Three-dimensional in vitro measurement of initial forces and moments acting on maxillary canine teeth using various Class II elastic configurations with a straight archwire fixed lingual appliance

Purpose

The presented study utilized an in vitro Orthodontic SIMulator (OSIM) to study how Class II elastic configuration effects the forces and moments acting on maxillary canine teeth when using a straight archwire fixed lingual appliance.

Materials and methods

Maxillary in-Ovation L self-ligating brackets were bonded to anatomically shaped stainless steel teeth on OSIM. A 0.016″ × 0.022″ stainless steel straight lingual archwire was used to provide a relevant arch shape and to position simulated teeth in a passive position. A mandibular typodont was positioned above the OSIM arch in a half cusp Class II malocclusion to serve as attachment points for elastics. Four different elastic configurations were tested: 1. maxillary–buccal to mandibular-buccal; 2. maxillary–lingual to mandibular–lingual; 3. maxillary–buccal to mandibular–lingual; 4. maxillary–lingual to mandibular–buccal. A new 4.5 oz 3/16″ elastic (n = 40 per configuration) was attached to the maxillary canine and mandibular first molar teeth for each trial. Forces and moments at the maxillary canine simulated center of resistance were considered. ANOVA was used to assess the effect of elastic configuration, and pairwise comparisons using Bonferroni correction were conducted to investigate configuration differences.

Results

Of the thirty-four pairwise comparisons, only two were statistically insignificant. Configurations 1, 2, and 4 were found to produce over 1 N of force in the desired distal direction, whereas Configuration 3 was significantly lower at 0.65 N.

Conclusions

Overall, the configuration of Class II elastics had a significant effect on forces and moments at maxillary canine teeth for a simulated straight archwire fixed lingual appliance.