古特拉克:克劳兰的圣人。Roberts Jane和Thacker Alan编辑。240毫米。Pp xlvi+594,图64,列53。肖恩·泰亚斯,多宁顿,2020年。isbn 9781907730818(hbk)、978190773082(pbk)。45英镑(hbk),28英镑(pbk)。

IF 0.2 4区 社会学 0 HUMANITIES, MULTIDISCIPLINARY
J. Blair
{"title":"古特拉克:克劳兰的圣人。Roberts Jane和Thacker Alan编辑。240毫米。Pp xlvi+594,图64,列53。肖恩·泰亚斯,多宁顿,2020年。isbn 9781907730818(hbk)、978190773082(pbk)。45英镑(hbk),28英镑(pbk)。","authors":"J. Blair","doi":"10.1017/s0003581521000184","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"vived to be excavated is a complex settlement comprising large circular houses and more irregular structures that infill the spaces between the round houses, the broch and the surrounding rampart. In the Middle Iron Age most of the houses were wheelhouses. Wheelhouses, like brochs, are a regionally distinctive tradition of stone-walled roundhouses found in Atlantic Scotland. They are characterised by a peripheral area around a central open space that is divided into rooms defined by stone-built piers that protrude from the inner wall face. They are architecturally sophisticated structures but, unlike the brochs, the sophistication is only visible to those allowed to enter the structure. The presence of the circular houses distinguishes the village at Scatness from the well-known broch villages of Orkney where the constraints of circularity were discarded, and it confirms the pattern observed at nearby Jarlshof where a very similar, though much smaller, broch village of circular houses was excavated. The presence of a substantial village reflects the agricultural fertility of this district of south Shetland where the windblown sands encourage arable agriculture. They do not seem to be a feature of many of the Shetland brochs, though most of these brochs are surrounded by additional boundaries and the occasional external structure is not unusual. It is difficult to make an accurate estimate, given the amount of destruction caused by the airport road, but a village of at least sixteen separate buildings could have been present in the area surrounding the broch. Not all of the structures were domestic dwellings occupied by a household; structure , a rectangular building attached to a wheelhouse, was clearly providing specialist facilities for the adjacent household. The broch itself seems to be partially restructured, possibly late in this phase, but remains the focal point of the settlement with an entrance facing west. The site provides an extremely valuable sequence that demonstrates the development of wheelhouses from the last centuries BC through the first millennium AD, and provides important new information on how they were used. The early wheelhouses have isolated rectangular stone piers separate from the internal walls of the house. Close observation of the wear on the architectural stones reveals that the narrow gap between the pier and the wall was used as a doorway that allowed movement between the peripheral rooms. These movements may later have been regarded as problematic and the spaces were blocked up; later houses had long piers that ran up to the surrounding walls. The final wheelhouses were much smaller structures withmassive triangular piers fully bedded into the house walls. It is clear that early wheelhouses had an upper floor and though in some cases this may have been a mezzanine gallery in others it is argued that the first floor spanned the interior and was likely to have been the main living space. The later wheelhouses are structurally much more secure buildings, but the reduction in size clearly indicates a shift in the social significance of the house interior. The large early wheelhouses provided an arena for social interaction within the household and between the household and visitors, which simply wouldn’t have been possible in the later smaller structures. This change can be related to the increasing importance of material culture and personal ornament in the later periods that culminates in the Pictish period. The finds from the site demonstrate the important connections that Shetland had with areas further to the south; important connections with the Pictish kingdom are emphatically demonstrated by the discovery of the Scatness bear: a strikingly lifelike carving of a bear done in a typically Pictish style. It is carved