events (Bremond), it was noticeable that in some of the stories, the episodes followed one another successively, while in others the episodes were embedded in previous episodes. A comparative reading of the Jackal and Wolf trickster stories revealed significant relationships between the structural elements of the different stories. For example, the stories all take place in a universal past; there are usually three characters in these stories, but usually it is only Wolf that is defeated. The characters are mostly male, and the few female characters present in the stories remain in the background. The characters constantly find themselves in a space thatfluctuates between a domesticated and an undomesticated world. The stories are mainly told by an external narrator-focaliser who narrates and observes and who is not limited to a particular position. These stories are most often told by male storytellers. Many of the storytellers are highly attuned to the audience and they often adapt the stories to suit their target audience (South African children). Many of the storytellers engage the audience by making use of ingenious techniques; for example, by directly involving the audience in dialogue or offering moral lessons. It clearly emerged that the identity of the hero in these stories depends on the perspective from which the events are considered. The investigated corpus shows that the stories can be described as trickster tales in more ways than one, and that they follow the general patterns of trickster tales. It is also clear that the identified structures remain dynamic. Keywords: actants, analysis, deep structure, folktale, narrative, patterning, structure, structural elements, trickster, trickster story","PeriodicalId":42800,"journal":{"name":"Tydskrif Vir Geesteswetenskappe","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":0.2000,"publicationDate":"2022-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Afrikaanse Jakkals-en-Wolftrieksterverhale: Strukturele en inhoudelike patroonmatighede Afrikaans Jackal and Wolf trickster stories: Patterning in the structure and general content\",\"authors\":\"C. P. van der Vyver\",\"doi\":\"10.17159/2224-7912/2022/v62n1a10\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"OPSOMMING In hierdie artikel word verslag gedoen van 'n deduktiewe ontleding van 'n versameling Jakkals-en-Wolfverhale met betrekking tot struktuurelemente, strukturele patrone, variasiepatrone en inhoud volgens die beginsels van strukturalistiese narratologie. Die struktuurmodelle wat reeds deur ander navorsers in volks- en trieksterverhale uitgewys is, is ook aan hierdie korpus getoets. Daar is bevind dat Afrikaanse Jakkals-en-Wolfverhale ooreenstem met die universele patrone van trieksterverhale. Dit het ook geblyk dat die held in hierdie verhale bepaal word deur die oogpunt waaruit die gebeure beskou word. Jakkals is onder meer 'n metafoor van die triekster wat in 'n sosiaal beter posisie geplaas word deur die feit dat hy slim is en daarin kan slaag om die fisiek sterkere te uitoorlê. Daar is bevind dat die struktuur van die Afrikaanse Jakkals-en-Wolfverhale in sekere opsigte uniek is - 'n universele verlede, unieke karakters, 'n beperkte ruimte, 'n verteller-fokalisator, gebeure waarvan die episodes op mekaar volg, episodes wat ingebed is in 'n handelingsreeks en vertellers wat ingestel is op die kindergehoor. Dit is duidelik dat die struktuur en algemene inhoud van Afrikaanse Jakkals-en-Wolftrieksterverhale dinamies gebly het. 