Can contrast between forest and adjacent open habitat explain the edge effects on plant diversity?

Abstract Forest edges are key features in human-dominated landscape. Located between forest and non-forest habitats, edges induce biotic and abiotic changes, which may have profound consequences on vegetation diversity. Recent studies suggest the importance of different edge types in the modulation of edge-related responses. However, edge effect on the spatial dynamic of vegetation, from forest to non-forest habitats, remains unclear. Our aim was to compare the species richness and diversity of vegetation communities between forest and open habitats with their respective edges, in high-contrast versus low-contrast situations. The degree of contrast was defined according to the disturbance regimen of non-forest habitats. We surveyed vascular vegetation along transects in forest and open habitats and in their respective edges, in three regions of France. We showed that edge effects occur on plant diversity, whatever the region, but asymmetrically. Edge effect tends to be greater on the open side than on the forest side of the border. Species richness and diversity were generally higher in open edge than in open habitat, whereas no significant difference was observed between forest edge and forest habitat, whatever the contrast situation encountered. This study shows that the edge effects detected along a forest–edge–exterior habitat gradient may depend in large part on the disturbance regimen in open habitats as well as the vegetation pool size. We highlighted the need to carefully consider the edge types, e.g. their contrast with adjoining non-forest habitat, in further studies to identify the relevant factors and mechanisms behind edge-related response patterns of biodiversity in human-dominated landscapes.