on an orthostat placed at the end of a pier on one of the wheelhouses. Much could and should be written about this carving; the style of the art, the symbolism of the animal, the selection of the stone, the original location and the way it was treated at the end of the life of the house. However, it is just one of several pieces of art and one of a multitude of finds from this exceptional site. The volumes published provide the end of the beginning of the work at Scatness. My review is limited and has had to ignore many important and fascinating aspects of the archaeology. The site itself has yet to be consolidated and laid out to the public, and there is still much work to be done to appreciate fully the significance of this monument and the work that has been carried out and documented here.","PeriodicalId":44308,"journal":{"name":"Antiquaries Journal","volume":"101 1","pages":"437 - 439"},"PeriodicalIF":0.2000,"publicationDate":"2021-07-26","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://sci-hub-pdf.com/10.1017/s0003581521000184","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Guthlac: Crowland’s saint. Edited by Roberts Jane and Thacker Alan. 240mm. Pp xlvi + 594, 64 figs, 53 col pls. Shaun Tyas, Donington, 2020. isbn 9781907730818 (hbk), 9781907730832 (pbk). £45 (hbk), £28 (pbk).\",\"authors\":\"J. Blair\",\"doi\":\"10.1017/s0003581521000184\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"vived to be excavated is a complex settlement comprising large circular houses and more irregular structures that infill the spaces between the round houses, the broch and the surrounding rampart. In the Middle Iron Age most of the houses were wheelhouses. Wheelhouses, like brochs, are a regionally distinctive tradition of stone-walled roundhouses found in Atlantic Scotland. They are characterised by a peripheral area around a central open space that is divided into rooms defined by stone-built piers that protrude from the inner wall face. They are architecturally sophisticated structures but, unlike the brochs, the sophistication is only visible to those allowed to enter the structure. The presence of the circular houses distinguishes the village at Scatness from the well-known broch villages of Orkney where the constraints of circularity were discarded, and it confirms the pattern observed at nearby Jarlshof where a very similar, though much smaller, broch village of circular houses was excavated. The presence of a substantial village reflects the agricultural fertility of this district of south Shetland where the windblown sands encourage arable agriculture. They do not seem to be a feature of many of the Shetland brochs, though most of these brochs are surrounded by additional boundaries and the occasional external structure is not unusual. It is difficult to make an accurate estimate, given the amount of destruction caused by the airport road, but a village of at least sixteen separate buildings could have been present in the area surrounding the broch. Not all of the structures were domestic dwellings occupied by a household; structure , a rectangular building attached to a wheelhouse, was clearly providing specialist facilities for the adjacent household. The broch itself seems to be partially restructured, possibly late in this phase, but remains the focal point of the settlement with an entrance facing west. The site provides an extremely valuable sequence that demonstrates the development of wheelhouses from the last centuries BC through the first millennium AD, and provides important new information on how they were used. The early wheelhouses have isolated rectangular stone piers separate from the internal walls of the house. Close observation of the wear on the architectural stones reveals that the narrow gap between the pier and the wall was used as a doorway that allowed movement between the peripheral rooms. These movements may later have been regarded as problematic and the spaces were blocked up; later houses had long piers that ran up to the surrounding walls. The final wheelhouses were much smaller structures withmassive triangular piers fully bedded into the house walls. It is clear that early wheelhouses had an upper floor and though in some cases this may have been a mezzanine