'n Wyer soektog behoort geloods te word om meer volksverhale, in veral die Suid-Afrikaanse konteks, wetenskaplik te versamel sodat meer verhale met mekaar vergelyk kan word ten einde tot 'n algemener gevolgtrekking te kan kom oor die struktuur en patroonmatig-hede in Suid-Afrikaanse volksverhale. Trefwoorde: aktante, dieptestruktuur, narratief, ontleding, patroonmatighede, triekster, trieksterverhaal, struktuur, struktuurelemente, volksverhaal ABSTRACT This article explores characteristic or repetitive pattern formations in the structure and general content of selected Afrikaans Jackal and Wolf trickster stories. By using a specific methodology, a corpus of stories was first selected, followed by a comparative analysis of the different stories. An analysis of repetitive patterns necessitates both syntagmatic and paradigmatic readings of the stories, as demonstrated in both Bremond's (1977) model, dealing with the action in stories and Greimas's (1966) actantial model focusing on different functions of characters. By utilising these analytic models, the methods of storytelling and foregrounding, as well as the meaning of these relationships and of the stories as a whole could be discerned. Pre-existing structural readings of the folk tale, the trickster tale and Jackal and Wolf stories also added value to the research. Some examples from the corpus of stories are provided to illustrate and substantiate findings. The corpus consisted of sound recordings by a project team led by Du Plessis (1987:814), recordings made by the researcher in the Murraysburg district in June 2010, Jackal and Wolf stories told by Dana Niehaus (2011), and stories from the volumes Die Kaskenades van Jakkals en Wolf (Rousseau, 2011), Die Mooiste Afrikaanse Sprokies (Grobbelaar & Verster, 2007), and Jakkals en Wolf (Grobbelaar & Verster, 2011). Both Bremond's action logic and Greimas's actantial model proved valuable in describing the structure of the stories and the unique formations of patterns that emerged from the analysis. For example, the actantial roles (Greimas) in Jackal and Wolf stories represented indications of an underlying deep structure informing countless re-telling of the different stories. Regarding the structure of events (Bremond), it was noticeable that in some of the stories, the episodes followed one another successively, while in others the episodes were embedded in previous episodes. A comparative reading of the Jackal and Wolf trickster stories revealed significant relationships between the structural elements of the different stories. For example, the stories all take place in a universal past; there are usually three characters in these stories, but usually it is only Wolf that is defeated. The characters are mostly male, and the few female characters present in the stories remain in the background. The characters constantly find themselves in a space thatfluctuates between a domesticated and an undomesticated world. The stories are mainly told by an external narrator-focaliser who narrates and observes and who is not limited to a particular position. These stories are most often told by male storytellers. Many of the storytellers are highly attuned to the audience and they often adapt the stories to suit their target audience (South African children). Many of the storytellers engage the audience by making use of ingenious techniques; for example, by directly involving the audience in dialogue or offering moral lessons. It clearly emerged that the identity of the hero in these stories depends on the perspective from which the events are considered. The investigated corpus shows that the stories can be described as trickster tales in more ways than one, and that they follow the general patterns of trickster tales. It is also clear that the identified structures remain dynamic. Keywords: actants, analysis, deep structure, folktale, narrative, patterning, structure, structural elements, trickster, trickster story\",\"PeriodicalId\":42800,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Tydskrif Vir Geesteswetenskappe\",\"volume\":null,\"pages\":null},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.2000,\"publicationDate\":\"2022-01-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Tydskrif