gallery in others it is argued that the first floor spanned the interior and was likely to have been the main living space. The later wheelhouses are structurally much more secure buildings, but the reduction in size clearly indicates a shift in the social significance of the house interior. The large early wheelhouses provided an arena for social interaction within the household and between the household and visitors, which simply wouldn’t have been possible in the later smaller structures. This change can be related to the increasing importance of material culture and personal ornament in the later periods that culminates in the Pictish period. The finds from the site demonstrate the important connections that Shetland had with areas further to the south; important connections with the Pictish kingdom are emphatically demonstrated by the discovery of the Scatness bear: a strikingly lifelike carving of a bear done in a typically Pictish style. It is carved on an orthostat placed at the end of a pier on one of the wheelhouses. Much could and should be written about this carving; the style of the art, the symbolism of the animal, the selection of the stone, the original location and the way it was treated at the end of the life of the house. However, it is just one of several pieces of art and one of a multitude of finds from this exceptional site. The volumes published provide the end of the beginning of the work at Scatness. My review is limited and has had to ignore many important and fascinating aspects of the archaeology. The site itself has yet to be consolidated and laid out to the public, and there is still much work to be done to appreciate fully the significance of this monument and the work that has been carried out and documented here.\",\"PeriodicalId\":44308,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Antiquaries Journal\",\"volume\":\"101 1\",\"pages\":\"437 - 439\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.2000,\"publicationDate\":\"2021-07-26\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"https://sci-hub-pdf.com/10.1017/s0003581521000184\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Antiquaries Journal\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.1017/s0003581521000184\",\"RegionNum\":4,\"RegionCategory\":\"社会学\",\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"0\",\"JCRName\":\"HUMANITIES, MULTIDISCIPLINARY\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Antiquaries Journal","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1017/s0003581521000184","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"社会学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"HUMANITIES, MULTIDISCIPLINARY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

即将挖掘的是一个复杂的定居点,包括大型圆形房屋和更多不规则的结构,这些结构填充了圆形房屋、胸管和周围城墙之间的空间。在铁器时代中期,大多数房屋都是驾驶室。驾驶室,就像驾驶室一样,是在大西洋苏格兰发现的石墙圆屋的地区特色传统。它们的特点是围绕中央开放空间的外围区域,该开放空间被划分为由石头建造的桥墩定义的房间,这些桥墩从内墙表面突出。它们在建筑上是复杂的结构,但与廊桥不同的是,只有那些获准进入建筑的人才能看到这种复杂。圆形房屋的存在将Scatness的村庄与奥克尼著名的胸针村庄区分开来,在奥克尼,圆形的限制被抛弃了,它证实了在附近的Jarlshof观察到的模式,那里有一个非常相似的胸针村庄,尽管小得多,圆形房屋被挖掘出来。一个庞大的村庄的存在反映了南设得兰地区的农业肥沃程度,那里的风沙鼓励了可耕地农业。它们似乎并不是许多设得兰群岛的特征,尽管这些群岛中的大多数都被额外的边界包围着,偶尔的外部结构并不罕见。考虑到机场道路造成的破坏程度,很难做出准确的估计,但在胸章周围地区可能存在一个至少有16座独立建筑的村庄。并不是所有的建筑都是家庭住宅;结构是一个矩形的建筑,与驾驶室相连,显然是为邻近的家庭提供专业设施。胸针本身似乎部分重组,可能在这一阶段的后期,但仍然是解决的焦点,入口朝西。该遗址提供了一个极具价值的序列,展示了从公元前最后一个世纪到公元第一个千年的驾驶室的发展,并提供了关于如何使用它们的重要新信息。早期的驾驶室有孤立的矩形石墩,与房子的内墙分开。仔细观察建筑石材的磨损,可以发现桥墩和墙壁之间的狭窄缝隙被用作门道,允许在周边房间之间移动。这些活动后来可能被认为是有问题的,空间被堵塞了;后来的房子有长长的桥墩,一直延伸到周围的墙壁上。最后的驾驶室结构要小得多,巨大的三角形桥墩完全嵌入房屋墙壁。很明显,早期的驾驶室有一个上层,虽然在某些情况下,这可能是一个夹层画廊,但在其他情况下,有人认为第一层横跨内部,很可能是主要的生活空间。后来的驾驶室在结构上更加安全,但尺寸的缩小清楚地表明了房屋内部社会意义的转变。早期的大型驾驶室为家庭内部以及家庭和访客之间的社会互动提供了一个场所,这在后来较小的结构中根本不可能实现。这种变化可能与后期物质文化和个人装饰的重要性日益增加有关,并在皮克特时期达到高潮。该遗址的发现表明,设得兰群岛与更远的南部地区有着重要的联系;与皮克特王国的重要联系通过斯卡内斯熊的发现得到了有力的证明:这是一个以典型的皮克特风格雕刻的栩栩如生的熊。它被雕刻在一个舵手室码头末端的直尺上。关于这个雕刻,可以也应该写很多东西;艺术风格、动物的象征意义、石头的选择、原始位置以及在房子生命结束时对它的处理方式。然而,它只是几件艺术品中的一件,也是这个特殊地点众多发现中的一件。出版的卷提供了在Scatness开始工作的结束。我的评论是有限的,不得不忽略考古学的许多重要和迷人的方面。该遗址本身尚未得到巩固,并向公众展示,为了充分认识这座纪念碑的重要性,以及在这里进行和记录的工作,还有很多工作要做。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
Guthlac: Crowland’s saint. Edited by Roberts Jane and Thacker Alan. 240mm. Pp xlvi + 594, 64 figs, 53 col pls. Shaun Tyas, Donington, 2020. isbn 9781907730818 (hbk), 9781907730832 (pbk). £45 (hbk), £28 (pbk).