Vir Geesteswetenskappe\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"98\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.17159/2224-7912/2022/v62n1a10\",\"RegionNum\":4,\"RegionCategory\":\"文学\",\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"Q4\",\"JCRName\":\"SOCIAL ISSUES\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Tydskrif Vir Geesteswetenskappe","FirstCategoryId":"98","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.17159/2224-7912/2022/v62n1a10","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"文学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q4","JCRName":"SOCIAL ISSUES","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
意见在本节中,根据结构叙事的原则,通过对Jaccals和WolfDepartments的集合进行演绎分析,报告了与结构元素、结构模式、变体模式和内容有关的内容。其他浏览器在人员和文件管理器中已经显示的结构模型也在该主体上进行了测试。研究发现,非洲人雅克和沃尔夫冈符合普遍的压力模式。我认为这是一个很好的例子。Jackal不仅仅是一个比喻,因为他身材苗条,有机会对抗体力,所以他处于一个更好的社会地位。研究发现,非洲裔雅克和沃尔夫冈的结构在某些方面是独特的——一个普遍的过去,一个独特的角色,一个有限的空间,一个讲故事的焦点,然后是彼此的剧集,嵌入交易系列的剧集,以及在儿童之家中建立的口译员。很明显,非洲雅克和沃尔夫发电站的结构和总体内容一直保持着活力。应该更好地寻求更多的公众利益,特别是在南非,以便将科学和科学关系结合起来,以便进行更多的比较,最终能够对南非的结构和赞助机构采取共同的后续行动。关键词:aktante,深度结构,叙事,ontleding,patronatity,triekster,文件服务器,结构,结构关系,火山摘要本文探讨了选定的南非荷兰语Jackal和Wolf trickster故事的结构和一般内容中的特征或重复模式形成。通过使用特定的方法,首先选择了一个故事语料库,然后对不同的故事进行比较分析。对重复模式的分析需要对故事进行组合和范式解读,正如Bremond(1977)处理故事中动作的模型和Greimas(1966)关注人物不同功能的行为模型所示。通过利用这些分析模型,可以辨别出讲故事和预测的方法,以及这些关系和故事作为一个整体的意义。现有的民间故事、骗子故事、豺狼故事的结构解读也为研究增加了价值。提供了一些来自故事语料库的例子来说明和证实研究结果。该语料库由杜普莱西斯领导的项目团队的录音(1987:814)、研究人员于2010年6月在Murraysburg地区录制的录音、Dana Niehaus讲述的Jackal和Wolf的故事(2011)以及《Die Kaskenades van Jakkals en Wolf》(卢梭,2011)、《Die Mooiste Afrikaanse Sprokies》(Grobbelaar&Verster,2007),以及Jakkals和Wolf(Grobber&Verster,2011)。Bremond的行动逻辑和Greimas的行为模型在描述故事结构和分析中出现的独特模式方面都被证明是有价值的。例如,《豺狼》和《狼》故事中的行为角色(Greimas)代表了一种潜在的深层结构,为无数不同故事的讲述提供了信息。关于事件的结构(Bremond),值得注意的是,在一些故事中,情节一个接一个,而在其他故事中,剧集嵌入了前几集。通过对《豺狼》和《狼》故事的比较阅读,可以发现不同故事的结构元素之间存在着重要的关系。例如,这些故事都发生在一个普遍的过去;这些故事中通常有三个角色,但通常只有狼被打败。角色大多是男性,故事中出现的少数女性角色仍留在背景中。角色们不断地发现自己身处一个在驯化和未驯化的世界之间波动的空间。故事主要由一个外部叙事聚焦者讲述,他叙事和观察,不局限于特定的位置。这些故事通常由男性说书人讲。许多讲故事的人都非常适应观众,他们经常改编故事以适合他们的目标观众(南非儿童)。许多讲故事的人通过巧妙的技巧吸引观众;例如,通过直接让观众参与对话或提供道德课程。很明显,这些故事中主人公的身份取决于对事件的看法。
Afrikaanse Jakkals-en-Wolftrieksterverhale: Strukturele en inhoudelike patroonmatighede Afrikaans Jackal and Wolf trickster stories: Patterning in the structure and general content
OPSOMMING In hierdie artikel word verslag gedoen van 'n deduktiewe ontleding van 'n versameling Jakkals-en-Wolfverhale met betrekking tot struktuurelemente, strukturele patrone, variasiepatrone en inhoud volgens die beginsels van strukturalistiese narratologie. Die struktuurmodelle wat reeds deur ander navorsers in volks- en trieksterverhale uitgewys is, is ook aan hierdie korpus getoets. Daar is bevind dat Afrikaanse Jakkals-en-Wolfverhale ooreenstem met die universele patrone van trieksterverhale. Dit het ook geblyk dat die held in hierdie verhale bepaal word deur die oogpunt waaruit die gebeure beskou word. Jakkals is onder meer 'n metafoor van die triekster wat in 'n sosiaal beter posisie geplaas word deur die feit dat hy slim is en daarin kan slaag om die fisiek sterkere te uitoorlê. Daar is bevind dat die struktuur van die Afrikaanse Jakkals-en-Wolfverhale in sekere opsigte uniek is - 'n universele verlede, unieke karakters, 'n beperkte ruimte, 'n verteller-fokalisator, gebeure waarvan die episodes op mekaar volg, episodes wat ingebed is in 'n handelingsreeks en vertellers wat ingestel is op die kindergehoor. Dit is duidelik dat die struktuur en algemene inhoud van Afrikaanse Jakkals-en-Wolftrieksterverhale dinamies gebly het. 