vived to be excavated is a complex settlement comprising large circular houses and more irregular structures that infill the spaces between the round houses, the broch and the surrounding rampart. In the Middle Iron Age most of the houses were wheelhouses. Wheelhouses, like brochs, are a regionally distinctive tradition of stone-walled roundhouses found in Atlantic Scotland. They are characterised by a peripheral area around a central open space that is divided into rooms defined by stone-built piers that protrude from the inner wall face. They are architecturally sophisticated structures but, unlike the brochs, the sophistication is only visible to those allowed to enter the structure. The presence of the circular houses distinguishes the village at Scatness from the well-known broch villages of Orkney where the constraints of circularity were discarded, and it confirms the pattern observed at nearby Jarlshof where a very similar, though much smaller, broch village of circular houses was excavated. The presence of a substantial village reflects the agricultural fertility of this district of south Shetland where the windblown sands encourage arable agriculture. They do not seem to be a feature of many of the Shetland brochs, though most of these brochs are surrounded by additional boundaries and the occasional external structure is not unusual. It is difficult to make an accurate estimate, given the amount of destruction caused by the airport road, but a village of at least sixteen separate buildings could have been present in the area surrounding the broch. Not all of the structures were domestic dwellings occupied by a household; structure , a rectangular building attached to a wheelhouse, was clearly providing specialist facilities for the adjacent household. The broch itself seems to be partially restructured, possibly late in this phase, but remains the focal point of the settlement with an entrance facing west. The site provides an extremely valuable sequence that demonstrates the development of wheelhouses from the last centuries BC through the first millennium AD, and provides important new information on how they were used. The early wheelhouses have isolated rectangular stone piers separate from the internal walls of the house. Close observation of the wear on the architectural stones reveals that the narrow gap between the pier and the wall was used as a doorway that allowed movement between the peripheral rooms. These movements may later have been regarded as problematic and the spaces were blocked up; later houses had long piers that ran up to the surrounding walls. The final wheelhouses were much smaller structures withmassive triangular piers fully bedded into the house walls. It is clear that early wheelhouses had an upper floor and though in some cases this may have been a mezzanine gallery in others it is argued that the first floor spanned the interior and was likely to have been the main living space. The later wheelhouses are structurally much more secure buildings, but the reduction in size clearly indicates a shift in the social significance of the house interior. The large early wheelhouses provided an arena for social interaction within the household and between the household and visitors, which simply wouldn’t have been possible in the later smaller structures. This change can be related to the increasing importance of material culture and personal ornament in the later periods that culminates in the Pictish period. The finds from the site demonstrate the important connections that Shetland had with areas further to the south; important connections with the Pictish kingdom are emphatically demonstrated by the discovery of the Scatness bear: a strikingly lifelike carving of a bear done in a typically Pictish style. It is carved on an orthostat placed at the end of a pier on one of the wheelhouses. Much could and should be written about this carving; the style of the art, the symbolism of the animal, the selection of the stone, the original location and the way it was treated at the end of the life of the house. However, it is just one of several pieces of art and one of a multitude of finds from this exceptional site. The volumes published provide the end of the beginning of the work at Scatness. My review is limited and has had to ignore many important and fascinating aspects of the archaeology. The site itself has yet to be consolidated and laid out to the public, and there is still much work to be done to appreciate fully the significance of this monument and the work that has been carried out and documented here.
求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
Antiquaries Journal
Antiquaries Journal HUMANITIES, MULTIDISCIPLINARY-
CiteScore
0.60
自引率
0.00%
发文量
34
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信