'n Wyer soektog behoort geloods te word om meer volksverhale, in veral die Suid-Afrikaanse konteks, wetenskaplik te versamel sodat meer verhale met mekaar vergelyk kan word ten einde tot 'n algemener gevolgtrekking te kan kom oor die struktuur en patroonmatig-hede in Suid-Afrikaanse volksverhale. Trefwoorde: aktante, dieptestruktuur, narratief, ontleding, patroonmatighede, triekster, trieksterverhaal, struktuur, struktuurelemente, volksverhaal ABSTRACT This article explores characteristic or repetitive pattern formations in the structure and general content of selected Afrikaans Jackal and Wolf trickster stories. By using a specific methodology, a corpus of stories was first selected, followed by a comparative analysis of the different stories. An analysis of repetitive patterns necessitates both syntagmatic and paradigmatic readings of the stories, as demonstrated in both Bremond's (1977) model, dealing with the action in stories and Greimas's (1966) actantial model focusing on different functions of characters. By utilising these analytic models, the methods of storytelling and foregrounding, as well as the meaning of these relationships and of the stories as a whole could be discerned. Pre-existing structural readings of the folk tale, the trickster tale and Jackal and Wolf stories also added value to the research. Some examples from the corpus of stories are provided to illustrate and substantiate findings. The corpus consisted of sound recordings by a project team led by Du Plessis (1987:814), recordings made by the researcher in the Murraysburg district in June 2010, Jackal and Wolf stories told by Dana Niehaus (2011), and stories from the volumes Die Kaskenades van Jakkals en Wolf (Rousseau, 2011), Die Mooiste Afrikaanse Sprokies (Grobbelaar & Verster, 2007), and Jakkals en Wolf (Grobbelaar & Verster, 2011). Both Bremond's action logic and Greimas's actantial model proved valuable in describing the structure of the stories and the unique formations of patterns that emerged from the analysis. For example, the actantial roles (Greimas) in Jackal and Wolf stories represented indications of an underlying deep structure informing countless re-telling of the different stories. Regarding the structure of events (Bremond), it was noticeable that in some of the stories, the episodes followed one another successively, while in others the episodes were embedded in previous episodes. A comparative reading of the Jackal and Wolf trickster stories revealed significant relationships between the structural elements of the different stories. For example, the stories all take place in a universal past; there are usually three characters in these stories, but usually it is only Wolf that is defeated. The characters are mostly male, and the few female characters present in the stories remain in the background. The characters constantly find themselves in a space thatfluctuates between a domesticated and an undomesticated world. The stories are mainly told by an external narrator-focaliser who narrates and observes and who is not limited to a particular position. These stories are most often told by male storytellers. Many of the storytellers are highly attuned to the audience and they often adapt the stories to suit their target audience (South African children). Many of the storytellers engage the audience by making use of ingenious techniques; for example, by directly involving the audience in dialogue or offering moral lessons. It clearly emerged that the identity of the hero in these stories depends on the perspective from which the events are considered. The investigated corpus shows that the stories can be described as trickster tales in more ways than one, and that they follow the general patterns of trickster tales. It is also clear that the identified structures remain dynamic. Keywords: actants, analysis, deep structure, folktale, narrative, patterning, structure, structural elements, trickster, trickster story
期刊介绍:
Die Tydskrif vir Geesteswetenskappe word gewy aan die publikasie van oorspronklike navorsing en oorsigartikels in die teologie, kuns en kulturele, sosiale, ekonomiese en opvoedkundige wetenskappe, sowel as aan boekbesprekings.